Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
The Fall of Michelle Malkin
At an alt-right conference running counter to CPAC, called AFPAC, conservative commentator Michelle Malkin fell further down the rabbit-hole:
.@michellemalkin on "anti-Semitism" pic.twitter.com/oFNMhVqLFj
— Zoomer Clips (@ZoomerClips) February 29, 2020
In this short clip Malkin engages in not just Holocaust denial, but also indiscriminately throws around charges of dual loyalty. It’s part of a trend for Malkin, who also endorsed anti-Semite Paul Nehlen in his contest against Rep. Paul Ryan.
In her opening remarks, Malkin referred to herself as the “Mommy” of the group and thanked the “Groypers,” the alt-right group hosting her, for pushing back against mainstream conservatives.
Today, the ConInc gatekeepers will welcome this lying asshole doxxer who does Antifa & SPLC’s dirty work back to @cpac. All the young culture warriors at @TPUSA & @yaf sit on their hands. Thank you, Groypers, for fighting back & hounding this toxic little menace! #AmericaFirst https://t.co/guZ3oCBmqF
— Michelle Malkin (@michellemalkin) February 29, 2020
It’s hard to overstate Malkin’s influence in the conservative media ecosystem; she is the founder of HotAir, Twitchy, and was a mentor to many up-and-comers over the course of her time at the helm of both.
Really embarrassing for anyone who continues to defend her and has refused to recognize she appeals almost exclusively to bigots now.
Hard for anyone on the right to complain about Omar, Tlaib etc. if we don't call this out.
— (((AG))) (@AGHamilton29) March 2, 2020
And because of Malkin’s influence, we (as a conservative movement) need to self-reflect about how reflective Malkin’s views are of our movement as a whole. Has Malkin always questioned the number of Jews who died in the Holocaust? Has Malkin always considered Jews to be agents of the Israeli government? How mainstream are the views she’s professing now in the conservative movement? They are uncomfortable questions, but ones we need to be asking as we continue to (rightly) call out the anti-Semitism on the Left with Omar, Tlaib, etc.
Published in General
Skillfully?
Gary, who are you talking about here?
I think this is exactly what happens with the overuse if the charge or racism. Any use of it is now automatically suspect. For people used to seeing it get used to shut down debate, there is an automatic response of defense.
If we want to combat real racism, we need to stop calling everyone racist.
But, even talking here, it happens. I wager I could discuss the Bell Curve and get called racist here.
Basil, it’s all already written apparently. There’s nothing more to know or discuss. Fuentes definitely wasn’t joking and Malkin, despite the ridiculousness of the proposition, is antisemitic too because of the company she keeps. Any questioning is inherently disingenuous.
It’s a matter of deciding what defines a group and makes it meaningfully different and unique. It isn’t necessarily about denigrating anybody else.
Aren’t they all?
I think so. A matter of degree, to be sure.
On the bright side, I have discussed The Bell Curve here, and have not been called racist. But I know what you mean.
I was perusing my news feed today and I came across a defense of Michelle Malkin by Robert Stacy McCain. For one thing he points out that Michelle malkin’s stance on immigration issues goes all the way back to the time when Nick Fuentes was a toddler. The other part of his defense is from his personal knowledge of Michelle. I have a lot of respect for Robert Stacy McCain, I have never known him to be wrong on an issue certainly not that I can remember now. So read the whole thing.
I read it, and I appreciate the link (see “like”). But I’d say that there isn’t much substance to the defense, and McCain honestly makes clear that he’s in debt to Malkin. I’m not going to accuse Malkin herself of being an anti-Semite, but I do think it’s time to judge, in a fair manner and on substance, whether those she mentions are worthy of her support. This is a difficult task, but somebody needs to do it, not the least because IMO the NeverTrump movement is grounded significantly in the largely inarticulated belief that Trump makes common cause with anti-Semites and other supremacist types. That’s not an endorsement of that view, BTW.
I agree, which is why I mention his personal relationship.
A while back Gen John Kelly was being accused of something or other and @bossmongo personally attested to Gen Kelly’s character. I accepted that, no questions asked.
While I do not put Stacey McCain on the same level as @bossmongo, I have been a long time reader and I am willing to take his word for it.
Particularly since McCain has convinced me that truly crazy things happen for real
E.g. Brett Kimberlin and Deborah Frisch.