Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Guns Don’t Kill Children … Swimming Pools and Cars Do.
This piece from Reason is a good primer on the lack of a market for “smart-guns,” and covers both the technical challenges in making them and — more interestingly — the lack of demand for them. Is this because gun owners are callous, child-hating fanatics? No: it’s just that firearms don’t kill that many kids.
Inspired by the piece, I took a gander through some of the CDC data for fatal injuries to children between the ages of 0 and 14 years in the United States between 2004 and 2010 (the most recent period listed). Here are some relevant data for the an average year during that period:
- 6,327 children were killed through injury (all causes, both intentional and non-intentional).
- 1,890 were killed through unintentional cars accidents (30 percent of total).
- 749 were killed by unintentional drowning (12 percent of total).
- 45 were killed by unintentional use of firearms (less than 1 percent of total).
- 378 were killed by all uses of firearms (6 percent of total). This would include all child suicides and homicides, as well as accidents.
(It should go without saying — though I’ll say it regardless — that every one of those deaths is a tragedy and that I can only imagine what the parents must be going through.)
So, the fact that there isn’t much of a market for smart-guns seems to be — in part — informed by gun owners’ understanding that there isn’t a great deal of need for them, especially in comparison to other threats to their kids’ safety and lives.
We all have a natural tendency to focus on obviously scary threats in comparison to others: sharks, for example, are way more frightening than moose, despite the fact that the latter are far more dangerous to human life. This isn’t surprising, nor irrational. It just means people aren’t familiar with the data and are letting their limbic system do their thinking for them, which is what we all do unless pushed and/or presented really hard evidence.
So, for God’s sake, buckle your kids up, drive safe, teach them to swim early and how to be smart around water. And yes, teach them to be safe are firearms and secure them from unauthorized use, too.
And watch out for moose.
Published in Guns
Dan,
I think this is quite adequate and usually civil liability would be part of the package. Of course, the hysterics who populate the anti-gun world won’t sit still for this simple but effective approach.
Meanwhile, as the debate is highjacked by the left’s hysteria we totally ignore the real problem. Gang violence with illegal guns is the cause of the vast majority of violent crime committed. The media blacks out the coverage of this reality.
Polemics are easy. Problem solving is hard.
Regards,
Jim
No, don’t read mine. Mine are just wise acre stuff…
True. But to the progressive, we recognize that cars and pool have dangers, and we tend to accomodate — seatbelts, airbags, and auto body features for example, or lifeguards and safety devices for the pool.
In the progressive’s mind, he’s been convinced that we aren’t do anything about firearms, evidence to the contrary notwithstanding. Obama capitalizes on this by demanding Congress pass “Common sense” reform (without really explaining what those are) as if just a little something will fix the problem that you and I know to be way overstated.
In a Progressive’s mind, this isn’t Shark vs. Moose (movie idea: Shark vs. Moose), but rather diving with a shark cage vs. diving without a shark cage.
Hey, c’mon, spell it right! It’s SQUIRREL. I about had a heart attack the first time I saw Christmas Vacation.
I can’t think of a more dangerous gun than one with a trigger that works *sometimes*. If a ‘smart gun’ isn’t absolutely flawless in execution, a lot of people are going to accidentally shoot themselves and others.