Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Breaking: SCOTUS Strikes Down Texas Abortion Laws
Via NBC:
Published in LawThe U.S. Supreme Court on Monday struck down one of the nation’s toughest restrictions on abortion, a Texas law that women’s groups said would have forced more than three-quarters of the state’s clinics to shut down. Passed in 2013, the law said clinics providing abortion services must meet the same building standards as ambulatory surgical centers. And it required doctors performing abortions to have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals.
Since the law was passed, the number of clinics providing abortion services in Texas dropped to 19 from 42. Opponents said that number would fall to ten if the Supreme Court upheld the law.
The Center for Reproductive Rights called the law “an absolute sham,” arguing that abortion patients rarely require hospitalization and that many patients simply take two pills.
[…]
The court’s decision will affect similar laws in twelve other states, some now on hold because of court challenges. The restrictions in Texas represented a new front in efforts to restrict abortion by focusing on protecting the health and safety of the mother rather than the life of the fetus.
yup.
As a point of clarification, the part of the Texas law banning abortions after 20 weeks has already been upheld by the Courts and was not affected by today’s ruling.
Mark, thanks for that. A bit of good news to come out of this today
Well, I guess. Except that Al Capone didn’t have the support of large numbers of Americans (not to mention the active participation in his activities of around a million American women every year). That pesky problem of living in a democracy.
As I see it, this SCOTUS decision is yet another instance of judicial overreach whose analysis is complicated by the subject. As with Obergefels, it is hard to escape the conclusion that there are those who would be considerably less scandalized had SCOTUS instead affirmed the Texas laws and, for good measure, made them the law of the land.
In any case, I’m not crazy about seeing the oft-repeated calumny of the pro-choicers —that pro-lifers only pretend to care about the health and well-being of women, when ending abortion is the goal— apparently confirmed.
yes—and that is important, I think.
Actually, he did. Bootlegging was not only seen by many as a public good, righting a wrong, but even a brave thing to do. Alphonse had an entire network of women making bathtub gin for his cheaper markets. And one of the more famous photos of a line of men waiting outside a soup kitchen in the depths of the Depression was taken at 9th and State Street in Chicago—a soup kitchen run by Al Capone himself. In December 1931, the Chicago Tribune noted that he served 120,000 meals, including a beef stew to families that Thanksgiving. Capone would go and shake hands with the men in line. The kitchen served three meals a day. At a time when John Dillinger was considered a hero, running a charity with the fruits of your labor was not bad at all for a guy from New York with syphilis, and why they could only get him for tax evasion and not murder.
Well said. The decision upholding these laws can be dumb — and the underlying law of Roe and Casey terrible — but that hardly means that the laws were well-crafted or honest.
Interesting!
Editor: Kindly delete the modified comment in toto. Thank you.
Ciao,
A.
Done, sir.