Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Cruz Bests Trump in Latest Poll: Can We Believe It?
So, here it is — in the first national poll taken entirely after the most recent Republican debate — Ted Cruz leads Donald Trump 28% to 26%, and Marco Rubio comes in third at 17%.
I would like to believe it. It is a consummation devoutly to be wished. But is it plausible? Trump has been ahead now in 31 consecutive national polls.
This poll, conducted by NBC News and The Wall Street Journal could be an outlier. They do exist. It could also be an indication that Trump was badly wounded in the most recent debate when he blamed 9/11 on George W. Bush, claimed that the Bush administration had advance warning of the attacks, and Jeb Bush and Marco Rubio went after him with a meat cleaver.
I do not know. But hope springs eternal. If The Donald were to depart the scene in a huff, we could have a serious debate between Cruz and Rubio — the two most attractive figures who remain in the race.
Even if it is an outlier, this poll might have an impact on the South Carolina race. As I said, hope springs eternal.
Published in General
I think it’s real and reflects the immediate reaction to the debate, which hurt Trump. That doesn’t mean it will last, the previous debate hurt Rubio and he seems to have recovered with a strong performance in the last debate. Trump could certainly recover in the next debate, or with a strong showing in South Carolina.
On the other hand it’s another chink in the “I’m a winner” armor.
First poll to be taken completely after the Saturday debate. We’ll see. I would expect, if Trump wins South Carolina, that polling will return to Trump being ahead.
Wishful thinking, including on my part. Trump isn’t going anyplace.
Trump would have to place second (or third) consistently to drop out. If it continues to be a three man race I think Trump holds out and has a good shot at the nomination.
I think this poll is an outlier.
If the South Carolina primary is dominated by regular Republican voters, Trump will suffer for his Bush-Iraq conspiracy.
If the open primary is spoiled by “independent” first-timers and Democrat saboteurs, Trump will gain because of that same conspiracy.
Not only is this after the debate, but also after four (4), I think had dropped out and Trump declined.
That is interesting that he didn’t hold his support and lost when other supporters were available.
I think the 3 leaders all shot themselves in the foot at the debate The difference with Trump is that he does everything big and apparently was carrying a .44 Magnum and blew his foot clean off.
This is a garbage poll. Only 400 respondents nationwide over three days and it it is a complete outlier from other national polls over a similar time frame. Complete garbage.
Yes, other national polls have more data from before the debate, but other post debate polling in SC hasn’t shown anything like the dip in Trumps support that this poll does.
I’m with Prof. Rahe. I doubted the polls when they put Obama ahead in 2008 and 2012. For some reason, I’ve just started believing in them again. (I really am an objective scientist in my field, but when it comes to politics I am hopelessly biased).
I suspect that you are right. It looks like an outlier, and I am surprised that the pollster for NBC News and The Wall Street Journal relied on so small a sample. But the data is 100% post-debate.
Why the h— do Republicans have open primaries? What is the matter with them?
The notion was that, if you could get them to vote in your primary, they might vote for your candidate in the general election.
This poll was from Feb 14 and Nate Silver gives NBC/WSJ poll a rating of A-.
peak crude?
I hope it is real. If only Trump would flame out and crash and burn…..Likely the only viable candidates remaining are Rubio and Cruz. I trust Rubio only slightly more than Hillary…….Time will tell
This poll is about par for the course. 400 samples of a population in excess of about 170,000 will give you a margin of error of 4.9% with a confidence level of 95%. At a certain point, the sample size required for additional reduction in the margin of error becomes prohibitive. Asking 800 people only brings it down to around 3.5%.
They are within the margin of error of each other, so at this point, it’s a horse race.
I can understand not trusting either Rubio or Cruz, but comparing them to Hillary is a low blow. I can see Rubio or Cruz lying when it benefits them, but Hillary lies as a point of honor and a point of style. Hillary lies when there is no apparent benefit or reason.
The Republicans have spent decades pursuing the elusive middle. Now that they have them, they are scared to death of them.
Not so much what Rubio says, but what he may do, what judges he may nominate and so on
The 10% for Ben Carson should have been the first red flag.
I don’t know how accurate it is, but it does strongly suggest movement in the right direction. This is very encouraging because if true, Trump delegates accrued to date and over the next several primaries will have no bearing on the final delegate count; and the Trump juggernaut will likely fizzle out by the time the winner-take-all states roll around.
So, I see it as an encouraging ray of sunshine. If we see similar results replicated over a few more national polls the Trump phenomenon can soon be put behind us and Republicans can move on to the serious matter of choosing a conservative nominee.
Hopefully, they back up and realize that neither Trump or Cruz can give us what we need. We need to stop yelling at each other and start building the nation up.
Neither Cruz or Trump has the ability to do anything but destroy.
Rubio is an optimistic future.
That is the right and only choice.
Annnnd… No.
Posted 15 minutes ago. Bigger sample, conducted from Saturday to this morning. Reuters/Ipsos. Surprised that Carson still has 10 percent in this one. Maybe he has diehard supporters nationally.
The margin of error on a poll that small is YUUUGE. :O
I notice that
[redacted]
[Editors’ Note: Personal attacks]
Ahem.
400 is a pretty good sample size if the sampling methodology is good. 40,000 wouldn’t be any good if the sampling methodology was bad.
BTW, I am hoping to hear an updated health report sometime soon, and I want it to be good news.
Oh God, please. Give Liberty one more shot.
Not to mention the MOE is 4.5 so we could basically say, at least as this poll goes, the two are tied. Plus, there is no link that I could find that took you to the entire poll. If I can’t see the internals, then I don’t trust the poll.
[redacted]