Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.












































Discussion (3)
CONTRIBUTOR
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
I don't think I'm ever again going to accept from Richard Epstein the principle that you have to follow the law as written. If the Federal Reserve is such a good idea amend the Constitution to put it in there. Either the law is the law and we follow it, or it's the law and good ideas in which case why do I care about the law? Oh, and the law is literally a suicide pact, otherwise how can you legally execute anyone?
Frankly, we've been letting that sort of thing slide for far too long. If we need a power in the Constitution, amend the Constitution or do without. We can start by reverting Vermont to a territory until there's a power to admit new states. Okay, that one's a bit facetious, but apply that to some of the other questions posed this episode. Can the president unilaterally bugger out of a treaty? Tell you what, why not amend the constitution to say so explicitly. Can congress control hiring and firing in the executive branch? Why are you relying on a Supreme Court precedent when you could amend the constitution and get a resolution in there explicitly? Okay, we don't want to amend the constitution for everything, but that treaty question, that seems important enough to get it in writing. And the appointments stuff; it came up for Andrew Johnson, it came up in that case Professor Epstein cited, it's come up recently with respect to independent prosecutors, it seems like maybe that's a thing that ought to be settled explicitly.
"But getting amendments is hard." Yeah, if I stop paying taxes, you think the judge is going to accept me saying it's too hard?
Either We The People are sovereign, in which case we ought to get the rules in writing, or we're ruled by a clerisy of lawyers, and may the best paid win.
CHARTER MEMBER
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Usually the power to exit from the treat is spelled out in the treaty itself.
CONTRIBUTOR
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
The question on the Podcast was NATO. If the US took Greenland by force that'd be an attack on a NATO ally, which would pretty much end that treaty. I think there was some mention on the show of the provision of the treaty that allows for a country leaving, but that none exists for forcibly removing one, as presumably the balance of NATO would want to do after such an attack. Beyond that the hosts discussed the general case, as to whether the Senate's power to confirm treaties meant that also only a similar vote could dissolve them, and paralleled it to the question of presidential appointments and firing.
I don't much mind the discussion, seeing as this is a podcast about legal questions, but I figure it has about as much real world applicability as a psychoanalysis of Abraham Lincoln. Should Trump invade Greenland the question isn't 'is this legal' but 'who can stop him?' Much as I like tweaking Europeans you can put me in the 90% of the electorate who does not think Trump should invade. I would hope that, should he do something like that, the Congress would stop him, presumably by zeroing out the military budget.