Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 40 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
The Increase and Normalization of Jew Hatred
COS Lt. Gen. Benny Gantz, Maj. Gen. Tal Russo and Brig. Gen. Yossi Bachar visiting sites where rockets hit in Southern Israel. Via Wikimedia Commons
For the last few weeks, I’ve noticed that the number of stories on Jew-hatred and actions against Israel seems to have increased. I decided to check out my perceptions of the current situation, and unfortunately my perceptions were confirmed.
To explain the data I collected, I organized information on increases under three categories: internationally, nationally, and in Israel. Although the first two categories overlap to some degree with the last, I think the divisions are helpful for reviewing the information.
Increases Internationally of Jew Hatred
The movement to Boycott-Divest-Sanction was minimally successful in attacking the country of Israel. But since the October 7 attack, participation has grown substantially:
Years of pro-Palestinian campaigning for a global boycott against Israel once found limited support. But in the months since the war in Gaza began, support for the isolation of Israel has grown and widened well beyond Israel’s war effort.
The shift has the potential to alter Israeli careers, hurt businesses and weigh on the economy of a country of nine million people that depends on international cooperation and support for defense, commerce and scientific research.
When an ethics committee at Ghent University in Belgium recommended terminating all research collaborations with Israeli institutions in late May, Israeli computational biologist Eran Segal didn’t see it coming.
The overall impact, over time, could be consequential:
The spate of new political and legal initiatives against Israel is unprecedented, said Eran Shamir-Borer, former head of the international law department in the Israeli military. They include moves against Israel and its leaders at the United Nations’ top court and the International Criminal Court.
‘I think there is definitely reason for concern for Israel,’ said Shamir-Borer, now a fellow at the Israel Democracy Institute. ‘Becoming a pariah state means that even if things don’t happen formally, less companies feel that they want to invest in Israel in the first place, less universities want to collaborate with Israeli institutions. Things just happen when you get this symbolic status.’
In addition to these restrictions, Israelis have been banned from conferences and from collaborating with other scientists and universities. Even fund managers in Europe are taking action. Norway’s largest private pension fund, KLP, has responded:
KLP unloaded over $68 million in shares in U.S. company Caterpillar in late June, citing a statement by the U.N. human-rights commission that said arms transfers to Israel could violate human rights and international humanitarian laws and called on 11 multinational companies—including Caterpillar—to end exports to Israel. Caterpillar didn’t respond to a request for comment.
University bans are becoming more widespread:
More than 20 universities in Europe and Canada have adopted such bans, she said. An Israeli student who was preparing to study at the University of Helsinki said she was already looking for housing in Finland—until the school told her in May that it had suspended its exchange agreements with Israeli universities.
There’s no indication that these bans will decrease in the future.
National Evidence of Growing Jew-Hatred
Although the number of pro-Palestinian/anti-Israel protests taking place on college campuses has dropped, they may reappear in the fall term. Meanwhile, serious and violent activities have demonstrated that these activities are continuing. On June 8, the following protest took place:
Thousands of pro-Palestinian protesters in Washington converged around the White House on Saturday, urging President Biden to stop all military aid to Israel and calling for an immediate cease-fire in Israel’s war in Gaza.
Holding signs calling Mr. Biden a liar, the protesters, mostly clad in red and bearing Palestinian flags, marched around the block of parkland where the White House sits. They spilled across two six-lane boulevards, pushing out tourists, whose faces showed variations of confusion, anger or intrigue. The police presence was heavy, and the U.S. Park Police used pepper spray against a protester at least once.
Many of the protesters on Saturday chanted slogans that some groups have said incite violence against Jews, such as ‘There is only one solution: intifada, revolution,’ as well as ‘From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.’
Washington, DC was not the only site for this type of protest.
A physician based in L.A., who requested anonymity because he fears reprisals, worked as a medic during Sunday’s [June 27] protest outside the Adas Torah synagogue in the predominantly Jewish Pico-Robertson neighborhood. During the hours-long melee, in which violent clashes broke out between pro-Palestinian supporters and pro-Israel counterprotesters, he said he treated at least 11 people, whose injuries ranged from chest pain and shortness of breath from inhaling pepper spray to a fractured arm.
