Your friend Jim George thinks you'd be a great addition to Ricochet, so we'd like to offer you a special deal: You can become a member for no initial charge for one month!
Ricochet is a community of like-minded people who enjoy writing about and discussing politics (usually of the center-right nature), culture, sports, history, and just about every other topic under the sun in a fully moderated environment. We’re so sure you’ll like Ricochet, we’ll let you join and get your first month for free. Kick the tires: read the always eclectic member feed, write some posts, join discussions, participate in a live chat or two, and listen to a few of our over 50 (free) podcasts on every conceivable topic, hosted by some of the biggest names on the right, for 30 days on us. We’re confident you’re gonna love it.
For many years, conservatives were ideological zealots. Like Spanish inquisitors, they were on guard for the slightest indications of heresy. Talk radio gurus in particular were punctilious keepers of the flame. If a Republican figure was thought to be “squishy” on any matter – guns, spending, immigration, or anything else – he or she was reviled. Jim DeMint, the former South Carolina senator who headed the Heritage Foundation for a time, said in 2009 that he’d rather have 30 conservative purists in the senate than 60 Republicans of varying hues.
This is a piece about John McCain, right? So just imagine: you could have written this piece and left the second paragraph out (the “I Hate Donald Trump” paragraph), and it would lose nothing.
So why was it necessary to include that?
My first thought as well. Note also the reference to “Spanish inquisitors,” and the dismissive tone of:
There’s a column to be written about honoring McCain, and I’m rather surprised that a professional such as Ms. Charen can’t really write it without the usual slights.
It’s like cud. It must be chewed and chewed and chewed. Unsightly to say the least.
John McCain’s militarily career is extremely honorable. His political career has not been honorable. As an elected politician, Trump has been far more conservative than McCain, which is all I care about.
Even Zubrin was able to passively appreciate President Trump today.
John McCain enjoys insulting and name calling fellow Republicans. He has a shown that he has a temper. The Maverick sought out positive press coverage and was the medias favorite Republican until he won the nomination. He is just a toned down version of Trump with an impressive military record.
Each Senator has a ridiculous amount of power to delay nominations and slow down everything. McCain advocates for increased American military power. If he was truly as honorable as you say, he would have stopped everything he could and made as big a fuss as possible until the VA problems were fixed.
This is the vote for President that I am actually ashamed of.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FZk32a0NWW8
Arizona has given two incredible Statesmen to the United States, Barry Goldwater, and John McCain, who was elected to Barry’s seat when Barry retired. A great article.
So which will be remembered as a greater achievement from McCain? Attacking the 1st Amendment through the campaign finance laws or saving Obamacare?
Gag.
He was one of 2 Senators to oppose the Bush Tax cuts, but no one remembers that. His Obamacare vote will be what he is remembered for only if nothing gets passed. Otherwise I think the attack on the 1st Amendment.
Color me unimpressed. He’s not quite the anti-Trump you make him out to be. Before Trump, Senator Maverick was the favorite Republican of Democrats with his “I’m not like them” schtick. He’s always been out for himself, politically. I don’t see much daylight between him and Trump on that count. And if you’re going to list his plaudits, you might want to talk about the less savory parts of his public life. Anyone remember the Keating Five? John McCain is undoubtedly a great American, but a terrible senator.
I don’t want to suggest the change in heart had something to do with beer sponsorship rights moving from boxing to the UFC, but…
Yes, funny that.
Short version: Mona Charen cares a lot more about opposing Trump than she does Obamacare or blatantly lying to constituents.
Oh, there’s plenty of room for lots of doubt.
I’ll appreciate him if he quits. But he won’t quit because he’s a blatant narcissist.
His little thumbs down routine was vomit inducing and I am curious if Mona genuinely admires his actions or more his self-aggrandizing Trump oppo schtick.
My take is that McCain’s innate recklessness and narcissism (which is right up there with Trump’s) put him in the seat of an A-4. This, in turn, led to his capture by the North Vietnamese. Yes, he was treated brutally and survived, which is no more than one would expect of any red-blooded male (dare I say that?). But McCain’s accidental “heroism” hardly puts him in a league with true military heroes.
