Promoted from the Ricochet Member Feed by Editors Created with Sketch. Time to Rethink College (Part 4): Filing the Gaps in the Gap Year Theory

 

BoxesOfLifeIf skill and time had not prevented, I would have liked the illustration at right to show a young person in the education box — not tall enough to look out and unable to see what is in the next box. In the previous series (I, II, III) I shared from my personal experiences with my own children, how I tried to give them exposure in both the education and work worlds as they grew so the career decision is not a jump into the unknown. In response, others added to my thoughts their own wisdom (thank you ricochettes). So if there is a parent or young adult thinking of bucking the trend, they need the support of many voices. Because, the hardest part in not conforming to the cultural expectation for college right after high school is trying to explain why to our family, friends and teachers. My daughter experienced this first hand while talking to a parent of one of her graduating peers. When my daughter explained she was taking a gap year, the adult walked away before she could fully explain the logic. That is tough on a kid and can be tough on parents. So the reason to do this last post is make it easier for others to take alternate paths.

Interweaving Work and School

TheExpectation

I think visually — So I thought it helpful to add some clarifying diagrams. Some will recognize the source. For those old enough to have read the Three Boxes of Life, you will understand the desire to interweave work and school. To the left (literally and politically) is the cultural expectation. You get educated, then, go to work. Simple, clear, easy to administer, similar to any other top down solution, and at odds with reality and the needs of the person. As some noted, young adults without previous work experience become difficult to “launch” at the end of college — the transition is too unfamiliar, the leap is too far to do in one step.

GapTheory

The better plan, obviously on the right, has experiences with work increasing from childhood. Where as a child, we experience the work world as household chores. Shall we will call that a “gap hour” from education and play? As one ages, the experience of work increases. You may work with your parent (a gap day). In your early teens help Uncle Bob outdoors (a gap week). Have a summer job in high school (a gap summer). Eventually the gaps become the fabric of your life when you work full time. What is important to see is the woven transition from education to work.

“Gap Year” Confusion

It has become clear that the terms “gap year” and “intern” have lots of meanings. If you Googled “gap year” you will be confused. The search results for “gap year” yield mostly gap year “programs” where you pay some organization to provide a travel, internship, or learning experience. That’s not what I had in mind. I’m recommending “real jobs” not a “program.” I’m recommending earning money, not paying money. If you pay money you become the student client, much like going to school, and it undermines what you need to learn. You need to learn what jobs the world is willing to pay for, and searching for a real job will tell you that. You need see what your industry of interest is really like as a career, and working in a real business in the only way to learn that.

Collective Wisdom

I would like to leave you with the collective wisdom from my favorite comments on the previous posts in this series:

“Gap year? I had “Gap summers” from the age of 14-21 with part-time jobs and yes, some European travel as well.”

“I think a gap year is a good idea, unless the kid just drifts off to nothing and never reclaims momentum to do anything else.”

“This path is not the expected one, and that it takes a certain amount of faith, hope and prayers. You do have to deal with the doubts of friends, family, and teachers. But, as I remind myself, I always taught my kids that they should not be conformists and always go with the cookie-cutter expectations.”

“Taking a job after high school can do more than flesh out how much one likes any specific job or line of work. Seeing how hard life can be for the uneducated provides motivation to study harder and get the most out of the time and money spent earning the degree.”

“Just the experience of working for a paycheck and paying real bills (my son moved into his own apartment) can be very helpful. It makes the concept of life after education much more real.”

“All my kids started working part time by 15. Full time in summers. I think having jobs as teenagers is vital. Raising the minimum wage is eliminating this vital opportunity for many.” 

“We agreed to the ‘College Reimbursement Plan’. The Bank of Mom & Dad are “reimbursing” them, we have a say in the field of study (we also only pay 100% for “A’s” and 80% for ‘B’s” anything lower is their learning curve).”

“I believe everyone should have the humility to serve others in entry level service industries, just so they remember the experience when they get on the other side of the counter.”

“I had classmates who seemingly had chosen their major by tossing darts at the catalog and going with the first one they hit. Most of them were miserable by their Junior year. I even saw one guy [in an IT degree] … complain bitterly about even having to take any programming classes. Had he worked a year mopping floors for an IT company he might have made a better choice in majors.”

“College provides two benefits — monetary and non-monetary. To the extent one pays for college in order to receive future monetary benefits, that’s called an “investment”. To the extent one pays for college in order to receive non-monetary benefits, that’s called a ‘luxury.’ ”

“Another thing I’ve noticed but rarely heard discussed is that a degree can limit the kinds of jobs you will be selected for… So, yes, you don’t want to rush into getting a degree and locking yourself into a specific field. If you get a business “brand” or an education “brand,” you may have to work extra hard to change brands.


Example Policies of Deferred Admission (Taking a Gap Year)

As a resource, in following are how some colleges accommodate Gap Years (no recommendation of these colleges is inferred).

 

There are 4 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. Wiley Inactive
    Wiley

    OOPS, I DID NOT MEAN TO REPOST THIS. I JUST CHANGED THE TITLE FROM “PART IV” TO “PART 4” TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE OTHER POSTS IN THIS SERIES. EVIDENTLY THAT MAKES IT A NEW POST (and loses all the comments).

    Administrators, feel free to remove from current member feed (hopefully without losing the link to the article).

    • #1
    • April 11, 2016, at 3:57 AM PDT
    • Like
  2. Casey Way Member
    Casey Way Joined in the first year of Ricochet Ricochet Charter Member

    Wiley,

    As a young adult still going through the transitions of education and working, there’s a lot of uncommon knowledge to your gap year series. Personally, I feel part of the problem is the educational institution understanding their role in the transition. The talk of career planning and next steps comes far too often after time for missteps and bad habits to be taught. But there many proactive steps that individuals can take, like gap year experiences, to better position themselves.

    I can still remember the group financial aid meeting at the end of my senior year of grad school. Every class member was handed a folder that outlined their total loan amounts. There were grief stricken expressions around the room as many people for the first time saw the sum total cost of all their years of education. In 2 months time, they would be responsible for starting payments on those loans without having had gainful employment in some cases for 8 years. The terror was understandable especially for those with no set job lined up.

    • #2
    • April 11, 2016, at 5:27 AM PDT
    • Like
  3. Quietpi Member

    But government interference in the workplace is making it far more difficult – in some cases impossible – for young people to find the very types of employment necessary, whether summer jobs, internships, or a host of others. They’re just disappearing.

    • #3
    • April 11, 2016, at 6:46 AM PDT
    • Like
  4. PHCheese Member

    For many young adults a small business venture makes a lot of sense. It can even transition into a career. It doesn’t need to be capital intensive. Maybe something that they can set their own hours. It can start in high school. My parents steered me into Junior achievement in grade school. I loved it.

    • #4
    • April 11, 2016, at 7:34 AM PDT
    • Like

Comments are closed because this post is more than six months old. Please write a new post if you would like to continue this conversation.