The Superfeed
The Ricochet Podcast3 Whisky Happy HourBeyond the PollsGLoP CultureDaily SignalThe Erick Erickson ShowThe Kevin Roberts Show with Larry O’Connor3 Martini LunchChicks on The RightThe Learning CurveThe American IdeaHeritage ExplainsFederalist Radio HourConservative Crossroads with Henry OlsenNot Dead YetWho Funds that?The Radio Free Hillsdale HourHillsdale DialoguesCall Me Back - with Dan SenorFirst Things PodcastThe Glenn ShowThe Report Card with Nat MalkusHeard at HeritageThe Back of the BookMom WarsWhat the Hell Is Going OnParsing Immigration PolicyFreedom to LearnThe LibertarianThe Conservative Woman’s GuideLaw Talk with Epstein, Yoo & CookeGiving VenturesThe Powerline ShowGray MattersMadison’s NotesMartini ShotThe Dave Carter ShowIn DissentSmart Girl PoliticsJames Lileks’ The DinerCase in Point: The Legal Show on the Hottest Legal Cases in Politics and CultureJobMakersOne on One with Robert DoarHubwonk
HostsOrganizations
Join

Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.

Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.

  1. Main Feed/
  2. X Promised ‘Freedom of Speech, not Freedom of Reach.’ Antisemites Got Both.
November 17, 2026 at 12:53 PM

X Promised ‘Freedom of Speech, not Freedom of Reach.’ Antisemites Got Both.

Sacha Roytman
@SachaRoytman

To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

Join to bookmark11likesJoin to like3comments

In late September, the far-right podcaster Ian Carroll posted an aerial photo of the Utah Valley University courtyard where Charlie Kirk was murdered, set beside a picture of a menorah. Who at Turning Point USA, he asked, decided Kirk would stand at the “center candle”? What were the odds that person was Israeli or Jewish? Then he answered his own question by suggesting that whoever picks the location for an assassination is the killer.

It was an absurd assertion on its face and, unfortunately, he was far from alone in his peddling of antisemitic conspiracy theories.

Over a two-week period, researchers at the organization I lead, the Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM), tracked 2,806 significant antisemitic posts across X, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook. These were posts seen more than 40,000 times. Together, they drew 1.18 billion views, and about 98% of those views came on just two platforms: X and Instagram.

We found one platform to be quite the outlier.

Whatever one thinks of TikTok, it appears to have taken measures that X and Instagram have not. Not so long ago, Jew-hatred ran rampant there. Yet, during our monitoring window, TikTok seemed to detect and restrict almost every post pushing antisemitic conspiracy theories, often within seconds. Only 13 TikTok posts made our list, compared with more than 2,000 on X.

Some influencers even complained that TikTok had become too strict while announcing they would post on Instagram and X instead. Those platforms created a fertile space for their hate.

We cannot see inside TikTok’s systems, and there still were a handful of posts that did receive more than a million views. However, the gap between the platforms is hard to ignore. For years, tech companies told us antisemitism online was too vast, too coded, and too hard to police at scale. If one company can do it, what is stopping the others?

None of this requires silencing anyone. In 2023, X described its own policy as “freedom of speech, not freedom of reach,” and I agree with that principle. While a user has the ability to author a hateful post, those who run the platform decide whether to recommend it to millions of strangers who never sought it out.

Holding companies to the standard they set for themselves is not censorship. It simply asks them to judge their own success the way they told us they would: by how far hateful content travels, and not only by whether it stays up. By that measure, X and Instagram are failing, because their own recommendation systems carried antisemitic posts to audiences far beyond the people who wrote them or went looking for them.

Look at what these companies chose to amplify. More than half of all views went to conspiracy theories, most of them repeating the centuries-old claim that Jews secretly control governments, banks, and the media. Those posts alone drew 514 million views.

When a Tel Aviv-bound FlyDubai flight was nearly hijacked in September, posts calling it an Israeli “false flag” drew another 106 million. A post by failed congressional candidate Dan Bilzerian announcing that “the jewish pedophile cabal is going to fall” was viewed 1.3 million times on X.

The two companies are not identical. Instagram removed nearly a quarter of the posts we tracked, while X removed only about one in 30.

With what its algorithm recommends, Instagram’s problem starts earlier. In May, our researchers set up two new accounts that followed only wellness and fitness creators. Within three days, both were being proactively offered undesired antisemitic content.

The problem is also more concentrated than it looks. Just 100 of the 683 accounts we identified collected nearly two-thirds of all views, and the top 10 alone took almost a fifth. That is a short list, and the platforms already know who is on it.

