Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Abood Overruled! Public Sector Unions Can No Longer Compel Dues Payments
This is a dagger in the heart of the ever expanding state and long overdue. Together with NIFLA v. Bacerra it’s a critical reaffirmation of our First Amendment rights of speech and conscience and a great day for the Constitution. It is darkened only by the sputteringly inexplicable fact that both decisions were 5-4.
The fact that four justices on our Supreme Court could dissent from these decisions is sad and terrifying. It shows us how close to the edge we were. Thank god for Mitch McConnell, Donald Trump, and Neil Gorsuch, who together preserved at least a narrow majority on the Court with fealty to the Constitution.
Published in General
<prayers> Please lord, let President Trump get it right.
If so, 6-3 becomes the new 5-4 to liberals.
If Notorious RBG departs, the same to 7-2.
Do you mean the ruling or the dissent is shameful?
Voting for Trump was definitely worthwhile! And now we get another Conservative SCOTUS.
Maybe the analogy should be that the bum squeegees your winshield without asking, makes it dirtier, then expects you to pay him for the service.
And you to pay up without complaining.
They will all start twisting and spitting, trying to insist that it’s only fair that Trump nominate a liberal candidate – to preserve “balance” or something, without coming right out and saying it. Or perhaps they will come right out and say it.
Trump will not cave. He will stick to the list. He might be the only guy in office at the time who will endure their BS, give it right back to them. Maybe some NTers will conclude that, on balance, it was worth it to have him as president, for a conservative supreme court.
This is going to be fun to watch.
Sounds like it’s time for Mueller to make his move (if he has anything that the Media Matters crowd would be willing to run with).
I should have been clear: the *dissent* for the union case is shameful.
To be honest it would be better if the union dues just went to booze and drugs, becoming a closer analogue to the bum.
I feel like someone threw America a surprise party!
“What the…? Hey, Constitution!! Nice to see you again! You guys are so thoughtful. And there’s cake, too?? You shouldn’t have… More please.”
So, so true…
Deus vult …
Thanks, R. I won’t take time right now to talk about these two very interesting points you bring up.
I’ve read the opinions, but not carefully all the way through. There were so many issues to be addressed which I’d never thought of! The problem is that, while I was made aware of lots of issues that matter to any true American liberal, and were addressed, I was really looking for the arguments on one specific issue which I had thought was the heart of the case.
A thought experiment will explain my question.
Suppose the union in the complaint had a consistently reliable policy: we will only do one thing, negotiate for the best possible wages and working conditions for the employees we represent.
Would the Court’s decision have been the same?
Did the plaintiff claim that being required to financially support speech whose only purpose was to get him higher wages was violating his Constitutional rights? I couldn’t tell.
He’s shown every inclination to defer to Leonard Leo, so we should be fine. A constitutionalist majority on the Supreme Court has been Leonard Leo’s life’s work. He isn’t going soft or squishy.
We’re already seeing calls to wait until after the mid-terms. As if Barack Obama and Harry Reid would have done that. )-
Today really does feel like a surprise party, doesn’t it. I’m walking on air. SO MUCH WINNING! God, maybe I’ll even vote for the orange buffoon next time.
Well said! I join the conclusion of this post completely. Well written Cato Rand
A million, million likes and from your keyboard Cato Rand to God’s eyes!
Just think! With Kennedy’s retirement, we can reverse Obergefell!
Exactly! The day the GOP grew a pair and got Gorsuch in, I was ecstatic. They’ve gotta do it again now, and get someone from Trump’s great list appointed. Do whatever you have to do–this is critical! Our America is on life support!
Yes! But while we’re all celebrating, are RINOs plotting to pass a general amnesty bill? No, we can’t get too drunk…
Although I sometimes jest that they cannot read and understand the meaning of the U.S. Constitution and the founders’ intent, I think it’s more a case that they just don’t care because they think they have a better idea.
The Left isn’t exactly known for its intellectual humility…
Heck yea. And Lawrence. We can lock up the faggots again! (Needless to say, Obergefell is not the reason I’m looking forward to Mr. Justice Kennedy’s retirement).
I don’t think there’s any doubt about this. I think some of them would tell you so if you asked.
A better idea, for “fundamentally transforming the United States of America.”
But it’s strictly heterosexual cake.
It’s heterosexual cake, but it identifies as a jelly donut.
What bravery!
I think so, yes. Because speech about wages and working conditions of public servants inherently involve government resources, and are therefore political.
I think it means Christ becomes a dictator?