Cow Flatulence No Longer a Laughing Matter

 

We all giggled, guffawed, or groaned at the Green New Deal’s line about cow flatulence causing the end of the world. We wiped up the coffee we had spewed over our phone or keyboard. Then we went about our lives as if this was not a clear and present danger.

Well, the dairy farmers of Wisconsin, the state built on (dairy cow) cheese and beer, are not laughing now. No farmer across this country should be in anything but full fight mode now. There is no flight option. John Hinderaker of PowerLine Blog has the story [emphasis added]:

The Green New Deal, and similar environmental initiatives, have little to do with the environment and much to do with the Left’s desire to control every aspect of our lives. Because everything we do, beginning with breathing, involves emission of carbon dioxide or other “greenhouse gases.” AOC’s Green New Deal specifically proposed, among other things, that all air travel be banned and that all cows be done away with because they produce methane.

…Today’s decision from the Minnesota Court of Appeals (which may have been justified by a completely different issue that the Court addressed) should be a wake-up call to all Americans that liberals aren’t kidding when they say they want to prevent us from eating meat, or drinking milk or consuming other dairy products, in the name of “climate change.” The battle has been joined, and if normal Americans don’t get engaged, the Left will win. As they did today.

Read the rest at the link. The case is In the Matter of the Decision on the Need for an Environmental Impact Statement for the Proposed Daley Farms of Lewiston, LLP – 2018 Dairy Expansion Utica Township. While no federal court is bound by this case, count on this being cited as persuasive authority in every state court across the country where Lab Coat Leftist professional litigants spot a judge sympathetic to the fundamental transformation of America.

Published in Environment
This post was promoted to the Main Feed by a Ricochet Editor at the recommendation of Ricochet members. Like this post? Want to comment? Join Ricochet’s community of conservatives and be part of the conversation. Join Ricochet for Free.

There are 35 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. MichaelKennedy Inactive
    MichaelKennedy
    @MichaelKennedy

    Clifford A. Brown (View Comment):
    President Trump is the first in a long time to take rolling back the regulatory state seriously, but is limited by the bad laws the legislative geniuses Ryan and McConnell did nothing to correct. Unless I missed something.

    There is a huge industry living off these regulations.  Much of the frantic opposition to Trump is funded by these “green” (the color of money) corporations.   Think about windmills.  What is the cost of the subsidies ?  In the days when I was a high income professional, these were recommended as tax shelters and the economics were explained, at least in part.

    This is big business. Sure there are crazy shock troops but there is also big money involved.

    • #31
  2. Clifford A. Brown Member
    Clifford A. Brown
    @CliffordBrown

    MichaelKennedy (View Comment):

    Clifford A. Brown (View Comment):
    President Trump is the first in a long time to take rolling back the regulatory state seriously, but is limited by the bad laws the legislative geniuses Ryan and McConnell did nothing to correct. Unless I missed something.

    There is a huge industry living off these regulations. Much of the frantic opposition to Trump is funded by these “green” (the color of money) corporations. Think about windmills. What is the cost of the subsidies ? In the days when I was a high income professional, these were recommended as tax shelters and the economics were explained, at least in part.

    This is big business. Sure there are crazy shock troops but there is also big money involved.

    It is also a lot of smaller businesses. See the Southwest Center for Biological Diversity. Search on their name and you will get a series of court cases.

    • #32
  3. CarolJoy, Above Top Secret Coolidge
    CarolJoy, Above Top Secret
    @CarolJoy

    The Reticulator (View Comment):

    Clifford A. Brown (View Comment):

    Full Size Tabby (View Comment):

    This may be a little too lawyerly for this discussion (and its not directly related to cow farts), but the part of the case that really stuck out to me (a lawyer) is that the lawsuit that produced the decision was filed by a private entity having no particular connection to the farm, after the government had issued the required permits. If a person or business cannot rely on getting government permits as evidence that it has complied with the law, what’s the point of government permits?

    Allowing political activists to sue a person or a business because the activists don’t like the way the town handles the permitting process allows political activists to take people hostage in the activists’ fights with the government. In my political (not legal) opinion, if the activists think the town’s permitting process doesn’t take proper account of things that the activists think are required, the activists should be required to take that up with the town, not to use the residents and businesses as hostages.

    The problem is with the federal environmental laws, which empowered such professional litigants.

