Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
A Letter to the Ravelry Community
Ravelry is an online knitting and crochet community, a tremendous resource of knowledge and expertise, and the go-to place for its millions of members all over the world for both selling and buying, online knitting, and crochet patterns. It probably won’t come as a surprise to you that politics, when they infect the site, list heavily to port.
But Ravelry has just put itself at the very top of my [expletive] list. I know several members here also belong to Ravelry, and I’d like your help in getting the word out (if you agree with me). Members can contact the site here. I’ve also sent an email to info – at – ravelry – dot – com, which is an address I’ve used in the past, although I can’t be sure it’s still live. Given my Ravelry user name (which has been the same for years), I’m not expecting a chummy response. Still, I have shelves full of knitting books, a huge stash of yarn, and lots of other things to do. I expect I’ll survive.
Published in GeneralDear Ravelry:
I have just read the following announcement on the home page of Ravelry:
“We are banning support of Donald Trump and his administration on Ravelry.
This includes support in the form of forum posts, projects, patterns, profiles, and all other content. Note that your project data will never be deleted. We will never delete your Ravelry project data for any reason and if a project needs to be removed from the site, we will make sure that you have access to your data. If you are permanently banned from Ravelry, you will still be able to access any patterns that you purchased. Also, we will make sure that you receive a copy of your data.”We cannot provide a space that is inclusive of all and also allow support for open white supremacy. Support of the Trump administration is undeniably support for white supremacy.”
This is disgraceful.
Ravelry is perfectly within its rights to require that its members remove overtly political messages from their patterns, comments and projects. To say that NO political messages of any kind, in support of any candidate (Trump, Biden, Weld, Obama, Sanders, Clinton . . . ) are permitted or supported on the site. You could go further, and say that no overt support of any social or political agenda of any kind is permitted. You could say that no patterns, comments or projects projecting any sort of racist or bigoted, or divisive points of view are allowed on the site. And if Ravelry would like to criticize Donald Trump, the politician, as someone it does not care to support, it may do that too. And whether or not I agreed with your stance, I’d respect it.
But Ravelry has crossed the line. To state unambiguously that Donald Trump’s supporters are all white supremacists is a disgusting and libelous falsehood. That is the statement that Ravelry has no business making. My personal political opinions don’t and shouldn’t, matter to you. I don’t put them on Ravelry, and no-one else should either. (I’m not even an American Citizen so I can’t even vote.) But if this policy isn’t reversed, I’ll be cancelling my Ravelry membership. I don’t go to Ravelry for the politics, and I won’t be staying around for the insults.
I’m not going to support or participate in an organization that disrespects and calumniates tens of millions of people, a few of whom are my friends, and who I know perfectly well are not white supremacists, or any sort of bigots, in this way.
Your entirely inappropriate, disgusting, libelous, false statement, needs to be expunged from Ravelry’s site. Immediately if not sooner.
I’m looking forward to your response, which I hope will be that you have re-written your policy in a fair and non-partisan way that doesn’t egregiously insult a considerable proportion of your membership, good people who have done nothing to deserve it, who are not in the least racist, who don’t have a white supremacist bone in their bodies, and who, along with you, condemn bigotry in all its forms, but who nevertheless happen to support a politician you don’t approve of, for reasons you can’t be bothered to understand. You are the bigots here. You are the ones maligning millions of innocents, for the despicable actions of a few. You are the ones who should be ashamed. And yes, I’ll say it, because as a foreigner, perhaps I expect more from the citizens of this great country than they sometimes expect of themselves: You are unAmerican.
Please correct this egregious overreach, and do it swiftly. The personal opinions of your members are none of your business, and you should respect that. I only wish I didn’t know your own opinions now, or the contempt that you have for a large proportion of your membership, and the lengths to which you’re willing to go to make that contempt known publicly.
I hope you can summon the common sense and intestinal fortitude to right this appalling wrong.
You should be ashamed of yourselves.
RightWingKnitJob, TKGA member and Ravelry member (for now)
Matt, I keep returning to the idea that most of us are probably more influential in real life — and that it’s harder, as we all know, to speak out in real life than it is on the internet.
