The Superfeed
The Ricochet Podcast3 Whisky Happy HourBeyond the PollsGLoP CultureDaily SignalThe Powerline ShowChicks on The Right3 Martini LunchThe Erick Erickson ShowThe Back of the BookThe Glenn ShowGray MattersFederalist Radio HourFirst Things PodcastCall Me Back - with Dan SenorThe Radio Free Hillsdale HourMom WarsWhat the Hell Is Going OnParsing Immigration PolicyFreedom to LearnThe Kevin Roberts Show with Larry O’ConnorThe Learning CurveThe American IdeaHeritage ExplainsConservative Crossroads with Henry OlsenNot Dead YetWho Funds that?Hillsdale DialoguesThe Report Card with Nat MalkusHeard at HeritageThe LibertarianThe Conservative Woman’s GuideLaw Talk with Epstein, Yoo & CookeGiving VenturesMadison’s NotesMartini ShotThe Dave Carter ShowIn DissentSmart Girl PoliticsJames Lileks’ The DinerCase in Point: The Legal Show on the Hottest Legal Cases in Politics and CultureJobMakersOne on One with Robert DoarHubwonk
HostsOrganizations
Join

Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.

Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.

  1. Main Feed/
  2. The National Popular Vote Plan is Unconstitutional
November 22, 2026 at 8:19 AM

The National Popular Vote Plan is Unconstitutional

KellyJohnston
@KellyJohnston

To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

Join to bookmark13likesJoin to like23comments

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) promises to guarantee the presidency to whoever wins the most votes nationwide without amending the Constitution. It doesn’t just reconfigure the Electoral College. Its critics argue that this is the problem: such a fundamental change cannot be accomplished through a side door. Courts would likely agree. I hope so.

Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 specifies that each state's legislature directs how its electors are appointed. The Constitution does not dictate how states must award their electoral votes, allowing for variation in state-level processes. The 12th Amendment, ratified after the contentious 1800 presidential election, further refined the process by which electors cast their votes for president and vice president.

The Electoral College is considered a constitutional mechanism designed to provide checks and balances, ensuring representation for both small and large states in presidential elections, and was intended to prevent larger states from dominating the process.

Pasted image

Where the Compact Stands

The compact is not in effect yet. Virginia, with a new Democratic governor, Abigail Spanberger, and a legislature that met earlier this year, wasted no time becoming the 18th state to join. The total stands at 18 states plus the District of Columbia, holding 222 electoral votes. That leaves the compact 48 votes short of the 270 it needs to activate.

Virginian James Madison, often credited with authoring the Constitution, must be spinning in his grave. Madison agreed to the Electoral College even though Virginia, at the time, was the nascent nation’s most populous state.

The 2026 elections may make the “compact” a reality. Democrats flipped five state legislatures, worth 61 electoral votes, that could supply the missing votes. The obstacles are not purely legal. Nevada’s legislature passed the compact in 2019, but then-Gov. Steve Sisolak, a Democrat, vetoed it, arguing it would cost Nevada its battleground status. Litigation will likely wait. Republicans are unlikely to sue until the compact takes effect, given standing and ripeness tests regarding justiciability. So the constitutional fight will probably arrive in the middle of a presidential cycle, with the stakes at their highest.

The Compact Clause

The strongest objection comes from Article I, Section 10. It bars states from entering into agreements with one another without Congressional consent. Congress has never consented to this one.

Supporters respond that the Supreme Court does not read the clause literally. In Virginia v. Tennessee (1893), the Court held that consent is required only for agreements that increase the political power of the states in a way that could encroach on federal supremacy. Decades later, U.S. Steel v. Multistate Tax Commission (1978) reaffirmed that test. The NPVIC fails it. The entire purpose is to pool the electoral power of member states so they can jointly determine the presidency, and the outcome depends on voters in other states.

Derek Muller argued as early as 2007 that the agreement would increase participating states’ political power at other states’ expense and therefore require congressional approval. The Heritage Foundation likewise argues that political compacts are permitted only with congressional consent. A compact designed to rewrite how the nation chooses its president is about as political as an agreement can be.