For New Yorkers, none of this is abstract. In the past year alone, Jews have been targeted in more than half of all confirmed hate crimes in the city, including multiple street stabbings targeting visibly Jewish passersby. I cannot tell you what any one attacker saw on a screen. But when platforms served hundreds of millions of people the lie that Jews are a hidden enemy, no one should be shocked when some of them have a violent response.

The fix is not complicated. Instagram and X must stop recommending antisemitic content to people who never searched for it, and they should enforce the rules already on their books. Neither step requires inventing anything new. TikTok’s results suggest the tools already exist.

Our research also found that many of the bots and fake profiles amplifying these narratives are run from abroad, mirroring patterns of hostile anti-West state actors. Users deserve to know where those accounts originate and the agendas of their operators.

TikTok has shown that limiting the reach of Jew-hatred is a choice a company can make. X and Instagram would be wise to follow the same path.

Sacha Roytman is CEO of the Combat Antisemitism Movement.

Recommended by MembersThis post was promoted to the Main Feed at the recommendation of Ricochet's members.

Discussion (3)

Sign in to commentSign in
  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    CarolJoy, Not So Easy To Kill@CarolJoy·1d

    Let's look at how in relative terms, Americans have witnessed rather quickly some immense changes that have come about from the pro-Zionist portion of America's Jews, with regards to labelling people as anti-semites and labelling today's social media's comments as anti-semitic.

    When the IDF ventured into Lebanon in the early 1980's and left 20,000 civilians dead in the wake of that militancy, none other than Pres Ron Reagan was upset. He lambasted Israeli leaders for this incursion and he focused on the massive injuries to one Lebanese girl to make the point that killing civilians was wrong.

    These days a president making those statements would probably be impeached.

    Since Oct 8th 2023, the public has witnessed atrocity after atrocity go down in Gaza. Although it soon seemed apparent that much of this was simple revenge rather than being a war strategy to bring down Hamas, a point now proven by the fact that Hamas leaders still seems to be alive and well, the US government under Biden accepted the idea that any civilians that were killed had their deaths occur due to being human shields.

    But once the Spring 2025 footage of what Gaza actually looked like after 18 months of IDF activity as videoed by drones was released, the public began to see that the situation could not be excused. Since that point in time, 61% of Americans find Israel to be deserving of contempt. Americans are tired of AIPAC money having so much clout in terms of choosing who is selected to run in American elections and who ends up winning.

    We are tired of knowing that Mark Zuckerberg runs FB according to his doing what he is told to do. The situation on X is a bit better as you most likely won't be banned for not supporting Israel, but your posts will be given less of a shot of being visible.

    The public is aware that the main way that Bibi Netanyahu hopes to change Americans' minds is by enacting a set of Noahide laws. He has announced this policy as being the eighth strategy of winning the war. And the public is witnessing the policy of deporting students here on visas who speak out for Palestine as ongoing policy. As well as policies that involve people being fired for speaking out.

    In other words, our First Amendment, which we have always held most dear, is to be muzzled, "for the greater good."

    And if we suggest that that greater good might not be for our nation's greater good, but for that of Israel, then we are labeled anti-semite.

    But maybe being an anti-semite is better than being anti-American. Because if you are not for the free discussion of ideas, and if you support the muzzling of the First Amendment, how American are you?

  • MODERATOR • CHARTER MEMBER

    To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    Randy Weivoda@RandyWeivoda·22h
    ReplyingtoCarolJoy, Not So Easy To Kill

    CarolJoy, Not So Easy To Kill (View Comment):

    Let's look at how in relative terms, Americans have witnessed rather quickly some immense changes that have come about from the pro-Zionist portion of America's Jews, with regards to labelling people as anti-semites and labelling today's social media's comments as anti-semitic.

    When the IDF ventured into Lebanon in the early 1980's and left 20,000 civilians dead in the wake of that militancy, none other than Pres Ron Reagan was upset. He lambasted Israeli leaders for this incursion and he focused on the massive injuries to one Lebanese girl to make the point that killing civilians was wrong.

    These days a president making those statements would probably be impeached.

    Since Oct 8th 2023, the public has witnessed atrocity after atrocity go down in Gaza. Although it soon seemed apparent that much of this was simple revenge rather than being a war strategy to bring down Hamas, a point now proven by the fact that Hamas leaders still seems to be alive and well, the US government under Biden accepted the idea that any civilians that were killed had their deaths occur due to being human shields.

    But once the Spring 2025 footage of what Gaza actually looked like after 18 months of IDF activity as videoed by drones was released, the public began to see that the situation could not be excused. Since that point in time, 61% of Americans find Israel to be deserving of contempt. Americans are tired of AIPAC money having so much clout in terms of choosing who is selected to run in American elections and who ends up winning.

