A Simple, Fundamentals-Based Prediction of the Presidential Election


I was at a wedding this past weekend, and the question kept coming up; who do you think is going to win? My answer, “I don’t know.” 

Predicting politics is a hazardous activity, and people are often wrong for some of the right reasons and right for the wrong reasons. But I think it’s important to make predictions and then conduct a postmortem, win or lose. We can learn a lot by proposing and testing hypotheses.

I am deeply uncertain about this election because there are many conflicting pieces of evidence and a huge number of important unknowns (both known and unknown). 

So let’s strip all of this down to the basics; 7-point partisan identification now, the shift in the partisan breakdown from all registered voters to ACTUAL validated voters in 2008, and the Obama/McCain vote share of each partisan category in 2008. 

I’m using the last NBC/WSJ poll from October for the 7-point Party ID because they report the breakdown then for all registered voters, not their stab at “likely voters.” The reported “likely voter” numbers are guesswork, not sampling science, but I think the polls of all registered voters as a starting point are pretty accurate.

I then get my prediction of the actual electorate this year by looking at the shift in partisan makeup in 2008 from all registered voters to all actual, validated voters using data from the CCES project. In other words, what was the actual drop-off in the percentage of pure independents in 2008? How much did the Strong Republican share increase? 

Here’s my prediction of what the national electorate will look like this year:

Party ID is hugely predictive of the vote. So I looked at the two-party vote for each of the 7-point party ID categories:


Finally, I assigned the same vote share to the predicted 2012 electorate. Obama wins, by a hair, if turnout is the same as 2008, if every category of partisan votes in the same proportions as 2008, if all that has changed is the mix of partisan identification.

But I don’t think those are very reasonable assumptions. So, what happens if turnout is down for the Dems and up for the Republicans, or if vote preferences have shifted on top of Party ID?

The table below lays out two, I think fairly conservative, scenarios where Romney wins, just barely. 


The basic facts make this election a tossup, and I think the mood of the country (not to mention the evidence from 2010) make a 3-point swing in partisan turnout AND a 3-point swing in the pure independent vote more likely than not.

My prediction: Romney wins, narrowly.

My caveats:

  1. Although I think it is unlikely, Romney could lose the election by losing in Ohio due to Obama’s dominance in the ad wars (both in terms of number of ads aired and their effectiveness in moving the vote), as well as the far more sophisticated and effective GOTV efforts on the Left.
  2. Although I think it is unlikely, Romney could win while losing Ohio for some of the same reasons; the Left’s ads and GOTV game pushes them over the finish line in Ohio, but in one or more “safe” Blue states where the Left has been mostly absent, the natural, underlying shift in turnout and preferences is able to deliver a winning Republican surge. In other words, Romney could lose Ohio but win with Pennsylvania or Wisconsin because the Left worked it’s magic in the former and not in the latter.
  3. Finally, again unlikely, Romney could fall just short in Ohio and the closing “Blue” states, losing the election but winning the popular vote.

There are 8 comments.

  1. Thatcher

    This is making me sick. I was a 9 out of 10 confident in a big Romney win yesterday morning and now I’m in full meltdown Eeyore. Now I feel like, best case senario is Romney squeaks by and we don’t take the Senate. How is he supposed to govern in that environment?

    We needed a huge, clarifying election in order to eliminate Obamacare, and suddenly it seems more likely Obama will squeak it out. No one is talking about the surprise Romney blowout anymore, and I’m starting to wonder if we were seeing what we wanted to see in the Rasmusen and Gallup numbers. Were they truly outliers? Did Sandy (and Christie) come at just the right time to completely screw us over, or have Democrats finally cobbled together their government-dependent class warfare governing majority?

    • #1
    • November 6, 2012 at 9:41 am
    • Like
  2. Member

    Very sharp analysis. Before getting depressed keep in mind that his analysis is based on registered voters. The key to a possible bigger Romney win is the conversion of registered voters to actual voters. There is some evidence that the conversion of potential Romney supporters to actual voters will be higher this year, so this analysis would be a worst case scenario.

    • #2
    • November 6, 2012 at 10:00 am
    • Like
  3. Inactive

    I can explain it in one short paragraph:

    The only way Obama can win is if turnout this year matches 2008. It won’t. Romney wins.

    • #3
    • November 6, 2012 at 10:04 am
    • Like
  4. Contributor

    Is anyone else disturbed about all the talk about “banked” votes? One can make some assumptions based on party registration but those ballots are still uncounted and supposedly secret still, yes?

    • #4
    • November 6, 2012 at 10:18 am
    • Like
  5. Thatcher
    ConservativeWanderer: I can explain it in one short paragraph:

    The only way Obama can win is if turnout this year matches 2008. It won’t. Romney wins. · 3 minutes ago

    That’s the kind of thinking that’s kept me optimistic for so long. And it still makes total sense. Then the question comes to coattails. What are our chances of reaching even 50 in the Senate? I’d rather not depend on Joe Manchin, even though he ran against Obamacare. Would Harry Reid let a Obamacare gutting reconciliation vote get past him if he new it would pass?

    • #5
    • November 6, 2012 at 10:20 am
    • Like
  6. Member
    ConservativeWanderer: I can explain it in one short paragraph:

    The only way Obama can win is if turnout this year matches 2008. It won’t. Romney wins. · 21 minutes ago

    Or voter fraud.

    • #6
    • November 6, 2012 at 11:00 am
    • Like
  7. Inactive

    I guess I just wish I could find a conservative blog today with some upbeat information. I am OUTA here.

    • #7
    • November 6, 2012 at 11:05 am
    • Like
  8. Contributor
    Adam Schaeffer Post author
    AnnaS: I guess I just wish I could find a conservative blog today with some upbeat information. I am OUTA here. · 1 hour ago

    Hey! I thought this was a pretty optimistic take on things!

    I do think Romney will win . . . but I think this is going to be hard-fought.

    • #8
    • November 7, 2012 at 12:19 pm
    • Like