Structural Problems Beyond Consent

The compact also conflicts with the structure of the Constitution itself. The 12th Amendment provides that if no candidate wins an electoral majority, the House of Representatives chooses the president. Critics note that removing the possibility of that contingent election could arguably require explicit congressional approval. A compact that eliminates a constitutionally specified fallback is hard to square with the document’s design.

Article II gives each state legislature the power to appoint electors as it directs. That is a power over a state’s own electors. It is not obviously a power to bind them irrevocably to a result produced by other states’ voters, under other states’ rules. That last point matters. The compact would combine election returns produced under different state voting rules without a uniform national election code, and one scholar has said those differences could invite equal protection challenges. Ballot access, voter eligibility, and counting procedures vary widely, yet the compact treats the totals as one national contest. A Virginia voter’s ballot could end up deciding Virginia’s electors based on how other states ran their elections.

Forty states, for instance, have smaller populations than Los Angeles County. Yet Democrats believe Los Angeles County should have a bigger say in electing the president than nine of the least populated states in the country combined.

David Harsanyi, Washington Examiner

Does that square with the Founders’ intent? Hardly. After all, we’re a Constitutional republic, not a mobocracy. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact contradicts that in spades.

Would Congress Rescue It?

Advocates may say Congress can simply consent. Perhaps so, but that route is politically fraught, and even a consenting Congress would face the 12th Amendment objection above. Without consent, the plan rests on a prediction that the Supreme Court will adopt a narrow view of the Compact Clause just when its application matters most. That is a risky bet for something as important as the presidency.

The Founders Intent

The Electoral College was established by the nation's founders during the Constitutional Convention of 1787 as a hard-fought compromise for electing the president. The Framers distrusted democracy. The chief architect of the Constitution and our fourth US President, Virginian James Madison, in Federalist Paper 10, said this:

[In a direct democracy], [a] common passion or interest will, in almost every case, be felt by a majority of the whole; a communication and concert results from the form of government itself; and there is nothing to check the inducements to sacrifice the weaker party or an obnoxious individual. Hence it is that such democracies have ever been spectacles of turbulence and contention; have ever been found incompatible with personal security or the rights of property; and have in general been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths.

Pasted image

The Electoral College in 1800

The Electoral College, the result of a hard-fought compromise, was an artfully crafted compromise to protect the interests of small versus larger states. I’m no lawyer or Constitutional expert, but it is hard for me to imagine the US Supreme Court—at least five of them—going along with a compact that allows states to jettison their sovereignty and the preferences of their voters in favor of California, New York, Chicago, and a handful of other large states. Maybe after Democrats finish packing the Supreme Court with a trifecta after the next election (and that may also violate the Constitution’s due process clauses of the 5th and 14th Amendments).

The Other Side

Defenders make serious arguments. National Popular Vote, Inc. says no court has ever invalidated an interstate agreement for lack of congressional consent. They also point to the states’ broad authority over electors and argue that the compact increases no state’s power over the federal government, since each state is exercising a power it already holds. Some defenders also contend that the Compact Clause applies only to agreements that threaten federal supremacy, which they say this one does not. Courts have never ruled on this question, and the outcome remains uncertain.

Now that Democrats control enough machinery to enact the NPVIC, they are shooting with real bullets, just as Democrats in the Senate will with terminating the filibuster (the Rule XXII supermajority vote requirement to end legislative debate).

Will they pull the trigger? My guess is yes—not that it has anything to do with the issues voters expressed most concern about in this year’s elections. It has everything to do with cementing political power and moving, as has California, to one-party rule. That’s tyranny, not democracy. Democrats are working overtime to eliminate the very democracy they claim to protect and defend.

Oh, sure, we will still have “elections,” but under rules and procedures that favor them and make it easy to cheat, whether by ballot harvesting or dirty voter rolls. How has that worked out for California’s “democracy"?