    We are tired of knowing that Mark Zuckerberg runs FB according to his doing what he is told to do. The situation on X is a bit better as you most likely won't be banned for not supporting Israel, but your posts will be given less of a shot of being visible.

    The public is aware that the main way that Bibi Netanyahu hopes to change Americans' minds is by enacting a set of Noahide laws. He has announced this policy as being the eighth strategy of winning the war. And the public is witnessing the policy of deporting students here on visas who speak out for Palestine as ongoing policy. As well as policies that involve people being fired for speaking out.

    In other words, our First Amendment, which we have always held most dear, is to be muzzled, "for the greater good."

    And if we suggest that that greater good might not be for our nation's greater good, but for that of Israel, then we are labeled anti-semite.

    But maybe being an anti-semite is better than being anti-American. Because if you are not for the free discussion of ideas, and if you support the muzzling of the First Amendment, how American are you?

    Muzzling the First Amendment would be calling for the government to punish a company for speech. I didn't see anything in the post asking for that. His chief complaint is that users who aren't looking for or following anti-Israel content are having that content recommended to them.

  • To read this bio, please join Ricochet.

    CarolJoy, Not So Easy To Kill@CarolJoy·3h
    ReplyingtoRandy Weivoda

    CarolJoy, Not So Easy To Kill (View Comment):

    Let's look at how in relative terms, Americans have witnessed rather quickly some immense changes that have come about from the pro-Zionist portion of America's Jews, with regards to labelling people as anti-semites and labelling today's social media's comments as anti-semitic.

    When the IDF ventured into Lebanon in the early 1980's and left 20,000 civilians dead in the wake of that militancy, none other than Pres Ron Reagan was upset. He lambasted Israeli leaders for this incursion and he focused on the massive injuries to one Lebanese girl to make the point that killing civilians was wrong.

    These days a president making those statements would probably be impeached.

    Since Oct 8th 2023, the public has witnessed atrocity after atrocity go down in Gaza. Although it soon seemed apparent that much of this was simple revenge rather than being a war strategy to bring down Hamas, a point now proven by the fact that Hamas leaders still seems to be alive and well, the US government under Biden accepted the idea that any civilians that were killed had their deaths occur due to being human shields.

    But once the Spring 2025 footage of what Gaza actually looked like after 18 months of IDF activity as videoed by drones was released, the public began to see that the situation could not be excused. Since that point in time, 61% of Americans find Israel to be deserving of contempt. Americans are tired of AIPAC money having so much clout in terms of choosing who is selected to run in American elections and who ends up winning.

    We are tired of knowing that Mark Zuckerberg runs FB according to his doing what he is told to do. The situation on X is a bit better as you most likely won't be banned for not supporting Israel, but your posts will be given less of a shot of being visible.

    The public is aware that the main way that Bibi Netanyahu hopes to change Americans' minds is by enacting a set of Noahide laws. He has announced this policy as being the eighth strategy of winning the war. And the public is witnessing the policy of deporting students here on visas who speak out for Palestine as ongoing policy. As well as policies that involve people being fired for speaking out.

    In other words, our First Amendment, which we have always held most dear, is to be muzzled, "for the greater good."

    And if we suggest that that greater good might not be for our nation's greater good, but for that of Israel, then we are labeled anti-semite.

    But maybe being an anti-semite is better than being anti-American. Because if you are not for the free discussion of ideas, and if you support the muzzling of the First Amendment, how American are you?

    Randy Weivoda (View Comment):

    Muzzling the First Amendment would be calling for the government to punish a company for speech. I didn't see anything in the post asking for that. His chief complaint is that users who aren't looking for or following anti-Israel content are having that content recommended to them.

    Okay, so what some other people discovered some months ago is that on X, an algo exists to direct things to your page that you have never shown interest in before. The idea is that maybe once you become aware, for example, that there are people who post baseball scores of the team in your area, then you will want to use X for sports discussions too.

    So this introduction to the opposite point of view regarding Israel/Palestine is something an ardently pro_israel person would find aggravating. Believe me, people have complained about this feature even when all it did was put recipes for cakes and pies on their feed. And that situation is a sweeter one to deal with than opposing viewpoints about the conflict in the Middle Est.

Trending

Become a member.

Tired of the toxicity of social media? Why not join Ricochet? Think of it as an online bar. Come in, have a drink, hang out, say whatever you want. But don’t badger, bully, or berate the other drinkers. That's our only rule. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.

Join Ricochet

Get the Ricochet app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
  • •
  • •