‘This was probably the scariest protest I’ve been to,’ he said. ‘It was very apparent that our police weren’t there to protect us and that any acts of violence that occurred in front of them wouldn’t be met with consequences.’
Apparently, the police were told to stand down in response to this protest.
Increased Hatred Toward Israel
Israel’s neighbors have been consistent in their attitudes regarding the atrocities that were committed. In fact, interest in the October 7 atrocities appears to be fading:
To this day, there seems little-to-no interest in the fate or condition of the hostages still in Gaza. Instead, there is denial that the October 7 atrocities even took place, compared to an almost obsessive regard for the safety of, and humanitarian aid for Gazans. When the U.N. is unable to deliver the aid, Israel, not the UN, is blamed.
Local Gaza polling also confirms that overwhelmingly the Palestinians support the rule of Hamas. And Hamas has been nothing if not consistent in its attitude toward Israel:
‘Israel is a country that has no place on our land,” said Ghazi Hamad, a leading Hamas terrorist, in an interview with Lebanese TV channel LBC.
‘We must remove that country, because it constitutes a security, military, and political catastrophe to the Arab and Islamic nation, and must be finished. We are not ashamed to say this, with full force. We must teach Israel a lesson, and we will do this again and again. The Al-Aqsa Flood is just the first time, and there will be a second, a third, a fourth, because we have the determination, the resolve, and the capabilities to fight.’
In 1979, when Iran took 52 of our citizens hostage, our response at that time showed a stark contrast to how we are responding to our citizens who are being held by Hamas now:
I’m old enough to remember the yellow ribbons. In 1979, Islamic radicals in Iran took 52 Americans hostage, holding them for 444 days. The hostages’ plight captured the nation’s attention. Some of them became household names. Across the country people prayed for their release.
The crisis was the lead story on the news every night. Tying a yellow ribbon on a tree or lamppost became a public expression of sorrow and concern. Even the White House Christmas tree had one.
What a contrast to our current hostage crisis. On Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas killed more than 30 American citizens and took as many as a dozen Americans hostage. Of those who were taken, at least two have been murdered. Five, we pray, are still alive. Do you know any of their names? Have you seen one yellow ribbon?
Are the Jews so despised that their well-being is either discounted or condemned?
Published in Culture
When several hundred protestors show up carrying the same professionally made signs, Palestinian flags, and what I call a capo(s) leading the chants someone or some group is financing all of this. When the tents all look the same to occupy higher education quads and pallets appear to barricade the encampment and prevent entry to a college building someone is financing that as well.
When Russian and Iranian troll farms incite fear and violence in the US and European countries to support Hamas and social media is used to get a mob to march on locations in the United States to support Hamas it might be time for the FBI to remove a surveillance team from a Catholic church and concentrate on domestic and foreign violent supporters of Hamas.
Antisemitism is a mental disorder.
No kidding! You may have heard that the Director of National Intelligence identifed Iran as infiltrating, organizing and engaging with protestors. Big surprise, right?
There have been several protests across Europe in the last couple of months; some are allowed, some are broken up–
https://apnews.com/article/amsterdam-campus-protest-gaza-europe-palestinians-israel-1eeb4e07231ebcc6776319ff0663db66
Having made a casual survey of the literature on stupidity, I like to think I understand the mind of the left pretty well. TeeJay, before “left” and “right” became the shorthand, said the distinction is between people who think that some of us should rule over the rest, and we who think liberty is the natural and proper state of humans. Tom Sowell, digging deeper, said it’s between people who think men are perfectible and those of us who think we’re all flawed by nature.
I prefer a psychological distinction to an intellectual one. I say that people of the left are those who take their mind to be reality, and give it precedence over the one reality that we all share, the one created by God. I think that flaw, which I identify as the Fall described in Genesis 3, is the fundamental root. Sowell sees the intellectual fruit of that error, and Jefferson noted the behavioral result.
