10 Types of Social Media Commenters

 

I opened a Facebook account years ago in order to keep up with family living in various places across the country. It’ll be fun, they said. And at first, it was. Pictures, events, recipes and everyone’s morning coffee have been shared on this venue, for which I am appreciative. It’s gotten pretty dicey at times and I’ve had to remind myself why I am on social media in the first place.

I often wondered why it changed so much but then realized it’s because the world we live in has. We’ve changed with it. Things that matter to us are all plastered on there and it’s no longer about sharing thoughts in our own words. It’s now full of memes, GIFs, political articles, competition, and memories of long ago that we share again in the hopes of remembering what was.

Then I started a Twitter account and kept it private until about a year ago. I wanted to just lay low and see how it was to interact with mostly strangers. Way out of my comfort zone, but I’ve grown to appreciate many in that community of people. There are some very smart people who have gained a following and use it fairly wisely. I use social media more than anyone else in the family, including the teens. They actually see it for what it is and if they want to connect with friends, they do so with texts and phone calls. I could learn a lesson from them.

I have spent many hours on social media, some for work, some in my friends bubble on Facebook and eventually outside of it on Twitter, quietly observing other users mostly in the writing arena in order to get a feel for what it would be like to be a writer whose work would be critiqued, commented on, and hopefully even found to be useful. I’m actually very impressed with how a few of my favorite writers handle (or don’t handle) comments from the masses.

I’ve been afraid to put myself out there in this day and age where everyone gets their news at the speed of light, and in turn can have an opinion on everything from politics to parenting and even some things that have no consequence to one’s existence. This is assuming, of course, that I get a following outside of my bubble.

Let’s be honest; sometimes the comment section on a post is like a car wreck you can’t take your eyes off of. Some of them even make us uncomfortable, because now we are faced with the fact that not everyone sees things the way we do. Sometimes people sit in their own truth, which is the furthest thing from the actual truth. Other times we are closer to agreeing on a issue than we think. It’s been a fascinating year and here are my general observations of the top 10 types of social media commenters, in no particular order.

The Headline Commenter: Many people who comment on news sites I follow read the headlines of articles but never the actual article. They are looking for something to find fault with and the quickest way to do so is to pick a controversial headline, type something irrelevant about the article, and get into conversations with complete strangers about a topic they know nothing about, yet apparently have strong feelings about the seven bolded words that lead up to it. You can figure out who has and who hasn’t read the article as long as you have.

The All Caps Commenter: These folks often get chided for using all caps in a conversation as if their caps lock is stuck. It’s usually older people who have a blank avi (they were called eggs on Twitter, but now they’ve changed the silhouette of the blank avatar to an actual person) and think they have wisdom that no one else has so in order to get their point across the caps come out. I’m all for respecting the elders; as a matter of fact, I pretty much am one now. But nothing says “I’m shouting at you on the internet” quite like the all-caps thing. It also doesn’t make your statement more truthful when you use them. My personal exception to this rule is a cousin of my dad’s, who told me before we started communicating on Facebook that she always types in all caps. No matter what. It’s her signature and I find it amusing.

The Snarky Commenter: I’m all for a little sarcasm. We can’t be serious all the time. There are some really quick-witted people who can comment about a topic and force us to see the humor and ridiculousness in it. I appreciate those people because I am one of them. When there is very little logic being used on one side of an argument, sometimes you just need to point it out in that way. It probably makes the other side more angry, but if they had an actual argument to begin with that wouldn’t be so easy.

The Parroting Commenter: Using phrases like “we the people,” “deplorable,” and “the new normal,” the parroter peppers their comments with catch phrases from talk radio and/or news outlets. They also use the words “global,” “social,” “misogynist,” and “Hitler” a lot. You can usually tell which side of the political spectrum these people are on and how disconnected from actual facts they might be. They mostly let their feelings rule them. Also see: trolls.

The Cursing Commenter: This one drops the f-bomb often, sometimes in abbreviations and acronyms you might have to look up in the urban dictionary to figure out, and those words are becoming more common than the word “the” in a sentence. It used to offend me, but now it’s part of the everyday language on social media so I’m not as taken aback as I was a year ago. Not my style, but it works for some, especially the younger writers. A friend once referred to Twitter as the bathroom wall of social media. I can’t say I don’t agree with that.

The Busy Body Commenter: Because I’ve been a wife for the last 26 years, a Christian, a conservative, a stay-at-home-mom, a homeschool mom, and the furthest thing from a feminist one can get, my life is fodder for controversy. The hilarious thing about it all is that it’s absolutely none of anyone else’s business how I conduct my life. It’s of no consequence to yours and your life is for you to live. Social media has given a voice to anyone with a keyboard and those voices are many times used to pass judgment on our fellow human beings for the absolute dumbest things. Guess what? It will never change my mind to know how some stranger on the internet feels about me teaching my kids at home. Thanks for your concern, though.

The Data Commenter: I, too, know how to Google and look stuff up. These folks post links to charts and data or articles from HuffPo to support their points, but they don’t make an actual point first. They just post the first wiki article that pops up and then expect you read it. If you want to have a conversation, use your own words and thoughts, not someone else’s. It’s pretty simple. Maybe comment first about why you chose the thing you are posting so it can seem relevant.

The Text Commenter: I get there are just 140 characters in a tweet, and now 280 for the select few. But really, the word “you” has just two more letters than “U” and it’s pretty easy to type “to” instead of “2,” unless you are confused about to, too, and two. Type the complete words out and just do another tweet if you run out of room. We shouldn’t have to try to decode the meaning of your post so please just stop. I don’t even read those anymore. But please do keep using emojis. They are useful many times; especially the eyeroll one.

