Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Number of Orthodox Jews Identifying as GOP Has Skyrocketed
The latest Pew Research study on religion is out, and this particular nugget stuck out at me:
Among the findings of the Pew Research Center’s new survey of American Jews is one that has become increasingly self-evident in recent years: Orthodox Jews in the U.S. overwhelmingly affiliate with the Republican Party.
According to the newest study, 75% of Orthodox Jews surveyed said they were Republicans or leaned Republican. In 2013, the last year in which Pew conducted a survey of American Jews, 57% of Orthodox Jews said they were Republicans or leaned Republican.
Why is that? Well, we’re seeing it play out in real-time with these latest Hamas rocket attacks against Israel. After four years of peace and peace deals, we’re back to the status quo, with my Israeli friends spending the night hiding in bomb shelters.
Shot:
America Stands with Israel. 🇺🇸 🇮🇱
— Mike Pence (@Mike_Pence) May 11, 2021
And chaser:
Don't worry, folks. Joe Biden has got this situation in Israel under control. 🙄
Psaki say's he's "directed his team to engage intensively with senior Israeli and Palestinian officials" and are in "support of de-escalation" while also "candidly" telling off Israel on settlements pic.twitter.com/0Xa16pJi8c
— Curtis Houck (@CurtisHouck) May 11, 2021
And this statement from former President Trump came before Biden’s:
NEW: President Trump releases a statement on the conflict between Israel and Gaza:
"Under Biden, the world is getting more violent and more unstable because Biden's weakness and lack of support for Israel is leading to new attacks on our allies." pic.twitter.com/cAY88yoGpI
— Daily Caller (@DailyCaller) May 11, 2021
There are a lot of other reasons why Orthodox Jews are finding themselves self-identifying more as Republican (our religious values line up a great deal more with the right than the left, for starters), but on Israel, the reasons are crystal clear this week.
Published in General
This is good news, but are there enough Orthodox Jewish voters to make a difference? Still, every vote helps . . .
If you are a Jew that favors the Democratic Party, you are affiliating with anti-Semites. Wouldn’t make sense to me.
It’s an interesting survey.
From which:
And
And weirdly:
Really? It seems unlikely, but ??
@susanquinn – why would liberal American Jews ‘not understand’ how Jews could vote Republican? What do they say (about you?)?
The same reason, @zafar, that Lefties don’t understand why everyone doesn’t vote like them. I’m sure they think I’m as evil as the rest of the Republicans.
Biden could ship Iran the rocket fuel for the missiles that deliver nukes at Israel, cheer leftist mobs for assaults on synagogues, and erect a monument to the PLO on the mall, and he could still get 50% of the Jewish vote. The lemming-like suicidal devotion to the progressive identity is pathetic and deep-seated.
We could wonder how they deal with the cognitive dissonance, but maybe cognition has nothing to do with it.
What does a Reform Jew and an Orthodox Jew have in common? There is no commonality in their beliefs, and very few in their behavior.
Judaism is not a race.
Well, most blacks support The Party of Slavery, so go figure . . .
Who has more children? The Orthodox Jew. Who believes the world has too many people already and fears to bring another child into the world? The Reform Jew. Who marries a non-Jew? The Reform Jew. Who believes the Palestinians want the same out of life as the Jews? The Reform Jew. Who believes in the “two-state solution”, ignoring the plain fact that the Palestinians are not civilized and ruin everything they touch (like Gaza)? The Reform Jew. Who will be the savior of Judaism in the long run? The Orthodox Jew.
Really? By whom? Has this phrase ever actually been used before, about any US presidential administration?
I’m not criticizing Trump about his Israel policy, but the first sentence of his statement is absurd.
If you want to workshop a supervillainess name I’m totally available.
But it is, in part, a culture?
I’m curious: you honestly feel more of a link to Evangelical Christians than to Reform Jews?
Why is it absurd? How many wars did Trump get us into? There was one Never-Trumper on Ricochet that had an avatar that stated “I’m Already Against the Next War,” from his fear that Trump would get us into new wars. Guess what? Trump didn’t get us into the next war. Further, the world was a more peaceful place (if you omit Democrat-run US cities) at the end of his term than at the beginning.
As near as I can tell, Trump has been the least interventionist President since Coolidge. Every President since Hoover has gotten us involved in foreign interventions. Trump did not.
So explain why he should not claim his was the Peace Presidency, especially as compared to all of his predecessors since FDR.
The absurdity is in the claim that the Trump Administration “was known as the Peace Presidency”. No one has ever described it as such.
No one in the media described Trump (a President who got the majority of the votes he received in 2020 from minorities and women voters) as anything other other than a white supremacist (while Biden’s margin of victory was provided by white males).
No one in the media described the Trump economy as the strongest of the century.
No one in the media described Operation Warp Speed as a success for Trump.
You know, maybe you are right. It was absurd that no one described the Trump Presidency as the “Peace Presidency” (Other than those who nominated him for the Nobel Peace Prize). But that doesn’t make Trump’s claim that his was the Peace Presidency absurd.
So I guess we shouldn’t laugh when Joe Biden claims that his colleagues in the Senate all called him Middle Class Joe. No one else can recall other senators calling him that, but since an argument can be made that they should have called him that, we’ll count it as a true statement.
We certainly get along far, far better.
A segue but not a direct answer. Okay.
Direct answer: YES. We have much, much more in common. We both believe in G-d, and in making our lives purposeful. We take the text seriously. I have extremely deep relationships with Evangelical Christians. But I have never managed to have a serious conversation about religion and Torah with a reform Jew. There is not enough of a common language.