Become a member.Become a Ricochet member.
Looking for better conservative conversation? Join Ricochet. Think of it as your neighborhood bar: familiar faces, lively debate, and room for a different point of view. Plus: listen to most of our podcasts ad-free. Take $15 off the first year of any annual membership with code: WELCOME15.












































Discussion (137)
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
Fascinating post, GD. I'm afraid I don't understand these sentences. Am I missing something? And did he consider himself the redeemer, or did his disciples call him that? And what will be won? (I must be really thick this morning...)
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
During WWII in Europe German occupation meant puppet governments in every nation they occupied with the exception of Poland. Ukraine, the Baltic States, and parts of Russia were an active battleground.
There was some heroic resistance to the occupiers and there was some collaboration with the occupiers. One should praise the courage of those who resisted. One should remember to temper their criticism of those who resented German occupation but did not act. The SS and Gestapo were ruthless, and court was conducted in a basement. Executions were carried out in basements, forests, and concentration camps.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
But it's important that this event "actually happened" isn't it? The meaning would be very different if the Danes never actually saved any Jews, but people just told stories that they did. Then the myth would be just an illusion, because while there actually was the great collective moral failure, there never was actually a great collective moral victory.
And does the importance that it actually happened somehow diminish with time? If the story is told two centuries from now, will it then no longer matter if it actually happened?
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
And not every country had the cultural "equipment," so to speak, to resist in unison. France had its own deep-seated anti-Semitism. IMHO, the people of Holland, having been occupied by (then rescued from) Germany twice in the lifetimes of many of its inhabitants, did not have a national identity that included successful resistance to aggression. That is not to say that individual Dutch did not resist---they did, and splendidly. What Denmark had---and this was either providential or accidental, take your pick---was a national identity, more or less consciously constructed in the 19th c. under the guidance of theologian H.S.F. Gruntvig; one that provided and inculcated a theological grounding for the early emancipation and full citizenship of Denmark's Jews. Thus, when the test came, the Danes as a group had been practicing what turned out to be a morally crucial cultural habit. The rescuer did not need to be counter-cultural in order to recognize and resist Germany's vicious anti-semitism. The individual rescuer had the implicit moral support of his entire country. That makes a big difference when someone is deciding whether or not to risk his or her life to defend the target of a more powerful entity's aggression.
That there were as many rescues of Jews as there were in all Nazi-occupied countries argues strongly that European culture as a whole retained elements that stiffened moral spines even if strong anti-Semitism still existed, along with ordinary human selfishness and human cowardice. One of these elements was clearly, often explicitly, the presence and tradition (as well as the practice) of Christianity.
That Naziism was not Christian and was in fact anti-Christian meant that Christianity (if not necessarily Christian institutions) remained a source of legitimate moral identity even if the national identity failed. WWJD? (The same, by the way, was true for the role of Christianity in anti-slavery and anti-Jim Crow campaigns.)
In Gaza, by contrast, there has been no recorded instance of any Gazan civilian rescuing even an infant Israeli hostage.
To read this bio, please join Ricochet.
It's an interesting question, isn't it?
We are too inclined to imagine that other peoples' mythologies "didn't actually happen." That is, that they were completely made up and bear no relation to events that a time-traveling historian could document by actually being there.
One of the events that will, according to science, actually happen is the rupture of the Cascadia Subduction Zone. It will result in a catastrophic earthquake and tsunami and wreak destruction of Biblical proportions.
One of the early clues to the danger was provided by the oral tradition of Indians who lived in the Pacific Northwest for centuries before Europeans arrived. Having survived the last Big One in 1700 (January 23rd, to be precise, at 9 pm) the human experience of that disaster were inevitably understood and described through the lens of their culture, but the meaning was understood: Don't count on your environment to be peaceful. Pay attention. Be prepared.
It was, in other words, mythologized. That doesn't mean it didn't happen. And yes, it matters that it did happen---it matters a whole lot, as it turns out.
Europeans and, later, Americans, incapable of translating the Indians stories not just into English but into reality, built cities, but perhaps more importantly, constructed a culture and cultural identity that assumes the ground won't shake and the sea won't rise and swallow the land and all its helpless inhabitants.
You're seeing five of 137 comments. Sign in, or join for just $5 per month, to read them all and add your own.