    And for that, I give partial blame to conservatives for not taking environmental issues seriously, thus leaving the field to the progressive left to design regulations that are as intrusive and burdensome as possible, designed to provide maximum employment and power for the ruling class.

    I am not sure the Republicans have done nothing. If it were not for the lowly rank and file Republicans in Calif, MTBE would have continued to be mandated as a 9% by volume addition to our gasoline supply.

    The end result would have been MTBE contamination of 50% of all Californian aquifers. This means not only a massive loss of possible drinking water sources, but farm irrigation sources as well. (One of the few good things about this carcinogen is that it can be detected by both taste and smell even when its proportions are 4 parts per billion. Even water with 4 ppb would end up tasting like kerosene. So there would  not be any way to use MTBE-tainted water for much of anything.)

    The R activists on this important issue were ridiculed by Diane Feinstein, and the Sierra Club. Luckily Gov Davis, a Democrat joined with the Republican activists  in having concerns. His Blue Ribbon Panel decreed that MTBE was all risk and no benefit, and the substance went out of the gas supply.

    Gov Davis paid with his career.

    It is true that many Republicans are now uneasy about talking about environmental issues. But Republicans raise their families and desire a  healthy environment freed from pollution, just as Dems do. We need a party platform on the issue.

    • #33
  4. CarolJoy, Above Top Secret Coolidge
    CarolJoy, Above Top Secret
    @CarolJoy

    Fake John/Jane Galt (View Comment):

    We need to take AOC and the Democrat POTUS candidates seriously. Why we find them funny serious people spending serious money has decided that they have tapped into America’s id and plan to ride it and their corrupt system right over all that oppose them.

    This one compendium shows exactly how funny they are. But you are correct: we need to take them seriously, even when they spout off about the planet ending in12 minutes or twelve years or whatev’s.

    https://cei.org/blog/wrong-again-50-years-failed-eco-pocalyptic-predictions?fbclid=IwAR1RJPxjghAP4comfU0jt1jQXDHWzoc9v2ylSHwK0FgfDclcJtw0E_2jPOg

    • #34
  5. CarolJoy, Above Top Secret Coolidge
    CarolJoy, Above Top Secret
    @CarolJoy

    The Reticulator (View Comment):

    Section 16 in Utica Township, Winona County, eh? I see from my records that I rode past that operation two years and two weeks ago. I had started the day in Genoa WI and ended up in St. Charles MN, a ride of 81 miles, which may have been my longest for that year. It was about sundown when I got to Lewiston, where the Utica Township Hall is located. It was dark by the time I got to our motel in St. Charles, 11 miles away, even though I rode as fast as I could. So I’m sure I didn’t pay much attention to the Daley farm as I rode past. From Google Satellite View it looks like a big operation, but the extent of it may not be so visible from the road, anyway.

    By the way, the road through the Daleys’ farm happens to be US Highway 14, of Little House on the Prairie fame. Many of the Ingalls’ residences, from Little House in the Big Woods through the Banks of Plum Creek and on to The Long Winter, were located on or near present-day US-14.

    As to the case, I’m not a big fan of Environmental Impact Statements, because they allow too much room for arbitrariness and corruption.

    The issue of water pollution from concentrating a large dairy herd in one location is a legitimate concern, though, and is a legitimate subject of regulation. The issue of methane production is a little different, though. To the extent that cow methane becomes atmospheric methane, it doesn’t matter so much whether it all comes from one point source, a hundred point sources, or a million point sources.

    If the Daleys are going to increase their herd size, when all is said and done it will be at the cost of driving smaller dairy farmers out of business. That’s been the way agriculture has changed over the past 150 years or more. SNIP Those who don’t get big will get out. So if the Daleys concentrate 4000 more cows in their central operation, roughly 4000 other cows will no longer be producing methane at their current locations. SNIP

    BTW, I have relatives who are dairy farmers in Minnesota, though not near Lewiston. It’s not easy for them to cope with these trends.

    A CA state law was passed that cows must be allowed X amount of time out in the field each day. Some of the more noteworthy families in the org dairy industry in Marin began writing letters to the editor about how  their pampered cows did not like being forced out into 38 degree sleet storms in  winter, or blisteringly hot 102 % days in  summer. (Cows in the org dairy movement in Marin are as pampered as my household pets.)

    The farmers’ rationale was not considered important of course. Even though that rationale was based on the clear common sense requests of the cows themselves!

     

    • #35
Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.