The Superfeed
The Ricochet Podcast3 Whisky Happy HourBeyond the PollsGLoP CultureChicks on The Right3 Martini LunchCall Me Back - with Dan SenorFirst Things PodcastThe Erick Erickson ShowThe Glenn ShowFederalist Radio HourDaily SignalThe Radio Free Hillsdale HourThe Report Card with Nat MalkusHeard at HeritageThe Back of the BookMom WarsWhat the Hell Is Going OnParsing Immigration PolicyFreedom to LearnThe LibertarianThe Kevin Roberts Show with Larry O’ConnorThe Learning CurveThe Conservative Woman’s GuideThe American IdeaHeritage ExplainsLaw Talk with Epstein, Yoo & CookeNot Dead YetGiving VenturesHillsdale DialoguesThe Powerline ShowGray MattersMadison’s NotesConservative Crossroads with Henry OlsenWho Funds that?Martini ShotThe Dave Carter ShowIn DissentSmart Girl PoliticsJames Lileks’ The DinerCase in Point: The Legal Show on the Hottest Legal Cases in Politics and CultureJobMakersOne on One with Robert DoarHubwonk
HostsOrganizations
Join

Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.

Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet for just $5/month. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free.

  1. Main Feed/
  2. Yes. You should judge groups.
December 11, 2025 at 1:55 PM

Yes. You should judge groups.

Henry Castaigne
@HenryCastaigne

To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

Join to bookmark41likesJoin to like30comments

Last week, Jon Stewart had a dumb take that was not even intellectually coherent. Very shocking, I know. (<Link here, NSFW> I recommend skipping the video and reading my summary, but you can do as you like.)

Basically, it’s terrible to judge Somali-Americans as a group because of the actions of a few bad Somali-American leaders. However, judging white South Africans by the actions of their ancestors is legitimate. Also, judging anyone who voted for Trump as being an evil white racist or a fool is totally fine. This, according to Jon Stewart, anyway.

It is a common tactic deployed by Muslims and leftists about the problems of Muslim immigrant groups. “Most of them are decent and hard working, and you shouldn’t judge all Muslims by bad examples.” Without any exceptions that I am aware of, these same people judge whites and Israelis as a group.

For example, the woke left used the specific instance of George Floyd’s death as being representative of the attitudes of all whites and white society in general. That individual occurrence in Minneapolis wasn't just one cop behaving badly. It is an emblematic example of racial oppression everywhere. Strangely, this applied even in Britain. Historically. Britain didn’t have chattel slavery or Jim Crow. But they still had BLM riots. Such was the power of George Floyd.

The other most common example by Muslims was found in their response to the October 7th attacks (which was not unlike the reaction to any terrorist attack in general). Islamic apologists say that Israel’s response against Palestine over the October 7th attacks was deeply unfair because it punished all Palestinians for the actions of a radical few. They then want to boycott all of Israel for war crimes.

The left and Muslims don’t actually believe in not judging groups. It’s just that when a group they are advocating for does something bad, they begin to say, “Not all x does y.” While that is technically true, it is used to obfuscate the obvious reality that some groups have strikingly different rates of particular behaviors. Somalis have much higher rates of government fraud, and Pakistani Muslims have much higher rates of rape. Both groups have very high rates of cousin marriage. Importing those groups in masse would simply cause more problems than importing other groups.

Jon Stewart likely knows that importing Somalis has more downsides than importing middle-class Swedes. If he doesn’t, his research team knows it. But the Somali’s are part of his coalition of the oppressed in the leftist imagination, therefore they can’t be judged by the regular moral standards that ‘regular’ groups of people can be judged by.

When Leftists say that you should’t judge groups, ask them if they judge Israelis, Afrikaners, or white Christians in the American South. If that doesn’t work, ask them if they judge Republicans. If they say that being a Republican is being part of an ideology and not an ethnic group, and that Republicans can be held accountable according to the results of that ideology, then ask if Islam should be judged by similar standards.

Likely, it will result in an ad hominem or communist gobbledygook, but it will be a lively conversation.

I find it all quite annoying. These rhetorical flourishes are used to avoid blatant statistical realities that everyone understands. Obviously, people notice that different groups behave differently.

Just a few days ago, as I was completing this essay, Piers Morgan interviewed Nick Fuentes and pretended that he was dumb enough to ignore the entire idea of per capita rates. I’m no Fuentes fan, but Piers Morgan's obstinate refusal to admit transparent realities made Fuentes look sensible.

As Thomas Sowell has noted, one of the most consistent patterns throughout human civilization is that different groups have markedly different patterns of behavior. Pretending that every demographic is the same can work for a while when you live in a neighborhood of upper-middle-class white people with private security, as Piers Morgan does. But in almost every other circumstance, from immigration policy to deciding where to visit in Chicago, pretending that every demographic is the same is the height of foolishness.

Recommended by MembersThis post was promoted to the Main Feed at the recommendation of Ricochet's members.

Discussion (30)

Sign in to commentSign in
  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Susan Quinn@SusanQuinn·48w

    Excellent post, Henry. And that is precisely what the Left does: they criticize groups they hate and embrace groups they love. The sad part is that I don't know if they even realize what they are doing. They just see these conclusions as "facts."

  • M

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    MiMac@MiMac·48w

    "If all cultures are equal, then cannibalism is just a matter of culinary taste."

    Léo Strauss

  • CHARTER MEMBER

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Misthiocracy has never@Misthiocracy·48w

    Disagree on purely semantic grounds.

    To judge is to assign blame and to dole out punishment. It's why we in the West limit the power of judgement to official representatives of the state. When Jesus talked about putting limits on judgement it was almost always in reference to an incident where the subject being judged was in imminent danger of execution by a mob.

    Yes, as individuals we should criticize, abhor, boycott, avoid, attempt to educate/deprogram, etc. certain groups, but to "judge" means taking it up a notch, beyond our authority as individuals unless we are willing to accept equivalent judgement in return.

    IMHO

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Subcomandante America@TheReticulator·48w

    I hereby judge MAGA on the basis of the bad behavior of some of its adherents.

  • CHARTER MEMBER

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Miffed White Male@MiffedWhiteMale·48w

    Chris Rock had a bit about, when driving through an unfamiliar city on the freeway, you should never take the exit at Martin Luther King Jr Street/Avenue/Blvd.

+25 more comments
Join the conversation

You're seeing five of 30 comments. Sign in, or join for just $5 per month, to read them all and add your own.

Trending

Become a member.

Tired of the toxicity of social media? Why not join Ricochet for just $5/month? Think of it as an online bar. Come in, have a drink, hang out, say whatever you want. But don’t badger, bully, or berate the other drinkers. That's our only rule.

Join Ricochet

Get the Ricochet app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
  • •
  • •