‘Joker’ Is Incomplete Without Batman


“What would I do without you?” The Joker asks Batman in The Dark Knight. “You complete me.” He’s right in more ways than he realizes, as the newly released Joker shows: the Joker, by his very nature, needs Batman, and, more importantly, so does the audience. Because without the Dark Knight there to serve as a ballast, the Joker’s anarchic, twisted, disturbing nature, and Joker itself, becomes unbearably difficult to watch.

Admittedly, in terms of film qua film, Joker succeeds in what it sets out to do. It’s well directed, Joaquin Phoenix turns in an incredible performance as the titular character, and the story provides creepy insight into the psyche of its psychopathic subject. And in fairness, Phoenix’s Joker is not necessarily more evil than past incarnations of the character. Heath Ledger’s turn as the Clown Prince of Crime, for example, was just as twisted, just as nihilistic. Also, Batman: The Killing Joke featured a Joker committing acts just as depraved and horrific. These Jokers, however, did not exist in a vacuum, and the stories in which they’re present also feature counters to their dangerous ideology.

Joker, in comparison, is devoid of any sort of moral challenge to its villain. Watching someone engage in truly despicable, grotesque evil on screen without anyone rising to challenge it, without any sense of hope for viewers is a truly painful experience, one that unsettled me so deeply I had to turn away from the screen on several occasions and nearly walked out at one point—and I managed to sit through the entirety of The Shape of Water, so that’s saying something. With scenes of murder that are realistically graphic and intense, it feels almost as if you’re watching artfully shot found footage of homicides. While it is unfair to say that Joker celebrates its protagonist, or even that it portrays him in a sympathetic light, the movie makes no argument against him, relying solely on the audience to pass judgement on the character.

The Dark Knight and The Killing Joke succeed just as well as Joker in diving into what makes the Joker tick, but the stories also provide an alternative to the villain’s sick worldview. Perhaps the most powerful scene in The Dark Knight comes when the Joker has tricked the city into evacuating onto two boats: one filled with the prison population, one filled with the citizens of Gotham. The boats are given detonators and the occupants are told to blow up the other boat or be killed themselves. After much debate, neither side decides to go along with the Joker’s game, resigning themselves to death rather than engaging to murder. Even under duress, they reject the Joker’s chaotic approach to life.

Joker took even more influence from The Killing Joke, which, like Joker, gives the character a backstory as a failed comedian, who turns into the murderous clown after life gets him down. Like the film it inspired, The Killing Joke was created specifically to explore the motivations of the Joker, showing how the pressures of the world finally led him to crack. But, more importantly, it also shows that he didn’t have to become what he is.

In the comic, the Joker decides he wants to prove that anyone would have gone down his path if they’d experienced the hardship he had. So, he kidnaps Commissioner Gordon, shoots and paralyzes his daughter Barbara (it’s implied that he also rapes her), then strips down the commissioner and brutalizes him. In addition to the physical torture he endures, Gordon is forced to look at pictures of what the Joker did to Barbara, yet when Batman rescues him Gordon insists that Joker be brought in “by the book.” The experience leaves him scarred but not broken, showing that it wasn’t the tragedies of the Joker’s life that created him, but rather his choice in response; that we all have such a choice to make when faced with hard times and that giving into darkness is never inevitable.

These stories succeed while the Joker fails because a foil provides real depth to the character. Seeing the ideological conflict between Joker and the forces of good draws attention to the ways in which his nihilistic view of the world falls short. While Phoenix talks a good talk about how his new film is a serious character study, Joker merely shocks and disgusts viewers with scenes of depravity. Toward the end of the movie, Joker states that he always thought his life was a tragedy, but he’s come to realize that it’s really a comedy. These are, of course, the ramblings of a madman; his life is tragic and so too is what’s been done with this film.

Published in Entertainment
Like this post? Want to comment? Join Ricochet’s community of conservatives and be part of the conversation. Join Ricochet for Free.

There are 5 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. Aaron Miller Member
    Aaron Miller

    There seems to be increasing interest in depravity as entertainment in itself. Not only do serial killers pack TV lineups, but they occasionally dominate screentime and define a show more than the detectives. So much that was once implied to occur off-screen is today lingered on in agonizing detail. 

    The Dark Knight is among my favorite films. And I can still enjoy the campy carnival ride of the previous Batman film, in which Nicholson played a similarly chaotic thrill seeker.

    But Joker‘s trailer didn’t interest me in the slightest for the same reasons I skip biopics of real serial killers. They do not have sympathetic stories. They looked into Hell and liked it.

    • #1
  2. Old Bathos Moderator
    Old Bathos

    Saw Joker this evening. A bit long, relentlessly dark but Joaquin Phoenix was truly amazing. The penultimate scene with DeNiro was the only one badly directed and wrong-paced as if somebody was so in love with the dialogue in the scene it could not get the pruning it really, really needed.

    The fictional Gotham of 1981 in this movie was so dystopian that the viewer ultimately does not care much about the victims of that shared dysfunction. Being numbed by the moral vacuity of Joker’s world is how evil can win. I left the theatre feeling about Gotham descending into chaos a bit like the way Abraham must have felt departing Sodom and Gomorrah —with limited regrets after not finding any good guys.

    • #2
  3. Bryan G. Stephens Thatcher
    Bryan G. Stephens

    I want stories were the bd guys are fought

    • #3
  4. Ray Kujawa Coolidge
    Ray Kujawa

    The reason Batman doesn’t appear in the movie is because the Joker did not want to co-star with any other star besides Joaquin Phoenix.

    • #4
  5. Western Chauvinist Member
    Western Chauvinist

    Ack! Dear @ricocheteditorsdesk. Are we really going to have to look at that nasty picture of the Joker all weekend??? I may have to sit it out. 

    • #5
Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.