Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet for just $5/month. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free.












































Discussion (4)
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Islam began very early in its history (within just a couple of hundred years of its founding) to conquer new territories and peoples by violent means, insisting that the locals adopt Islamic practices. Which suggests that violence is built into the fabric of the "religion."
With some rare exceptions, Christianity has sought to persuade, not to conquer by force.
Judaism was (in my opinion) supposed to persuade other peoples that following the Hebrew example of maintaining a relationship with the Almighty G-d is the way to go. Force and violence seem to be limited to times and places in which others tried to prevent the Hebrew Jews from worshipping G-d as they had been instructed. (I think that the Hebrew people erred in coming to see Judaism as exclusively for the Hebrew people, but that's a different discussion.)
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Even in the earliest recorded Judaic intercessory prayer (Abram pleading on behalf of Sodom, Genesis 18:16-33), Abram uses logic (rationality) in his plea to G-d, suggesting that from the very earliest direct interaction, humans understood that G-d operated on rational bases. The G-d of Judeo-Christian history is a rational G-d. Yes, He sometimes acts in ways we don't understand, but such occasions seem to be more a function of our lack of understanding than G-d's irrationality.
One of the characteristics one sees in the local deities that the Almighty G-d showed Himself to be superior was the irrationality of the local deities. The people could plead with those local deities, but with no assurance such deities would respond in any logical or rational way. It is hard to maintain a relationship with a deity that is irrational, arbitrary, and capricious.
What I hear from Islamists suggests that they view "Allah" is an irrational deity that responds arbitrarily and capriciously to inputs.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
The lecture was mainly targeted at a Western audience- not Islamic. The West has fallen deeply under the influence of Nietzsche and Sartre and the Frankfurt school. In that milieu, truth does exist and it is all about choice/power. It is a voluntaristic conception of humanity (and for some Christians, God). The implications are large…for a taste of the issues:
wordonfire.org
Open link
edwardfeser.blogspot.com
Open link
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
I assume that rather than "truth does exist" you meant to say truth DOES NOT exist according to Nietzsche etc.
Yes, those links are good, I also like this one.
In considering your comment and what you have linked, it is important to understand what theological "voluntarism" or Divine Command Theory is ... the assertion that God is not bounded by reason ... the Islamic view of their god