The Superfeed
The Ricochet Podcast3 Whisky Happy HourBeyond the PollsGLoP CultureWhat the Hell Is Going OnParsing Immigration PolicyDaily SignalThe Erick Erickson ShowThe Kevin Roberts Show with Larry O’Connor3 Martini LunchChicks on The RightThe Learning CurveThe American IdeaHeritage ExplainsFederalist Radio HourConservative Crossroads with Henry OlsenNot Dead YetWho Funds that?The Radio Free Hillsdale HourHillsdale DialoguesCall Me Back - with Dan SenorFirst Things PodcastThe Glenn ShowThe Report Card with Nat MalkusHeard at HeritageThe Back of the BookMom WarsFreedom to LearnThe LibertarianThe Conservative Woman’s GuideLaw Talk with Epstein, Yoo & CookeGiving VenturesThe Powerline ShowGray MattersMadison’s NotesMartini ShotThe Dave Carter ShowIn DissentSmart Girl PoliticsJames Lileks’ The DinerCase in Point: The Legal Show on the Hottest Legal Cases in Politics and CultureJobMakersOne on One with Robert DoarHubwonk
HostsOrganizations
Join

Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.

Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.

  1. Main Feed/
  2. Thrice Told Tales: Joan of Arc
November 18, 2026 at 6:08 AM

Thrice Told Tales: Joan of Arc

Eustace C. Scrubb
@EustaceCScrubb

To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

Join to bookmark17likesJoin to like12comments

In 2022, London’s Globe Theater debuted the play I, Joan, written by non-binary playwright Charlie Josophine and starring non-binary actor Isobel Thom. The play reimagined the story of Joan of Arc, using her practice of wearing men’s clothing and taking on what were considered men’s roles (such as leading an army) as a celebration of trans and non-binary identities.

Something tells me the real St. Joan would not approve.

Joan of Arc is one of the most astounding figures in history. In 1428, a 17-year-old peasant girl convinced Charles VII, the king of France, that she should lead his armies in battle. Joan claimed her authority came from angelic visions, and she proved herself worthy through her discernment and a genius in battle. After a series of military defeats, she was captured by the English, tried, and burned at the stake for heresy against the church. Years after her death, she was retried and acquitted. (Couldn’t overturn the death sentence, though. Shame about that.) The Catholic Church canonized her in 1920.

Joan has been the subject of many histories, novels, and plays through the years (in my senior year of high school I wrote a term paper on one of those plays, George Bernard Shaw’s Saint Joan). Some day I intend to get around to reading Mark Twain’s Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc, but (more importantly for Thrice Told Tales, this continuing series of posts), Joan has been portrayed a remarkable number of times on the silver screen.

I found fifteen films that tell at least part of Joan’s life story, beginning with Georges Méliès' 1900 short (which is not very good). Many depictions feature her along with other historical characters, including Daughters of Destiny (1954), The Story of Mankind (1957, in which Joan is played by Hedy Lamarr), and, of course, 1989’s Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure.

I have to narrow my choices to three films, but at least the first choice is easy. It’s considered one of the greatest films ever made (in the British Film Institute’s Sight and Sound 2022 poll rating of the best films of all time, it ranked #21 with the critics and #30 with directors).

The_Passion_of_Joan_of_Arc_(1928)_English_Poster

The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928)

A common complaint about historical films is that filmmakers play fast and loose with the facts. That’s not the case here. Director Carl Theodor Dreyer worked with screenwriter Joseph Delteil on a script based on transcripts of Joan’s actual trial.

You might wonder how accurate those transcripts were. A notary named Guillaume Manchon, along with two other notaries, compared their three sets of notes every day of the trial. The manuscript was written in Middle French, but four years later Manchon took the work to the University of Paris and, with assistance, translated it into Latin. Five original copies of those translations are still extant.

Dreyer worked on the script for a year and a half to reduce 29 interrogations that took place over 18 months to a film length of about two hours. (Even when the film was released, it was edited by government and church censors. Through the years, many different edits of the film were released with different running times. It was released in the United States in 1933 with a running time of 61 minutes.)

Not surprisingly, considering the year it was made, the film was silent and black and white.

