Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet for just $5/month. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free.












































Discussion (20)
MODERATOR
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
I found this post challenging. On the one hand the "gender affirming" mutilations and other rending of healthy body parts reflecting mental illness are clear desecrations. But where do you draw the line? Is any surgical modification a desecration of your Creation? Clearly the removal of cancerous parts of your body or other potentially life threatening conditions (e.g. appendicitis, etc) are not desecrations unless you believe in predestination. Then you have "cosmetic" changes. I put that in quotes because breast augmentation changes your appearance while some rhinoplasties actually improve nasal functionality. Then there are breast reductions to reduce back pain and other ailments. Are implants of various sorts, desecrations? Certainly we have examples of body modifications not involving "gender affirming care" that also bespeak of mental illness (e.g. "cat" lady, and horns).
I am truly sympathetic with the "desecration" argument. Ideally we would all learn to accept our and other's bodies as the result of creation, and to not judge or shame one another or ourselves. And we should not be reliant on the surgeon to deliver outcomes that could be achieved through lifestyle choices. It is complicated. And I don't want to oversimplify it, even as extreme cases that negate fundamental biological functions are (IMO) beyond ethical limits for surgeons and other medical professionals.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Great comment, @Rodin. I hope I didn't oversimplify the issue. In my perception, most of your questions can be answered by asking, am I doing this out of ego or out of physical necessity? For example, breast reduction has a practical, health benefit. If a person is getting a nose job to breathe better, to me that's different than doing it for aesthetics. A person who amputates his legs--there is no health benefit--unless he has a cancerous leg. I had a breast removed because I had a tumor, but I didn't have both breasts removed. A child that has a cleft palate and can have that corrected, should--for health and aesthetic reasons. So I think, from my perspective, a person has to be honest.
On TV I see the Shriner's Hospital commercials with children who have all kinds of what-we-would-call deformities--born without arms and legs. I saw one little boy play the piano with his feet, and have seen a woman who paints art with her feet. If either one of them could be fitted with prostheses, good for them (which is the opposite of having a body part removed). I just think we should have a reverence for our bodies, however we are born.
Edit: It also seems that those parts of our bodies that contribute to procreation are especially sacred: our sexual organs
MODERATOR
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Amen.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Not gonna lie, this will have the opposite of the effect desired in nearly all cases.
CHARTER MEMBER
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
If an individual on reaching his majority is bound and determined to "correct" the circumstances of his birth, there will always be those around to oblige him – if the price is right.
Counseling children to do so is evil. May they receive justice, both in this world and the next.
You're seeing five of 20 comments. Sign in, or join for just $5 per month, to read them all and add your own.