Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Day 65: COVID-19 “Shelter-in-Place”
The US has now surpassed Italy in active COVID-19 cases. That’s the bad news. The good news is that Worldometers.com has added “Total Deaths per Million Population” Column and the US is at 3 as compared to Italy (124), Spain (73), Netherlands (21), France (20), Switzerland (18), and Belgium (15).
New York City is the epicenter of the US pandemic. Many New Yorkers are fleeing to other locations, principally Florida, and those jurisdictions are trying to contend with the possibility that this could be a new source of infection for them. Or as Dr. Birx has called them, “seeds.”
Compare and contrast New York City with two other well-reported locations of high population density — Singapore and Hong Kong. New York City is currently reporting 17,856 active cases. Singapore cases totaled 631 with 469 active cases; Hong Kong cases totaled 410 with 304 active cases. The density of the three locations are: New York City 27,751/sq mi, Singapore 20,212.3/sq mi, Hong Kong 17,552.3/sq mi. Both of the Asian locations have experience with earlier epidemics and have greater social control in their cultures. Singapore was particularly aggressive in its surveillance and quarantine and had prolific public information campaigns very early on. Hong Kong was in the midst of unrest and particularly alert to events occurring in mainland China.
Meanwhile, in my part of the country, there are a total of 2,853 cases in California with 77% of the cases being either in the San Francisco Bay area or the Los Angeles area nearly evenly divided between them.
[Note: Links to all my COVID-19 posts can be found here.]
Published in General
Weather report:
Singapore 91 F
Hong Kong 78 F
NYC 44 F
I still think heat and humidity are factors for covid-19.
Perhaps we are exaggerating its ‘novelty’?
Los Angeles 65 f
NYC 45 f
NYC 44 F
Hospitals all over the country are running out of ICU beds. It’s not just New York City.
In Texas they project that we’ll have 200,000 in need of hospitalization by the middle of May, and we have 50,000 beds. I hope and pray that’s wrong. I hope and pray that hydroxychloroquin-azithromycin is proving to work, or they find something that does now.
Well in slightly good news Italy seems to have stabilized somewhat, so it looks like their lockdown at least has had an effect.
Is it the temperature and humidity or the fact they jumped al over this early, did everything right and everyone in public wears a mask.
I guess time will tell.
I agree. 46 degree 64% H here in Mi today where I am.
If Texas has 200,000 covid patients in need of hospitalization in May I’ll buy everyone at Ricochet a new car.
Consider: Sweltering Bangkok had the most human exchange with Wuhan during the month before China locked Wuhan down. It had a flush of initial cases which then dissipated, and Bangkok is an over-crowded, poor, third-world heap. Houston has Bangkok’s weather, a teensy percentage of its virus seeding, and it’s rich. It’ll be fine.
I hope you’re right about that.
I’m not planning to think that until I have a reason to think that.
It’s not a sure thing, but it’s not too early to think about what kind of car you want.
A physician in a hot zone who has treated “hundreds” with the infection: chloroquin recommended in moderate to high risk patients in the outpatient setting. Perhaps as prophylaxis in very high risk.
Switzerland is getting hammered on a per capita basis, but it’s not really in the news much. I wonder why not?
Willis Eschenbach at WUWT has a very interesting piece about Italy:
Emphasis added. RTWT
I think the same inertia that we have seen with the CDC is operating with the therapy. I would love to know how many people with early symptoms have used hydroxychloroquine to treat the suspected infection. More importantly, testing has been very sluggish. How many people being placed on respirators have had an infusion of remdesivir? I suspect the numbers approach zero.
Yugos for everyone. Cutting edge of Serbo-Croatian technology.
Seriously though, to put that 200,000 estimate in perspective, that would mean that in two months hot Texas would have more hospitalized Covid patients than the whole of planet earth has had in the last three months.
I just can’t believe that “experts” actually believe such things. The only explanation I can come up with is that they’re lying, but for reasons that they believe to be noble. But it’s not noble.
It depends on what you mean by “hammered.”
Switzerland has a lot of cases, 1,259 per million, which is higher than Italy (1,230) and Spain (1,059). Tiny Luxembourg is actually the highest in W. Europe, with 2,129 cases per million. The US has about 199.
Switzerland has few deaths, however, about 18 per million, compared to 124 for Italy and 78 for Spain. Luxembourg is at 13, and none of the other W. European countries are over 21. The US is at less than 3.
At present, the vast bulk of the problem is in Italy and Spain.
If you combine the US and W. Europe — with a total population of about 738 million — Italy and Spain have 74% of the deaths thus far, with 15% of the population.