Dreyer constructed a huge set to replicate Rouen Castle. The cinematography was unusual, primarily relying on close-ups of the actors. The actors were not to use makeup, giving them a tired and worn look. Maria Falconetti, a woman in her mid-thirties, played Joan, a girl in her late teens. Yet she gives one of the greatest performances ever brought to the screen, the unforgiving close-up capturing her sense of hope, betrayal, anguish, and ecstasy.

Joan’s decision to wear men’s clothing is portrayed as a response to her call from God, not as a personal choice or fetish. She longs for communion from and with the Church, but not at the cost of obedience to God.

This French/Danish co-production would not have passed under the Hollywood Hays Code. At the movie's end, in the crowd watching Joan’s execution, we see a close-up of a woman breastfeeding her child. We see graphic images of Joan’s burned body. The Hays Code also asked for positive portrayals of the clergy—a desirable outcome that isn’t always possible.

The story of the recovery of the original cut is arguably miraculous. Throughout the years, censors of all kinds hacked away at the film. The original negative was destroyed in a fire. In 1981, though, a janitor in a mental institution in Asker, Norway, happened upon three film canisters in a closet. In 1928, Dreyer had shipped the film to the director of the hospital. When the janitor found it, the film was in its original packaging.

try again

Joan of Arc (1948)

When The Passion of Joan of Arc was in production, many people in France were not pleased that the director was Danish. It was even more important to them that the actress who played Joan was French. Rumors of Lillian Gish taking the role were received with hostility.

But after World War II, the French public had enough to worry about, so they didn’t seem to be too concerned when Hollywood decided to tell the story of Joan with a 33-year-old Swede in the role, an actress by the name of Ingrid Bergman.

This film was a lush production, the very opposite of Dreyer’s austere work. It was directed by Victor Fleming, noted for directing Gone With the Wind and The Wizard of Oz.

This film tells a fuller story of Joan’s life rather than concentrating on the trial. The story opens, in fact, by letting viewers know that the church made Joan a saint — that way viewers know the Church is good and that in the end we’ll have a happy ending.

We see Joan as a young woman receiving the vision of angels, and the angels tell her that the Dauphin, Charles, will be crowned King of France. Joan goes to meet the Dauphin, who has disguised himself in the crowd. She recognizes him, winning his trust and respect. He puts her in charge of his army.

At the camp, as the army prepares for battle, she orders the men to refrain from drinking, gambling, and using the Lord’s name in vain. She sends away the camp followers and prostitutes and has the army prepare for battle by going to confession and attending Mass. The army is triumphant in the Siege of Orleans.

Joan leads the army to other victories, and the Dauphin is crowned king, but he also signs a treaty with the Duke of Burgundy, giving control of the army to the Duke. While defending Compiègne, Joan is captured and sold to the English. The story of her trial, the focus of The Passion of Joan of Arc, is told here too, but more briefly.

Joan is burned at the stake, but we are spared from seeing it.

The film received critical acclaim at its release. New York Times critic Bosley Crowther called it “one of the most magnificent films ever made.” It was nominated for the Oscar for Best Picture and received Oscars for Best Cinematography and Best Costumes. The production costs were considerable, and it just broke even at the box office. Nonetheless, this film hasn’t had the lasting cultural impact that Dreyer’s film has had.

Oddly, the full version of this rendition was also thought to have been lost for years. In 1950, the picture was rereleased with 45 minutes of its original 145-minute running time cut, but in 1998, a mint condition print was found in Europe, and the film was restored.

Also in 1950, the Roman Catholic Church condemned Ingrid Bergman — who had played not only Saint Joan but a nun in The Bells of St. Mary — for her adulterous affair with Roberto Rossellini and for giving birth to a child out of wedlock. Bergman would play Joan again in another film, 1954’s Joan of Arc at the Stake, directed by Roberto Rossellini.

messengar

The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc (1999)

Finally, we have an actress playing Joan who isn’t in her thirties. Milla Jovovich was in her early twenties, which is at least closer to the teen Joan was when she went to war. Jovovich and director Luc Besson had previously worked together on the renowned science fiction epic, The Fifth Element. Besson is perhaps even better known for his 1994 film, Léon: The Professional, about a professional hit man who trains a twelve-year-old orphan in his craft.

