Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Minneapolis Lunacy: A Recipe for Disaster
This morning my blood ran cold when I heard the latest recommendation from the Minneapolis City Council: disband the police department. Sundance at the Conservative Tree House explains the background for this action:
The term ‘community policing’ has been used for several years by groups advocating for radical changes to law enforcement; however, behind the innocuous phrase is really a much more serious agenda.
If each community can determine the enforcement of law, then essentially all communities can eliminate the underlying law itself. Remove local enforcement of law and the local community can independently assemble a social structure separate from all other binding contracts that frame a larger societal compact.
This is not the community-oriented policing that Rudy Giuliani instituted in New York. These actions, instead, would be the perfect recipe for lawlessness and chaos.
Spearheading this action is Jeremiah Ellison, the son of Minnesota Attorney Keith Ellison, a Muslim activist and far Left advocate:
Jeremiah Ellison, the son of Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison and a representative of the city’s Ward 5, explicitly led calls to ‘dramatically rethink’ how the city keeps its people safe.
‘We are going to dismantle the Minneapolis Police Department,’ he tweeted. “And when we’re done, we’re not simply gonna glue it back together. We are going to dramatically rethink how we approach public safety and emergency response. It’s really past due.’
Lisa Bender, president of the city council, sent out this warning:
On Wednesday she posted a thread about how a ‘white person’ should think about dismantling the police.
‘If you are a comfortable white person asking to dismantle the police I invite you to reflect: are you willing to stick with it? Will you be calling in three months to ask about garage break-ins? Are you willing to dismantle white supremacy in all systems, including a new system?’ she said. ‘I mean this quite sincerely & seriously: just look at recent conversations about City-funded neighborhood organizations to understand how explicitly we would have to work to establish alternative systems that do not replicate the same problems. White ppl need to show up for this.’
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I think Ms. Bender is telling the white people in Minneapolis that if the deprived black people attack the homes of the white community or commit any other offenses, get over it. Pay back is tough.
The city council is due to vote on this issue today.
Published in Policing
In the federalist America of my dreams all the the progressives move to 25 states and all the conservatives move to the other 25 states and they get to enact all their dream policies. Take away the federal government’s ability to print money and force policy on states and progressivism get’s real untenable real quick.
The parasite cannot survive without the host.
Great post Susan. I was almost ready to post about this end the Police Nonsense myself. It is really important and people have to understand what this is really about.
I am surprised no one has mentioned this yet, but one must understand that the Left wants chaos. Ending the police guarantees chaos in a huge way.
The Left wants an revolutionary atmosphere were all the positive public institutions are questioned and eventually discarded in favor of a Leftist oriented mob rule which quickly begets a nasty thuggish Marxist Dictatorship where there are no rights. At all. Chaos is best way to initiate and foment a revolutionary atmosphere that will lead to the Left’s dream revolution. Ending the police is the means to Chaos and Chaos is best vehicle to lead to revolution and the end of our Republic.
That is also what much of the Pandemic Lockdown is about; bring about chaos. This end the Police nonsense is intricately intertwined with pushing the disruption of our rights through a lockdown.
I know some of the libertarians here want to talk about reform and such and about how dismantling the police as we know them in some sort of enlightened process, but this process once it gets started is going to move quickly downhill into street warfare, mayhem and chaos. No doubt about it.
Earlier today I was watching a youtube video about St. Patrick. Patrick grew up in Britannia, an advanced, productive, imminently civilized colony of Rome in what we now called England just as the Roman Imperial Guard was leaving Britannia as the Roman Empire collapsed. Barbaric Irish marauders took him as a slave as Irish slave raiding parties increased exponentially as the Guard left. Patrick was a slave for 6 years in Ireland in a barbaric society that had no towns, nor roads, no industry, no learning and was bereft with infighting among the clans before he escaped back to Britannia. But Britannia in the six years he was gone became engulfed in almost total chaos. Civilized society had dissolved quickly after he left and in the next few decades, the Britains, except for a few peoples in Wales, Cornwall and northeast Britain were enslaved almost totally by Angle, Saxon and Fresian mercenaries they had brought to Britain to protect themselves. Britannia society was decimated. Very quickly. This is what happens when civil order is not defended by something like a police force.