The problem is that there is little empirical evidence behind this claim (from an article by Jim Geraghty at National Review). There is some data on hospital occupancy — but no indication, for example, of the ordinary levels of occupancy. It would be a difficult thing to analyze, and most of the claims in Geraghty’s argument seem to be based on anticipated problems if a great many new cases arrive.
The OP shows fewer than 1,400 serious or critical cases in the entire country. I do not know whether this figure is accurate. No figure whatsoever is given in Geraghty’s article.
If “serious’ means hospitalized, and roughly 20% of hospitalized patients require ICU care (I think that this was the proportion in Italy), then we have — nationwide — a grand total of 280 additional people in the ICU and 1,120 additional people in the hospital. Based on data that I looked up about a week ago, there are over 900,000 hospital beds and about 95,000 ICU rooms in the US.
There’s a comment on that Geraghty column from an EMT (at least he says he is) who says it’s chaotic because everyone who feels a little hinky thinks they have it and they’re going to die, so they call 911. Then they have to get transmitted to the ER, take up a bed there, etc., etc. Many of the calls are media-panic driven.
Jerry, =) because you’re a sucker for data, these links refer to the same data set on hospital capacity across states.
Neil Ferguson, the Imperial College guy who was all over the news last week explaining how his computer models anticipate 1.7 million US deaths and 250,000 UK deaths, said today he now anticipates “substantially less” than 20,000 deaths in the U.K. He also said as many as two thirds of those would likely have died later this year anyway from other illnesses.
But of course he did.
This is clearly the case locally. Area ER’s are swamped. Local labs are buried in tests to be processed. And our county stands at 12 confirmed infections.
My daughter works for a hospital that has 250 total beds. The Portland area hospitals have organized a consortium to deal with the crisis in cooperation with the state health department. Her hospital has been told to prepare for 1200 ICU patients at peak in mid April. It can’t be done. I hope the projections are wrong.
I wanna see a coronavirus debate between Neil Ferguson and Niall Ferguson.
Not obscure to us geezers.
I read that too, and believe it is a true assessment. If they don’t have it know, just about everyone I know either thinks they already had it, or knows someone that thinks they had it.
Thought I heard fox business rattle a few stats, but I was driving and can’t recall the exact figures, but it seems it was 3,900+ hospitalized in NY. CNBC about 20% intensive care. prob. about 780, I’d guess, more than that tonight.
Detroit News said Beaumount is near capacity, but Henery Ford’s 5 hospitals had 170 patients at the time of the article. It also said they will be working out sharing loads between them where they can. There are also other hospitals in the area. Detroit Receiving, St. Joes, and UofM is in nearby Ann Arbor. Most of Michigan’s cases and deaths are in that cluster of counties. Grand Rapids had one death. The pattern is the larger urban areas so far. It is also not unusual for a lot of rural people to travel to one of the larger hospitals. Lots of low regard for some of the rural medical outfits. I can only think of two major hospitals in the Northern part of lower MI; Alpena General and Munson in TC. Alpena Co didn’t have one positive as of earlier today. Lots’ of old people in that NE part of Lower Mi though.
My sister’s hospital at Traverse City has about 400 beds, 50% occupancy; surgeries canceled, and corona virus ward set up with patients pending tests. 3 confirmed cases in that area so far. I’m sure there will be more. She also said they are getting a lot of people thinking they have it. They won’t test unless you are sick.
Three (or maybe 3 1/2) random observations:
It’s about time they provided per capita information when comparing countries with differing populations. The same thing should happen when comparing U.S. states.
I’ve never been to the Asian cities of Singapore and Hong Kong, but since Asia in general is so much more populous than Europe and the Americas in general, I figured that both cities would have a higher density than New York. Sometimes stereotypes are right. But this one led me wrong.
I’ve not only been reading Jim Geraghty, but Richard Epstein also. Epstein has been strongly asserting that worldwide deaths from this are unlikely to exceed 50,000. He’s starting to wobble because he also asserted that total U.S. deaths are unlikely to exceed 500, and we’re starting to get close to that mark. But if Epstein turns out to be essentially correct, there will be a reckoning towards medical leadership that were allowed to wreck our economy. That reckoning will mostly be in terms of their loss of credibility. In the U.S., the FDA and CDC have already taken a hit in credibility over their botching of getting testing kits to the public.
Speaking of which, the FDA is still not allowing home based testing kits.
In today’s “Law Talk” podcast Epstein calls that low estimate of US deaths a “howler” of a mistake and says he should have said “something like 5000”.