Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet for just $5/month. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free.












































Discussion (11)
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Dear SuperGrok,
Please evaluate Person BB's OP.
Answer (57 seconds; bolding in the original):
"Person BB’s reflection is a coherent, theologically grounded critique of anthropomorphism toward AI, of materialist determinism (via Harari), and of equating computational power with human-like intelligence or wisdom. It functions more as a faith-informed meditation on Lennox’s 2084 than as a technical or neutral philosophical treatise. It is strongest when highlighting practical dangers of treating tools as agents and the internal tensions in hard determinism; it is weaker where it leans on simplified dichotomies (left/right brain, pure materialists “denying consciousness”) or assumes the book’s dystopian framing will land uniformly.
Core thesis and framing
BB reframes AI as “ALIEN Intelligence” rather than artificial, emphasizing that humans readily anthropomorphize cars, voice interfaces, and algorithms. The Exodus 20 passage is invoked as a caution against idolatry of images/likenesses—extended here to treating sophisticated automata as alive or authoritative. This is consistent with a classical Christian concern about misplaced ultimate trust. The piece positions Lennox’s book (a 2020 engagement with AI futures that critiques Harari’s Homo Deus) as useful mainly for people of faith and likely disappointing to technologists or secularists. That assessment of audience fit is reasonable given Lennox’s explicit theological commitments and the book’s eschatological close (“Come Lord Jesus”).
Free will, motivation, and materialism
The strongest philosophical point is the observation that hard determinists (Harari is quoted on choices being fully determined by genes, biochemistry, culture, etc.) still write books, advocate, and appear motivated. BB notes the oddity of “effort” and “pleasure” under a view that free will and consciousness are illusions. This is a classic and legitimate challenge: if every action is the inevitable output of prior physical states, the phenomenology of deliberation, authorship, and purpose becomes difficult to explain without residual dualism or eliminativism that many find unsatisfying. Chess is used effectively here—the enormous game tree (Shannon number ≈ 10^120) does not make Stockfish “aware” it won; it is an optimization tool. The same distinction applies to current large models and autonomous systems: high performance on narrow or broad tasks does not entail subjectivity, intentionality, or understanding in the human sense.
A materialist reply would typically invoke compatibilism (free will as acting according to one’s own determined desires without external coercion) or argue that the feeling of choice is itself a useful adaptive illusion produced by the brain. BB’s text does not deeply engage those positions; it treats the denial of free will as binary and self-undermining. That is a fair rhetorical move from a theistic standpoint but incomplete as philosophy of mind.
Intelligence, wisdom, and information
The distinction drawn from Ayad Akhtar (and echoed in Proverbs 9:10 and the Socratic “I know that I know nothing”) is useful: flooding people with curated information can produce certainty without wisdom. Wisdom involves navigating contradiction and uncertainty; pure information scaling does not automatically yield it. BB correctly notes that machines can construct sophisticated systems without “creating” in the ex nihilo sense attributed to God. The cosmological asides (heat death on ~10^100-year scales versus a possible big crunch) serve to relativize technological immortality claims against Christian claims of actual eternity; they are illustrative rather than rigorous cosmology.
Risks and Christian eschatology
On societal risks—job displacement, concentration of power, autonomous weapons, hubris producing uncontrolled systems—BB is aligned with widely discussed concerns. The “guns don’t kill people” analogy is applied to AI tools: the primary agency remains human (or the designers/operators). The Matthew 10:28 citation reframes physical threat relative to spiritual stakes. The closing suggestion that Hell might be self-constructed by those who reject an eternal soul is a recognizable theological speculation (echoing some readings of Lewis), not a central dogma.
Limitations and balance
Overall, the reflection is thoughtful, literarily engaged, and internally consistent within its premises. It usefully resists both uncritical AI hype and pure technological determinism by insisting on the distinction between tool and agent, information and wisdom, and temporal optimization versus eternal significance. Its primary value is as a personal and confessional response to Lennox rather than as a comprehensive technical or secular philosophical analysis. For readers who share the theological starting point, the warnings about anthropomorphism and the free-will paradox land cleanly; for others, the same passages function mainly as data points about how one coherent worldview interprets accelerating AI capability."
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Perhaps you should start there? And mention the author, as in "2084 and the AI Revolution by John C. Lennox . . ." I was left wondering, since the only book you had mentioned thus far in the conversation starter was the Book of Exodus. How does that title play on Orwell? Having the title of the book repeated four times as the title of the conversation also confused me. Is this whole thing an AI glitch?
This is why I really came into the conversation. The car I currently drive is a Ford. The official color is "Toreador Red." Thus, my wife named it Hemingway. I was wondering if there were some related origin to "Ferdinand."
CHARTER MEMBER
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
My bright green VW Taos is named Kermit Spargle.
CHARTER MEMBER
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
This is the book in question. I too was confused and thought the review was of Yuval Harari's book.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
My sister-in-law named her teal-green station wagon the Gherkin.
You're seeing five of eleven comments. Sign in, or join for just $5 per month, to read them all and add your own.