Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.












































Discussion (5)
CONTRIBUTOR
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Interesting. Stupid idea here.
That phrase "Subject to the jurisdiction thereof", that ought to apply a paradox to sanctuary cities. If the illegals are subject to the jurisdiction of the federal government then they can't be granted sanctuary, because sanctuary denies that jurisdiction. But if the illegals aren't, then their kids can't be birthright citizens, because the text of the Amendment doesn't apply to them. It seems like setting up a Sanctuary citizen actually hoses any illegals that would take advantage of it.
That is, if the whole concept of sanctuary cities had any relation to logic at all.
CHARTER MEMBER
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
After listeing to Richard outline his position, I’m still not certain I know what it is.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Richard may not either. It wouldn't be the first time.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
If the Wong Kim Ark decision really means, as Prof. Yoo says, that nothing more than physical presence in the United States at the time of birth is required for United States citizenship, why did the Court spend so much of the opinion describing the immigration status of the parents? The Court’s extensive description of the parents’ immigration status strongly suggests that the parents’ immigration status matters, and in turn that “subject to the jurisdiction” means more than just physical presence at the time of birth.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
And all diplomats, travelers, etc, are physically present if their child is born while they're in the US, but nobody ever thought that meant their children are automatically citizens.