Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Why Progressives Will Always Fail
As I was working on another post, I had the realization that the Progressives will never be successful in transforming our country into a Leftist state. Their goals are to create a perfect country run by perfect people to create a perfect future. What they never seem to understand is how deeply flawed their aspirations—and they—are.
First, they are the most naïve people among us. No matter how intelligent they are, they have no wisdom. No matter how educated they are, they don’t understand human nature. Regardless of their passion for changing the country and everyone else, they are the ones who are incapable of learning deeply and understanding (as James Madison did) the vulnerabilities and weaknesses of human beings.
They think by offering a flawless world that we will all line up behind them. But we only need to look at them to realize the impossibility of their goals. These are people who need to feed off others’ accomplishments, steal the results of others’ successes, and are prepared to try to destroy the very elements of human nature that allow us to thrive and grow. It is our diversity, which they celebrate, that forecasts the failure of their dreams.
We have had too much success as a country and as a people for them to enlist or coerce us. We are a country born in freedom with more wealth and opportunity than any country in the world. Why would we give that up?
Most Americans (who aren’t Progressives) at some level realize the bounties they have realized. They can pursue any job they might desire. They can live anywhere in the country. They can have families of any size. They can travel wherever they choose. They can worship however they wish, in any community they choose, and can change their allegiance at any time.
Progressivism doesn’t take into account that Americans, of all the peoples in the world, are incredibly blessed. They don’t need to steal from others or give up any of the prospects for their futures. We speak the language of gratitude, opportunity, creativity, possibility, and fulfillment.
Progressives don’t have a chance.
Published in Culture
Then you get to the question of the New Yorkization of U.S. politics, in that New York for over a century now has periodically walked itself back from the progressive abyss, but things have had to become really, really awful for just enough voters to finally motivate themselves to vote the progressives out of office.
Taking that ethos nationwide would be really, really bad for the nation, and as places like Chicago and the West Coast have shown, their are locales that have even higher tolerance for progressive misgovernance than NYC has shown over the years, where voters will allow vast quality-of-life plunges to avoid admitting ideologically they backed the wrong horse.
I’m not giving up, but I do keep in mind that there might be a South Pacific island that could make a perfect bug-out location.
Maybe that’s what I need to do–develop a back-up plan or an escape route!
OK, but fighting the wrong battle in the wrong way isn’t productive. I keep thinking about JR Dunn’s recent American Thinker column.
There is a direct line from that to Saul Alinsky, Cloward-Piven, Bernie Sanders, and headline after headline. Look at things that have been or are being deliberately “destigmatized:”
• Communism
• Anti-semitism
• Sexually transmitted diseases (that one started in the 1960s)
• being on welfare
In progress:
• pedophilia
• incest
• polygamy
And stigmatized:
• gun ownership
• self-defense
• patriotism
• nationalism
Dunn suggests:
I think he’s too optimistic, but he’s suggesting what sounds like a useful tactic.
Now I’m really depressed. It sure does seem like he’s right. I just can’t imagine the destruction they’re trying to wreak. Do they really think they’ll be able to create something good out of the ashes?
This is the lead link article to Salon on Drudge this hour:
Why Bernie Sanders is just the beginning of an American turn to the left
It’s written by members of the Democratic Socialists of America. It records the history of current successful socialist moves in the country and outlines steps forward. Many Ricochetti would dismiss this article as delusional, but at thousands of schools – at all levels – around the country this will be met with from “Yes!” to “of course, and why do you even need mention it.” Whats pretty key is that in a couple of spots they kind of glide by “andthentherewillbearevolution…” Uh, yup. And Antifa are just the kindergarten level of the coming forces.
https://www.salon.com/2020/02/22/why-bernie-sanders-is-just-the-beginning-of-an-american-turn-to-the-left/
And what better place than Tahiti!
To give our readers a taste of this scary article:
Adherents of the democratic road strategy don’t claim to know the precise sequence of events that will lead us to socialism, nor do we pretend it will be a cakewalk to eliminate capitalism, even with our people in power. Past attempts to make such transformations in countries like Chile and France have been stymied, as we’ll get to later in this chapter. But we do know that the United States will not be able to achieve anything like socialist governance, and join other nations in the project of building international socialism, without both a mass movement of workers and the formal power to stop capitalists from undermining that movement as it engages in class struggle. We see engagement in electoral politics as an important tactic for accomplishing both of these goals, and ultimately bringing about a scenario in which the working class can actually win.
Be fun to ask the angry people on the left if they’d like to repeal the Posse Comitatus Act along with the Second Amendment. While I’m sure they’d be fine with having local law enforcement alone repress the unruly masses, the end game eventually would be to send the troops in to repress the public (something even wacky-but-lovable Uncle Joe hinted at a couple of weeks ago in terms of his mindset, when he said it was silly for people to want guns to protect themselves from the government, because the government would just come in and bomb you to death).
Scratch a lefty and totalitarian blood always flows.
Those at the extremes are fighting a war by other means, and they are deadly serious about bringing down America as we know it. Omelet, eggs, and so forth.
For the record, I don’t believe the left will fully enact socialism, at least not for very long. It doesn’t work. It will fail as it’s failed everywhere. But they will expand the welfare state (perhaps back to a 60 to 70% tax rate) and they will encode their cultural
moralimmoral values and they will re-write Western and American history so they will identify it as racist, misogynistic, homophobic, militaristic, and everything else negative they can think of. And they will do this not through totalitarian means but throughconvincingindoctrinating our children.I wonder if, at some point, the black population will seek vengeance against the left for convincing them to abort themselves into being a less powerful and less desirable voting bloc than Hispanics, for example?
The Left has done such a good job of fooling blacks about their concern for them that I doubt that anyone will convince blacks otherwise. But we’ll see.
Maybe so. But didn’t Trump already get more of the black vote in 2016 than Republican presidents have in a long time, maybe ever? And there’s a good chance that will go up this year.
As usual, it’s the white liberals – such as those mostly responsible for AOC’s election, she didn’t get a majority of her own ethnic group – thinking they know what’s best for minorities.
“I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death! “
The day has not yet come when I find it necessary to take up arms, but it does seem to be just over the horizon. . . I don’t relish the thought, as I will likely fall quickly, but in the end I am duty bound to protect the constitution at all cost.