If you think the Supreme Court’s been busy the past few years, “turbulence and contention” await you. If the NPVIC had been in effect for the 2024 election, Donald Trump would still be president with the Electoral College votes of California, New York, Virginia, and other states that didn’t vote for him.

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is a bad idea whose time should never come.

Recommended by MembersThis post was promoted to the Main Feed at the recommendation of Ricochet's members.

Discussion (23)

Sign in to commentSign in
  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Red Herring@EHerring·6h

    The Democrats, professional election cheaters that they are, would crank up their cheating schemes into high gear. There would be nothing to stop them, no Constitutional redress once the votes are quickly certified. Our country has neither the ability nor desire to stop their cheating. Heck, far too many don’t want to admit it is going on. We keep letting Democrats get away with crossing red lines.

    Freedom-loving people need to reenforce the guard rails that prevent us from following Europe into the abyss. The ratification of the Constitution is what united sovereign states. If blue states are that desperate to void the Constitution, red states need to tell them that will voided the compact. How many more red states have the commies claimed this year? They openly admit what they are now, DSA party and new Muslim states.

    The Constitution-loving red states won't be able to stand up to the Frankfurt School Marxist wave much longer. Your nextdoor neighbors who ignore politics most of the time then are suckers for Democrat propaganda the few months before elections aren’t going to stop them. I’m not going to stop them. At my age, I won’t be around to suffer the consequences. Besides, I believe the voters deserve the government they vote for. The foolish voters in my state gave away a House and Senate seat because the lefties promised “affordability.” Gas had dropped down to $2.98 a gallon when a filled my tank Thursday. Suckers. They didn’t give Trump long enough. Now they can’t undo the damage for six years. Yes, the lefty Democrats read the room and said it is time for our endgame. It is going to be interesting.

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    DonG (Here.We.Go.)@DonG·5h

    If the fate of America depends on the integrity of Ketanji Brown Jackson, we are screwed. The Founders were against pure democracy, because it results in stability. When scholars write about the end of America they will write about this popular vote compact and the SAVE act.

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Red Herring@EHerring·5h
    Edited
    ReplyingtoDonG (Here.We.Go.)

    DonG (Here.We.Go.) (View Comment):

    If the fate of America depends on the integrity of Ketanji Brown Jackson, we are screwed. The Founders were against pure democracy, because it results in stability. When scholars write about the end of America they will write about this popular vote compact and the SAVE act.

    The 2026 election won’t be seen as the cause, but the crystal ball.

  • BT

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Bob Thompson@BobThompson·5h
    ReplyingtoRed Herring

    DonG (Here.We.Go.) (View Comment):

    If the fate of America depends on the integrity of Ketanji Brown Jackson, we are screwed. The Founders were against pure democracy, because it results in stability. When scholars write about the end of America they will write about this popular vote compact and the SAVE act.

    Red Herring (View Comment):

    The 2026 election want be seen as the cause, but the crystal ball.

    Given that the Constitution designates the authority to decide how to appoint the Electors to reside with the State Legislature, it appears that for a compact to be valid, it would need to be approved specifically by each newly elected state legislature.

  • D

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Django@Django·4h

    I don't understand why a "compact" is necessary. Maybe I'm just dense, but if one state simply says "for all future presidential elections, our electors will vote in a manner consistent with the national popular vote", how is that the concern of the courts? Why is it a constitutional issue at all? If a few other states think that is a good idea and follow along, it's just an organic movement. Naturally, I hope the movement will fail because I don't want CA, NY, IL, and similar states determining how the country is governed.

+18 more comments
Join the conversation

You're seeing five of 23 comments. Sign in, or join for just $5 per month, to read them all and add your own.

Trending

Become a member.

Tired of the toxicity of social media? Why not join Ricochet? Think of it as an online bar. Come in, have a drink, hang out, say whatever you want. But don’t badger, bully, or berate the other drinkers. That's our only rule. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.

Join Ricochet

Get the Ricochet app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
  • •
  • •