So I wear the darned hat, as much as I dislike hats. For years, my wardrobe has consisted of blue jeans and black tee-shirts/sweatshirts, but I’m thinking maybe I need to get some shirts that make a statement, something conservative and socially… challenging.
More and more, I think pushing back is something we conservatives have to start doing. People have to see that there are conservatives everywhere — that we’re here, we’re proud, and we’re going to stay.
Good timing. June is “Pride” month. Should we apply for our own parade permits? “Conservative Pride.” I like it. March in 3-piece suit and tie? Ladies in pumps and wide skirted dresses (with pearls, of course)? I’d do it. I already have the dress and shoes (and pearls, of course).
And we can have our own rainbow flag done in shades of beige.
Or stick with Old Glory. Prettier colors, too. I look awful in beige.
Yes, that’s true. However, I already live in a pretty conservative area. There already are conservatives everywhere. Wearing “the hat” around here doesn’t occasion any comment at all, as most people already have one, and many are wearing it themselves.
I already have several rather non-PC T-shirts, (although I don’t have the “Knitters for Trump” one. Hmm (lightbulb). Maybe a product for the Ricochet store!) I do have the “I knit so I don’t kill people” badge and ribbon. But obviously there aren’t as many knitters around here as there are voters, and there’s a limit to the the effectiveness of standing, or speaking up for conservative values around here, because they’re the norm.
Artificial “communities” such as those that thrive on the Internet can be a force for much good. Ravelry has been a source of knowledge, expertise, resources, patterns and ideas for me for years. I’m sorry to see them insult and alienate a large proportion of their membership this way, in what I suppose is an effort to establish a “knitting lobby” in US politics (humorous as that sounds, I don’t think it’s much of a stretch; I expect there’s money at the root of this somehow or somewhere).
I don’t think conservatives are very good at responding to, deflecting, or thwarting such efforts. Maybe it doesn’t matter. Or maybe we need to get better.
Another wrinkle, with sites like Ravelry which take political stances like this is that they have a substantial number of members who are vendors, and who depend on business from site visitors for a percentage of their revenue (I don’t know if Ravelry takes a cut, or how that works as I’ve never sold anything through the site). In addition, it’s the default value when knitters are looking for patterns, or pointing another knitter to a pattern–go to Ravelry, and you’ll probably find it there.
Many of the vendors are LYS (local yarn stores), or very small businesses, or ladies or gentlemen who design and sell patterns for pin money, or mad money, or a little extra cash. Ravelry claims that 6,000 new patterns are added each month, and thousands of patterns a month are purchased and downloaded. In addition, books are recommended and purchased from Amazon and other sites, and patterns on other sites are linked to, purchased, and downloaded, neither of which revenue or numbers shows up in the Ravelry figures. People find knitting instructors, people who’ll do the “finishing” (sewing together) of their knitting projects for them, custom knitters, and any number of other services, all through Ravelry.
I have no doubt that many Ravelry vendors are Trump supporters, and that they’re unhappy with this move for many reasons besides the political one. (Why do I think that? You can probably guess.) They see their businesses becoming politicized. They see staying on Ravelry as supporting a political stance they abhor, and they see leaving Ravelry without a viable alternative as financially harmful. They don’t want their customers assuming that they have a particular political stance because they’re on Ravelry. They don’t want to be political at all. They just want to be, as someone from a different organization said to me yesterday “all about the knitting.”
There’s quite a lot of activity in the “knitting community” at the moment. I hope it’s productive and something comes of it. Stay tuned.
Does Ravelry feature advertising on its site? If so, there’s an action point: contact the advertisers. Tell them that if they continue to advertise on Ravelry, you will not use their services.
This hits Ravelry right in the wallet.
This.
@she, just visited your blog and printed the pattern.
I am more likely to crochet than knit, but I will be making this hat and sharing the pattern. Thanks!
Well, I am now officially in purdah. I have been put into Ravelry “account restriction,” on the basis of the following eleven comments. What this means, in Ricochet terms, is that I cannot post any threads, comment on any threads, or send any PMs to my new friends, of which, unsurprisingly (to me), I have quite a few, for 60 days. There’s no way for me to complain or ask what, exactly I’ve done to violate the terms of service or community guidelines, since I cannot send a message to anyone, including the pogue (thanks, @bossmongo, etc.) who informed me of this ludicrous situation, at this point.
