Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.












































Discussion (3)
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
This graphic points to an important legal consideration with regards to sitting presidents:
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
John was on fire talking about executive power in this discussion with Henry. Particularly interesting to me was their speculation about the extent to which the executive's power could reach down the ranks of civil service to fire public employees. But their tentative settlement on drawing the line at the divide between management and labor that, in a union setting, bars management personnel from joining a collective bargaining unit, seemed incomplete.
Putting aside whether the firing line should be drawn at a management/labor divide, there was a problem with the fundamental approach they were taking, which implicitly relied on an assumption that the positions from which the employees are being fired would be refilled.
What I was hoping they would address is the situation where--as in mass layoff situations--positions would not be refilled. In those cases, it shouldn't matter whether the employee was a manager or among the ranks of labor.
When it comes to executive power and the layoffs that Trump is planning by eliminating positions, the questions should have focused on:
1. Whether the executive branch did or could have created the position. I assume that the various departments and other bureaucracies have seen mushroomed payrolls over the decades. Congress may provide funding for those increased jobs in its budget allocations, but isn't it the executive branch that creates the new positions and hires? If the executive branch has the power to create new positions, shouldn't it also have the power to eliminate those positions?
2. If the executive branch does not have the power to eliminate positions in the executive branch bureaucracy, does that power belong instead to Congress? If so, growing the bureaucracy will necessarily be a ratchet affair, ever growing, because that body doesn't have the te$tic1e$ to cut anything.
CEO's in the private sector have to make tough layoff decisions in tough times. The president, as our country's CEO, should have the same latitude and power.
Change my mind!
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
I agree with your thinking.
As far as number two, Congress loves having positions that its talentless progeny can occupy.
In the old days, politicians were outed as being corrupt when they died. For instance after a Chicago alderman died, oodles of shoeboxes would be found in the garage, filled to the brim with pennies nickels and dimes from city parking meters.
Now a corrupt politician can just see to it that their friends, associates, and the relatives of big time donors get to hold an important spot in the EPA's division of "Counting Populations of Rare Fish Species" or whatever. If there isn't yet such a division inside the EPA, once that Congress critter has the clout, they'll see that it comes about.