Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Christian Theology and the Jews
Since I sometimes write about Christians and Jews, I’ll weigh in on the criticisms of the pastors who spoke at the US Jerusalem Embassy dedication.
I respect that many Christians believe that salvation is only through belief in Christ.
And religious leaders who think Hitler was part of God’s plan? Hardly surprising. And not a good reason to be offended.
Believe whatever you want about what happens to me after my death. And I should hope your theology has an explanation for Hitler.
I have more than enough religious tolerance to not judge these men negatively for such beliefs.
I do fear those who call on their followers to hurt me. And those who minimize their evil statements and actions, and who want me to be vulnerable to them.
I also fear those who try to shame and exclude religious leaders because of beliefs that are not tied to calls to violent action.
But I’m fine with those who will let God decide how to reward or punish me for my beliefs and actions. Especially if those leaders are making common cause with me in this world, and affirming God’s relationship with the Jewish people.
Thank you Pastors Jeffress and Hagee for your support and your kind words. Sorry about the bigots trying to hurt you and drive us apart.
Published in Religion & Philosophy
Yes to “something bad.” I read @bobw as referring specifically to the Holocaust.
Well, I thought it was clear that by “we” you meant “the human race”.
The danger/extreme in Christianity, especially Protestant forms, is that the believer can become so fixated on the internal disposition of his faith that he is always doubting whether he has enough faith. Works aren’t the main focus, so faith, which is subjective, becomes hard to live up to.
A Jew is basically free from this. He believes that what matters is keeping God’s commandments, which the Jew, unlike many Christians, believes is in fact possible. So there is an objective measure of whether a Jew is successful religiously: am I keeping the commandments? This is potentially a liberating way of relating to God, because you’re more free than a Christian of always worrying about what is lurking in your sinful intentions. It’s almost as if God is saying, “Don’t worry about what’s going on in your head, just do what I tell you.” But the extreme of course is that it can more easily devolve into mere legalism.
Different approaches, and different ways it can become unhealthy as well.
As I’ve been told on several occasions: “I said it was simple, I didn’t say it was easy.”
This is correct.
I am not bothered by passing bad thoughts – what matters is what I say and do.
As the Buddhist flavored bumper sticker says: “DON’T BELIEVE EVERYTHING YOU THINK,” although if the car also has “MY OTHER VEHICLE IS THE MAHAYANA” I tend to think the driver is pretentious.
Not making this up. 5 or 10 years ago, lower deck of the SF-Oakland Bay Bridge.
I am an amateur observer of this stuff. Due to some personal factors and the fact that I don’t believe in uncaused causes, I’ve had to get in to it.
I listen to Dennis Prager quite closely (I’ve bought a bunch of his speeches and I get his podcast) and the way Jews use aphorisms and talk about things seems to me to develop people and productive, civil society in a really good way. I’ve gone to some educational things at a synagog here, and I got the same thing from those guys. They had different people doing the “sermon” beforehand and they were all spectacular. I like the focus on the now.
I grew up in a Congregational UCC church, but I think because I’ve got personality disorders on both sides of my family tree, I never got an affinity for it.