And therefore there’s no way for me to ask why, since I reported other members for calling me a liar, a bot, a hack, a troll, and accusing me explicitly, and in rather vulgar terms, of photoshopping my profile, of lying about my tenure and experience at Ravelry, and of mocking and ridiculing me with screenshots of “bacon” in my profile where purchased patterns are supposed to be (I guess this is meaningful to a certain type of Internet user, but what it means is a mystery to me) it seems I have no recourse to this insult–there’s no way for me to inquire why nothing was done about these insults to me, and why, in fact, I was further insulted by people telling me that the people who run Ravelry are so important that they don’t have time to pay attention to my silly complaints.
Oh, wait . . . . Perhaps there is something I can do . . .
(Since the following are all MY comments, I feel no shame in reproducing them here. I’ve tried to remove others’ names. Sorry if I missed any. Or if I get the lightning bolt because I missed a bad word somewhere. And sorry you cannot see the “replies” or the “provocation,” or the occasional idiocy which led my comments. I’ll share as much as I think I ethically can)
To be clear, it appears what set things off today, and sent people over the edge was my observation that the pregnant woman in Alabama who was shot, and whose unborn baby died (she’s been charged with a crime), was shot by a woman. This was in reponse to a comment by a Raveler that was along the lines of “what the [expletive] are Christian pro-life Republicans doing here when they are blaming the woman for this violence instead of the man who held the gun?” Merely pointing out that a woman was the shooter caused a serious blither and may have contributed to the unfortunate overreaction that is my “account restriction.
Really. I’ve enjoyed my time on Ravelry (over a decade, I think), but at this point, it’s a total clown show. Here you go:
Account restriction notificationSent at 5:54 PM Today
rightwingknitjob,
Your account has been restricted for violating the Terms of Service and/or Community Guidelines.
References:
https://ravelry.com/about/terms
https://ravelry.com/about/guidelines
Restriction applied: forum posting, messaging, and commenting are disabled for 60 days.
Content in violation:
1 OF 11 [The following are my words, stepping through the eleven “violations.”]
2 OF 11
3 OF 11
4 OF 11
5 OF 11
6 OF 11
7 OF 11
8 OF 11
9 OF 11
10 OF 11
[NOTE: This is where things got exceptionally nasty for a while, and where people accused me of photoshopping the patterns into my profile so that it would look as if I had purchased them. Really loony stuff. Photoshopped (for real) images of the above screenshot with bacon in them, and nasty mocking comments. Let’s be clear–I love bacon. Trump supporters love bacon. Maybe there’s common ground over bacon! Nevertheless, I could have done without the insults.
Really. Yeah, Ravelry, I don’t have enough to worry about, or to do, that I’m pulling this sort of stuff. I complained about the behavior and the insults, and the foul language, which was rude, mocking and ridiculing. I asked a moderator to do his or her job and to stop this gratuitous and stupid abuse. Crickets. That’s what Ravelry thinks of those who’ve fallen afoul of their licensed and approved anti-Trump vigilantes.]
11 OF 11
[NOTE: I was engaged in a fairly civil conversation with a person I disagree with, about “triggering,” but that conversation was hijacked by a rude and accusatory person to whom I responded first. The response was interlinear, and hard to pick out, but I may post it later.
My response to my friend, who asked me to “hide” my unpleasant and triggering language, and who thought that I might not understand that some people on Ravelry were survivors of violence and sexual abuse would have been the following]:
However, I couldn’t post that comment, and I can’t add the disclaimer, because they’ve restricted my account. And, so it goes. Thank God for Ricochet (where a hell of a lot of you still think I’m a NeverTrumper, although I repeatedly tell you I can’t vote, but somehow, mostly, it still works.) Crimenutely. Contemplating the next move.
Bella Stark over at American Greatness also had a piece about the Great Ravelry Unravelling. She included a couple of alternate options.
I don’t know anything about the sites, or the app (or knitting either, for that matter) but thought anyone still reading might be interested.