This film, of course, tells the story of Joan and Charles, the wars and her trial, adding also a bit of Joan’s younger days. There is a beautiful scene of young Joan confessing to a priest that she gave some cheese to a poor monk. (The cheese wasn’t hers, but her father’s.) The priest tells her she can’t bring every little thing in for confession or she would have to live in the church. “And what’s wrong with that?” Joan asks.

There is also a scene of English soldiers breaking into Joan’s home. As she hides in a closet, the soldiers rape her sister. It’s a brutal scene but an important reminder that the French were not dealing with abstract Anglo oppression.

Bresson admitted his goal in the film wasn’t historical accuracy. He wanted to explore Joan’s emotional journey and to show the emotional toll of war. This narrative doesn’t take for granted that Joan’s visions are real, but rather questions her sanity. Another innovation is the undercurrent of feminist theory included in the film.

The Messenger received mixed critical reviews and barely broke even at the box office.

France is facing new challenges and a very different kind of invasion these days. She, the Eldest Daughter of the Church, could use another prophet, warrior, and saint in the mold of Joan. Then there might be hope for that great nation yet.

passion of joan
bergman
mila

Promoted by an EditorThis post was promoted to the Main Feed by an editor.

Discussion (12)

Sign in to commentSign in
  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    OccupantCDN@OccupantCDN·1d
    Eustace C. Scrubb (View Post):

    Something tells me the real St. Joan would not approve.

    Correct. I think Joan of Arc would not have even fathomed something so farcical that she maybe a man.

    The only film of these Ive seen was "The Messenger" I dont really remember it that well now, but I think I generally liked it. Unlike the Fifth Element, which I have seen dozens of times and really loved it. I also loved that it was a unique and creative science fiction film that didnt get milked to death with endless sequels, spin offs and mindless crass cash grab merchandising, in the years following it.

    Thank you for the great post, when I first started reading, I thought this was Gary McVey's.

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Postmodern Hoplite@PostmodernHoplite·1d
    Edited

    Thanks for posting an excellent review of these three films; I hope it launches a worthy discussion.

    Of the three, the only one I’ve seen is the 1948 version, directed by Victor Fleming and starring Ingrid Bergman. Describing this movie as “lush” is perhaps an understatement, as it has an almost 3-D quality to its visual depth and use of color. Of course, any movie starring Ingrid Bergman risks losing any focus other than to her beauty, but Fleming’s direction makes it so that one sees Bergman’s beauty as an outward expression of Joan’s inward piety and purity.

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Eustace C. Scrubb@EustaceCScrubb·1d
    ReplyingtoOccupantCDN

    OccupantCDN (View Comment):

    Thank you for the great post, when I first started reading, I thought this was Gary McVey's.

    Now that's high praise. Thank you.

  • CONTRIBUTOR

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Seawriter@Seawriter·1d

    When I was a kid, in Ann Arbor during the 1960s, one of the TV stations we could pick up was Channel 8 - CKLW-TV in Windsor. They had an afternoon show, Bill Kennedy at the Movies.

    The host and narrator was Bill Kennedy (I know - who expected that), who had been a studio player for Warner Brothers. He claimed his most famous role was as the executioner in the 1948 Joan of Arc, setting fire to Joan. As I recall, his keynote line was "We need more faggots," which was received with hilarity by the gay community of the 1940s.

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Front Seat Cat@FrontSeatCat·1d

    Both London and France could use a Joan of Arc . Portraying a trans Joan of Arc is as stupid as a trans Bond girl. Given the new Bond, and if they add that, I'm done with them. A shame - Daniel Craig is a tough act to follow.

+7 more comments
Join the conversation

You're seeing five of twelve comments. Sign in, or join for just $5 per month, to read them all and add your own.

Trending

Become a member.

Tired of the toxicity of social media? Why not join Ricochet? Think of it as an online bar. Come in, have a drink, hang out, say whatever you want. But don’t badger, bully, or berate the other drinkers. That's our only rule. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.

Join Ricochet

Get the Ricochet app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
  • •
  • •