Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Best Rock Song Ever
Fred Cole (@fredcole) thinks the best rock song is “White Room” by Cream for some reason. Jon Gabriel (@jon) said he’d only ever heard The KLF song titled “White Room.” I listened to both and now I want to go BASE jumping without a parachute.
I say “Unforgiven” by Metallica is much better, although it’s not even necessarily my favorite Metallica song (“Whiskey in the Jar” is high on my list). You see, Fred and I obviously have a difference in opinion when it comes to music. He seems like easy listening soft rock, while I prefer to listen to good music.
What do you think is the best rock song ever? Or, at least, share one of your favorites. And don’t forget to casually insult anyone who disagrees with you. That’s the fun part of asserting one’s own subjective preferences as being objectively true.
“White Room” by Cream (😴):
“Unforgiven” by Metallica:
Another favorite of mine is “Cochise” by Audioslave:
If you’d like to post a video of your own favorite rock song in the comments, all you have to do is paste the YouTube or Vimeo URL onto a new line by itself. The video will automatically appear after you publish your comment.
For decades around here, Stairway to Heaven topped the list every year, until finally supplanted by Livin’ on a Prayer.
A Day in the Life is the best Beatles song, thereby making it the best rock.
The best rock and roll song ever performed is objectively Paint It Black by the Rolling Stones and if you disagree you’re a filthy communist. It is overshadowed however by the best heavy metal song of all time which as everyone knows is Metallica’s Battery on Mondays, Wednesday and Fridays and Iron Maiden’s Flight of Icarus on all other days.
I’ve been to five concerts in my life, all between age 19 and 22: Rush once, and Billy Joel four times.
So I’m probably not qualified to comment.
Ummm Define Rock music. There are so many genres within Rock it’s hard to determine which is the best song ever. I nominate the greatest and shortest lived super group ever.
I prefer the 1962 Highwaymen version.
“Layla” 1970, Derek and the Dominos.
Philistines.
I really hope this can degenerate into a high-toned discussion about what is “rock” and what isn’t. As noted just above, this is an impossible question.
But when you have one the best rock bands ever covering one of the best rock songs ever, you’re getting close. And it’s definitely rock.
Not a rock song. A rock cover of a rock cover of a reggae song. Cretin.
No… Just no. Glam Boy pretenders from Jersey. No way!
Won’t Get Fooled Again by the Who is the obvious answer.
Back when music was music.
I can’t tell which parts of this are parody and which are serious. Can someone get @vicrylcontessa involved in this discussion since she’s the only one on the site who actually knows anything about actual music?
Not a rock song?
Wha?
Granted, not everything the composer of “I Fought the Law” wrote was rock. Exhibit A:
The criterion I use is: do both my son (19 yo) and I reach for the volume to turn it up?
So the answer is…
Iron Maiden, Infinite Dreams:
Megadeth, Peace Sells….But Who’s buying?:
Max, I keep forgetting, how do we embed videos?
[edit by max: paste the YouTube url onto a new line by itself, starting with the “https”]
No, no you are not. 🤣😇
Not so. Are you thinking of “Pressure Drop”? I’m good with the cretin part though.
Nope. I Shot the Sheriff.
Yeah, ok, but you do like Skynyrd, right? I mean, obviously…
@jameslileks , of course you know this, but I have to say…
Not in the hands of your neighbors, Husker Dü.
Anyone who likes the Rolling Stones can just toss their computer out the window, by the way. ;-P
This is enough to make me concoct two or three dozen phony bug reports and send them your way.
Fred didn’t even get the best song by Cream. That’d be “I Feel Free”.
Hmmm… I can’t say my favorite for sure but I just heard Toto in the car and told myself, “Man, I forgot how good that song is!”
Gladly. I can’t stand the vile little mechanical beasts. Look at what they’ve done to this once flourishing community–made us question the most fundamental truth in Rock! This division will tear us apart. A thread divided cannot stand. Accept the Stones now and heal this hurtful wound.
Musically, the best rock song of all time is Roll With The Changes by REO Speedwagon.
Yes, I know, It’s REO, But listen to it – it’s got everything. Screaming guitar solos, good vocal harmony, great drums, interesting bass line underneath it all, it’s even got a Hammond Organ.
Theres a lot of competition for the best Cream song.
Richrath was pretty good. I was never a big REO fan even before the ballad period, but for 70s rock – a period when all the music was hand-made – that’s top-shelf mid-tempo Midwestern rock.
Of course, my taste in 70s Midwestern rock leaned more towards scorchy numbers like this:
REO would never have tried that dissonance at the end of the first chorus, and I don’t think they ever wrote anything as simple and ingenious as the bridge. It’s dressed up like mean heavy metal, except it’s not: it’s actually joyous.