The pity of it is that McCain’s accidental “heroism” enabled his election to Congress. He has stayed there for 34 years thanks to his accidental “heroism” and penchant for garnering publicity.
I hope that he will be succeeded by a principled Republican who is actually a conservative.
McCain actively campaigned for Obama in 2008, both by suspending his campaign, and by declaring, “You have nothing to fear from an Obama presidency.”
I used to enjoy reading Mrs. Charen’s columns and listening to the NTK podcast. It’s sad to have lost such an intelligent and thoughtful commentator. This is such a shame, especially because it didn’t have to end this way.
A piece praising John McCain and slamming Trump? This is just trolling at this point. I’m not going to try to find fault with the man’s service record or dispute what it means to be a hero but his recent showing of his ass against republicans over the healthcare bill reinforced that he needs to get out of DC forever.
Folks here are jumping on Mona for her Trump comments, but those comments were about us. Trump did not run as a conservative, had shown few signs of being a conservative and many of being a progressive, and the party chose him over at least three real conservatives. So her point is very valid. However, President Trump seems to be learning and his appointments demonstrated more conservative instincts than we could have hoped for. Senator McCain has never been a conservative, he was a cold warrior when we needed it but, in contrast to President Trump he doesn’t show much learning. McCain Feingold, was a predictable disaster and demonstrated how little the Senator actually understood about the world those many years ago.
McCain seems to have peaked during his military career. As a politician he was early-on involved the the Savings and Loan scandal from the late 80’s as a member of the Keating 5. Remember that one? Go back and read about that, it’s salacious stuff, free trips, “investments” for his wife’s real estate deals, giant campaign donations, very ugly stuff. He later ran a completely dreadful campaign for POTUS where he actually suspended his campaign (no drama there right?) during the “too big to fail” B.S shoved down our throats by Bush 43 and then threw his own VP nominee under the bus. He famously opposes Trump (that’s a 2-way street to be fair) and even went so far as to send a liaison to London to pick up fake Russian documents about Trump paying prostitutes to pee in a bed Obama slept in when in Moscow, you can’t make this stuff up.
Oh yeah, he blatantly lied to his constituents when running for reelection saying that he was for a wall/fence and enforcement of our border laws, and he called members of the Tea Party “hobbits” on the senate floor, and not in a cute endearing way, but in a nasty, typically McCain way, throwing out insults when nobody is there to fight back. And let’s not forget we have Obama Care today because of his typical diva routine of waiting to the last moment in order to elicit an audible gasp from his Senate colleagues with his dramatic thumbs down vote. Gee what honor, what service to your country, please.
We all salute his military service, I just wish his public service had ended there. As a politician he has been an utter failure.
As for Mona, I no longer read or listen, but just check in occasionally to make sure she’s being fact checked when she does her typical assault from the opera box, from the looks of things on this thread we’re having none of it from her and her ilk. Good on ya deplorables!
Why John McCain voted to save Planned Parenthood and Obamacare
typical assault from the opera box
Nicely played.
The country would have been better if Keating 5 had taken the good senator down. Too bad it didn’t.
Reading about that scandal today it’s a wonder he survived. I wish he had been re-introduced to the private sector after that one.
John McCain’s state of AZ had 130% increase in healthcare premiums – one of the worst in the country – I am glad his health insurance is covered by whatever the feds give Senators – I can assure you its not Obamacare – if he throws another political wrench in the works regarding the repeal and replace – there will be much more suffering – the Republicans have had this issue on their plates to deal with for a long time and they haven’t done it – it’s appalling what has happened to our country’s healthcare system. Even MD Anderson – the best cancer treatment center in the US doesn’t take Obamacare. No praise here for McCain unless he does something positive in this area.
Us hobbits and Waco birds need to understand the good health insurance is not for the “little people” only Public Servants deserve this benefit.
With Mona, it’s swine before pearls.