Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Stanislaw Lem and Real Life
I have noticed in the past several weeks the surprise by some at what it takes to run our day-to-day lives. The stunning obliviousness as to how the things that we depend on are made and transported to us. “We must shut down the interstate rest areas,” some central planner exclaimed. Only to be shocked by the fact that truck drivers have to use the bathroom. I’m sure that planner, if he had ever been to a rest area, looked at the semis parked there with a type of resignation that he must mingle with the hoi polloi in a substandard bathroom since there wasn’t an exit nearby. It never occurring to him that every item he packed for his trip had originally traveled in a semi to get to him.
This same blindness infects the discussion of what an essential business is. “We must have protein,” the planners decide. The packing plants need to remain open. But just like they have no idea of what it takes to create a pencil, they have no idea of what’s essential beyond the slaughterhouse itself. The packing plant is essential, it must be cleaned. Are the companies that sell the water hoses, mops, rags, etc., essential as well?
I’d like to think that this is a relatively new phenomenon but as King Solomon said in Ecclesiastes, “there is nothing new under the sun”. Who can argue with the wisdom of Solomon? The Polish author Stanislaw Lem saw it as well. I just finished reading Hospital of the Transfiguration. It was written by Lem in the 1940s and is set in 1943 Poland. I’d like to share the following passage with you. This is the set up; Stefan is a young doctor who was out for a walk when a bad storm rolled in. He was offered shelter at an electrical substation by the foreman, Woch. While there, he watched Woch and his team expertly manage a crisis in the grid caused by the storm.
Published in LiteratureOf all the people who used to come to [Stefan’s] father’s workshop when he was a child, it was the workers who interested him most-the machinists, locksmiths, and electricians who made various parts to order. He had been intimidated by them-they were so different from everyone he knew. They were always patient, listening to his father with silent attention, looking at the blueprints carefully, almost respectfully. But beneath the cautious politeness lay something closed and hard.
Stefan noticed that although his father liked to go on and on at the dinner table about people he had met, he never mentioned the workers as if they, in contrast to the lawyers, engineers, and merchants, had no personality. Stefan had the illusion then that their life -“real life,” as he called it-was shrouded in mystery. For some time he racked his brains over the puzzle of that “real life,” before finally concluding that the idea was foolish.
Now, lying awake in the darkness, the memory surfaced. There had been some sense in that boyish dreaming after all: there was a real life for people like Woch!
Where Uncle Ksawery propounded atheism, … his father invented, and Stefan read philosophy and talked … for months on end to recognize “real life”-that life was out there maintaining their world, shouldering it like Atlas, as inconspicuous as the ground beneath their feet. But no, he was mythologizing, because something like a mutual exchange of services went on: Anzelm knew about architecture, … he and Ksawery treated the sick. Stefan suddenly realized that nothing would really change if all of them disappeared. Whereas without Woch and others like him, the world could not go on.
He rolled over, and some obscure impulse made him turn on the nightstand lamp. It was nothing, of course, but the light struck him as a symbol, a sign that Woch was on the job. The yellow light filling the impersonal room was somehow soothing; it ensured freedom for all tasks and thought. As long as it shined, it was possible to fantasize about worlds beyond the existing one.
… he noticed an open book on the table-Lord Jim, which he had been reading. He flicked the switch and darkness surrounded him again. In a quick leap of association, he wondered whether Woch would ever read that book, but the idea was so ludicrous that he smiled in the gloom. Woch would never pick up such a book; he had no need to sail the oceans with Lord Jim. He would look on Conrad with contempt for solving on paper problems that he himself solved in reality.
This is what puzzles me about all the talk of transitioning back into a post-Covid normal. Planners will never get it right. At some point we have to say “Go out there and be careful” and just let the market find its own equilibrium.
Here’s an interesting example of “essential”….GE Healthcare, in ramping up production of ventilators, needed some 3-D printing services from a small shop. The shop had been closed as “nonessential”.
This specific problem was fixed, but how on earth would a government official…even an intelligent one…know what the role of a particular company might be in the complex web of supply chains that makes up the economy?
We think doctors are more important than craftsmen and the laborers, but they are not. They are to the one person who might be injured or sick, but they do not keep the world running. Humanity would continue whether or not there were doctors-it won’t live if we don’t have food, shelter and clothing.
Bones was a doctor – not a ship’s captain.
This is true beyond imagining.
The guys and gals who pick up our trash, who run our sewers, who create and deliver electricity, who farm our fields, who truck our veggies, who staff our stores, they do more good for society and preserve more lives than I can ever hope to do. Shut down the nation’s medical care, as we have done for 6 weeks now, and a few of us suffer, a very few of us die. Shut down the nation’s municipal water works for a couple of days, and we all die.
The complexity of modern life is mind boggling. Everyone in private industry is essential. If they were not essential, their industry would not be profitable. It’s only a matter of degree.
Open America today!
Thank you for that: Few of us have read Lem. He is one of those writers who are more talked about than read, and is read less today than 40 years ago.
Indeed. This is a fatal flaw in the old socialist fantasy of a Planned Economy. (I would say the fatal flaw but there are others.)
I hate to agree, but you are right. Visit an 18th Century graveyard and contemplate the numerous markers for children who only lived a few years. To bury one child after another is a heartbreaking tragedy that few of us can truly understand but nonetheless our societies continued and even prospered. (See Herodotus’ famous quote in his Histories about the inversion of the natural order when fathers must bury sons.)
“I have seen the future and it requires maintenance.” (to paraphrase a one-time apologist for Soviet totalitarianism.)
John,
I appreciate your concern. However, I think you fail to grasp that we are living in woketard wonderland. The average woketard, although receiving hundreds of participation trophies, actually has an IQ (adjusted for societal values drift) of a medium-sized kumquat.
Just forget it, John.
Regards,
Jim
Those who work for the municipal water works are usually municipal employees. They are absolutely essential as you state. Add police, fire, trash collectors as well. In some municipalities those supplying the electricity are as well.
I only ever read Lem’s sci-fi, but he was good.