I also get that wokeness is an emotional preference and sympathy for the weak, and so Western weaklings prefer brown Arabs to white Jews. And I get that the Arabs themselves must hate the Jews, because Allah of Islam is a deity of pure power and the nature of the Western deity is reason.
And I suppose that’s why Western leftists must hate Jews too.
It’s a pretty good start on a Unified Theory of Something.
Carterpillar’s market capitalization is $161.93 billion.
They were rolling on the floor laughing.
I am just an old Presbyterian, but I don’t think I’ve seen as much antisemitism in my life. Perhaps even worse, I am becoming more convinced that ‘my’ government has a pretty direct hand in it.
Is there any way you would recommend for an ordinary citizen to let Israel know that the country is on their side and supports their rights to defend themselves (Unfortunately, I can’t afford to donate any jet fighters)
I like Jews. Even if the leftist wackos don’t.
I like Jews, even if most of them are leftist wackos who don’t like me.
Perhaps people oppose Israel because it is an exceptionally evil state. Its history is infiltration, invasion, terrorism, ethnic cleansing, wars of aggression, occupation, oppression, and lately, it’s graduating up to apartheid and genocide.
I think that it would behoove non-Israeli Jews to disassociate themselves from the behavior of Israel. I certainly know that not all Jews support Israel’s crimes, and some are among the most prominent critics. This includes some Israeli Jews, though the proportion inside Israel seems to be a lot lower.
You had such a thought-provoking post about the results of the UK election. Why couldn’t you stick to that instead of going back to your anti-semitic rants?
QED.
The title (Jew Hatred) didn’t match the content (opposition to Israel).
Maybe if Muslims didn’t have such an extensive record of oppressing Jews….
I think it’s often more of a spiritual disorder.
It metastasizes.
I always appreciate your discussions on stupidity. This time I especially appreciated the sentence above. To think one’s mind is reality is absurd and misguided. Thanks, Barfly.
Great question, WS. I think the best thing you can do is refuse to tolerate anti=Semitic discussions. You don’t have to get into an argument, but you can simply tell people they’re wrong.
Why else would they take actions to damage Israel? Because they love them? C’mon, Zafar.
People can do the wrong thing, whether I like them or not. Or the right thing. It’s what they do that matters, not whether I like them or not.
There are 193 countries in the world. Many of these countries (even our own) are doing something that we might consider “the wrong thing” at any given moment. Some of those things are pretty horrific. That a tiny country on the eastern Mediterranean is singled out as “exceptionally evil” says more about those doing the singling out than it does about that country.
I think what has happened is that the Left has embraced anti-Semitism. Not that they would call it that, of course – no, it’s “anti-Zionism.” Yeah, right….. Given how powerful the Left is, and its capture of academia and the media, I’m afraid this is the result.
If it is only “anti-Zionism,” why are Jews in this country being hounded off of campuses?
I can’t help but wonder, Jean, when the Jews on the Left will wise up. How they can stay associated with the Left, especially with recent events, is beyond me.
I guess it’s the evil genius of Hamas that they can convert overt lust for genocide into a world cause simply by provoking a defensive response from Israel. I am amazed at my naïveté in believing the West was beyond this pervasive Jew hatred notwithstanding any strategic disagreements regarding peace in the Middle East.
Is it really “pervasive” or is it just a few people making a lot of noise?
Good question. But there is a lot of noise, and then there is A LOT OF NOISE. It’s far louder than I would have imagined.
I admit to being completely stumped by that as well. A couple of possible explanations come to mind: one, their Jewishness is merely a box that is checked, as opposed to a lived faith, and as a result their real religion is the Leftist progressive agenda; or two, they are naive and believe that as long as they have the “correct” (meaning, Leftist) views, they will be safe. I would think that October 7th would have disabused them of the second explanation, as many of those killed were solidly in their ranks, but then clear thinking isn’t going to be found in this group. What do think, Susan?
How many would it take to make it an issue of concern? Like the protestors on college campuses, they are only a small part of the population, but they sure are intimidating a lot of people.