The Logical Fallacy Commenter: These are the people who took debate in high school or read some books on logic and want to impart their wisdom to us all. They point to generalizations, strawmen, red herrings, and the like, after which Google gets a workout from those in the conversation who have no clue what any of that means. My rule, always, is to stay on topic, know your audience, and don’t get personal. That way I won’t have to tell you that you are using an ad hominem. (I was a debate teacher, so….)

And lastly,

The Troll Commenter: They can be spotted a mile away. Many on Twitter are bots now. They are programmed to respond instantly and are never nice or have anything useful to say. They want a response as instantly as they gave theirs. It is the troll’s desire to get attention, even if it’s bad attention. They love to be combative, never stay on topic, are rarely logical, and comment just to get a rise out of people. They are commonly accused of living in their parent’s basements. Don’t feed the trolls.

I’m positive I’ve left someone out. Like the people who just want to make sense of it all. Who are honestly sharing their perspectives on a topic and would like to know more about how other people are thinking and have a legitimate conversation. We are living in a rapidly changing world because of social media. It’s a blessing and a curse. Some just want to reach out to know they aren’t alone trying to navigate a world that makes no sense at times. When I can, I want to be the commenter that lets them know they aren’t. We need more of those.

Published in General
This post was promoted to the Main Feed by a Ricochet Editor at the recommendation of Ricochet members. Like this post? Want to comment? Join Ricochet’s community of conservatives and be part of the conversation. Join Ricochet for Free.

There are 38 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    SkipSul (View Comment):
    The Pouncer – Similar to the Logical Fallacy and Troll commenters, these people will seize upon one particular point, no matter how minor or even relevant, and then beat on you, hammer and tongs, to recant your entire post because you were (or so they say) entirely wrong on that point. No matter how much you defer, deflect, or ignore them, they will magnify their grievance to the point where it attains critical mass and sucks all the life out of whatever discussion you wanted to have.

    The Authority – Now you’ve done it, you’ve attracted the attention of the “expert” on whatever topic you’ve posted. They’ll shred your entire post with mockery and derision.

    The Ardent – Similar to The Authority, except that they will couch everything in terms of moral castigation instead of factual. You are not merely mistaken, you have sinned against whatever authority they claim and are a very bad person, possibly not even human.

    Hammer and Tongs LOL!! Let’s add these to the list.

    • #31
  2. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    La Tapada (View Comment):
    I have concluded that much on the Internet and social media it just plain obnoxious nagging: “10 things you must do,” “15 things you should never do.” I have an acquaintance who appears to have recovered from cancer by becoming a vegetarian (which I appreciate and am glad for). Now all her posts are about how benighted the rest of us are for eating conventionally.

    My brother and sister-in-law who live abroad recently spent a week with us in North Carolina. My sister-in-law told me that she wanted to challenge my 28-yr-old son on Facebook. He says he doesn’t believe in God and frequently posts on Facebook that “believers in God are idiots.” (I believe he is dealing with drug addiction and bipolar disorder.) I told her I had decided not to respond to him “in public.” (I think people forget that challenging others on social media is challenging them in public. I think we forget that responding on Facebook is not the same as personally spending time with someone, conveying the fact that we love them, and privately engaging them about an issue.)

    It’s memes, memories, and mayhem. And occasional laughter. Which is why I stay. I hope your son gets the personal attention he needs when the time is right. Bless you.

    • #32
  3. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    Doctor Robert (View Comment):
    Laura, I joined FB in 2010 to keep in touch with all the people in my life simultaneously. Have been off it for two years.

    At first it was fun but it became tiresome and then annoying. A crazy sister used FB to stalk my cousin, the discussions of politics and especially the GIFs and memes are all so pointless.

    But the thing that really pissed me off and led to my leaving was all the liberal people who put up the French tricolor as their photo on the day after the Bataclan atrocity. My last post on FB was to the effect of, your putting up the tricolor is meaningless. If you care about muslim terror, stop voting for politicians who facilitate it.

    I don’t miss FB a bit. Not one tiny bit.

    My 23 year old daughter completely deleted her Facebook for many of these same reasons. I never saw a profile filter for Vegas. Not that I would use it, anyway. My favorite posts recently are, “If you are a ______ voter, unfriend me.” My response: You know how to unfriend people, right? I’m about out of there as well.

    • #33
  4. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    Merrijane (View Comment):
    This is actually why I like Ricochet. People are generally nicer and engaging and take the time to think things out and respond to you intelligently.

    YES!!!

    • #34
  5. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    OkieSailor (View Comment):
     

    Homeschooling is a lifestyle choice, not for everyone. It has many rewards though. For one thing it enabled our kids to complete their coursework in half days enabling them time to pursue their lifetime interests at a young age. I wouldn’t trade it for the gold standard of private education. Nor would I disparage anyone who chooses differently.

    I am of the exact mindset. I love your story and I appreciate you sharing it here. Thank you and Mrs. OS for committing to it and setting a path for others to follow. I’m on my last year- 18 years. I now have to figure out what I will be when I grow up. :)

    • #35
  6. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    ShawnB (View Comment):
    Sadly, I was at times some of these people when I was on facebook. I ditched it a while ago and became a happier person. But these “10 types” seem right on. Nice article.

    Thanks for reading, Shawn!

    • #36
  7. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    Merrijane (View Comment):
    I feel like sharing this video here would be appropriate. Cracks me up every time: Facebook Friends Song.

    …and we’re also on Twitter HAHAHAHA!!

    • #37
  8. Laura Gadbery Coolidge
    Laura Gadbery
    @LauraGadbery

    Jason Rudert (View Comment):

    Laura Gadbery: I’m positive I’ve left someone out.

    Category Eleven, checking in.

    I laughed so loud I scared the dog.

    • #38
Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.