Exactly why such an “experiment” would help no one. Evidently, few Democrats learn from their mistakes when they abandon the cities and states they despoiled. Evidently, few journalists learn from events and report the failures of Democrat policies.
People would learn what happened to the once American city by watching it happen again in their own towns after Democrat “refugees” settle there.
My deepest condolences to Lileks and others who are watching their towns burn and bluster. I pray for a swift resolution.
Every society has a police force. You can defund it or disband it, but another force will rise up to fill the vacuum. It is a law of nature.
Wouldn’t it be more like the Balkans? The tribal territories are better delimited in Iraq and Afghanistan, and to some extent still are in Syria. When the state gets weak, the tribes still are a stabilizing force. The Somalis in Minneapolis may be ahead of the game.
We may have our hopes and our dreams but I think we all know this and we all are laboring to keep the wolf at bay.
MS 13, Crips, Bloods. La Eme. In some places veterans, or cops and retired cops.
Deciding who gets the sofa when nations divorce tends to be bloody.
But not a tradition of English common law that we’re so used to.
Even unifying under sharia would be seen as better than different laws and different enforcers and different policing “ethics” encountered block by block or neighborhood by neighborhood.
If their goals weren’t so sickening, their zeal would almost be admirable.
Life is a movie. And they’re very precious.
I don’t think community policing means that local communities determine the law. And the Minneapolis council member talking about disbanding the Minneapolis Police Department seems pretty vague on the details.
Does this really mean no more police presence in Minneapolis?
Not necessarily.
For example:
With better outcomes:
So it might be a good thing. ??
As previously mentioned, this is precisely the strategy that made Detroit the city it is today.
Nobody in the next community over necessarily cares what you think.
Disagree. Another force doesn’t rise up to replace the police. Multiple competing forces rise up to replace the police. They are called “gangs”.
You should wish that their proposal was to merely privatize the police department.
The powers-that-be have already declared that vandalism, theft, and arson are legitimate forms of protest. Do you really think that such folk will dare to oppose municipalities that rebel against the Constitution?
Crime rates only go up if crimes are reported and recorded. If you stop answering 911 calls and make sure the citizens patrol only bring back good news (assuming they venture out at all) you have a crime-free city. No reporter or social scientist in his or her right mind is going to wade into what’s left to check your reported outcomes.
One can almost smell the success on the way. If Minneapolis does this I will be expecting royalties or a consulting fee.
Without cops, who’s gonna take the guns?
Wow. Yup. Of course that will happen.
There aren’t many – stats say 92% of the cops live outside of the city.
There’s no way this leads to an unarmed “civil enforcement authority” or whatever they call it. They’re talking about a different model of policing, where you send in a social worker or mental health worker first, instead of sending in a cop who might not have the training or sensitivity or patience to deal with someone in crisis. Then you send the armed cop after the social worker was stabbed.
I could be wrong; they could be that nuts.
Yeah, no. We just had a flaming – literally – example of what you get when the cops are absent. Even if the example results in destruction and anarchy and the loss of a great American city, it wouldn’t stop the Left from attempting to implement the idea elsewhere. It would just mean Minneapolis hadn’t done it correctly.
I’m going to call my city councilperson on Monday. As a Member of the Media, I might get a call back. I will have some questions. I’ll report back when I get some answers.
Using what police force?
I think the thinking on the part of the generally deluded is that cops are brute-force symbols of patriarchal oppression, and social workers will be able to enter a violent domestic scene and bring words of compassion and enlightenment to resolve the conflict. What those who are above these deluded people think, the anarchists and anti-fa, is that they will functionally affect semi-autonomous banlieues. Those that fund the violent extremists think, this will bring about the destruction of the Western Judeo-Christian society and use violence to control the lower classes.
[Never mind.]