Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Save or Kill – Ricochet Edition
This past weekend, I did a pop-culture post based on a game Collider uses on its website called “Save or Kill.” The premise is that you are presented with two icons, both threatened with being wiped from existence forever, and must choose which of the two to save; you cannot save both. The game works best when you really love both icons, so it becomes a real Sophie’s Choice.
That first post didn’t get as many responses as I’d hoped — though my thanks to those who did participate, and there’s still time to jump in! — so I’m tailoring the game in this post with options better-suited to the interests of the Ricochetti.
So, read the list of the choices below and — in the comments — post which of the two icons you’d save for each of the ten choices. There’s no obligation to explain your reasoning, but I think it’ll be more fun with it. The criteria you use for judging is entirely up to you: you can do this based exclusively on personal preference, or on which option you feel is more important to society. Also, if you’re not familiar with both options in a scenario, feel free to abstain from that particular scenario.
Alright, I’m gonna post the list below. Let the game begin!
- Milton Friedman or Thomas Sowell
- John Wayne or Clint Eastwood
- The Lord of the Rings or The Chronicles of Narnia
- “The Star-spangled Banner” or “America the Beautiful”
- John Ford or Alfred Hitchcock
- Hamburgers or Bacon
- Led Zeppelin or Rush
- Star Wars or Firefly
- Mark Steyn or Jonah Goldberg
- Football (American) or Baseball
Published in Culture
1. Sowell
2. Wayne
3. LOTR
4. Star-Spangled Banner
5. Hitchcock
6. Bacon
7. Rush
8. Firefly
9. Steyn
10. Football
The hot dog champion?
Star Trek is not a choice. Which when you think about it is kind of weird since it has always been the Star Wars/Star Trek split.
Actually they do that (or at least did that) for baseball games, and they take the better part of 30 minutes for most games (with commercials). That’s how our local BB network covered the weekday day games that weren’t otherwise televised. They’d put up the summarized version that night. They had a name for it, but it escapes me at the moment.
This was GREAT!
Very Tough Choices:
Milton Friedman, John Wayne, Hamburgers, Mark Steyn
Very Clear Choices (alternatives were preposterous):
“The Star-spangled Banner”, Firefly
Pretty Easy Choices:
The Lord of the Rings, John Ford, Led Zeppelin
Meh Choice (who cares?):
Baseball
Sowell
Wayne
LOTR
Battle Hymn (I know, not a choice)
Hitchcock
Bacon
Stones (Again, not a choice)
Firefly
Steyn, by a hair (This is the toughest of all of them.)
Baseball (I am a Redskins fan so football is nothing but misery for me.)
Fun!! I love giving my opinion! HAH!
Certainly as a cultural influence, Star Wars is much more important. No Star Wars, no Firefly. And while I did pick Firefly, if this scenario actually became real I think I’d probably go with Star Wars. I just watched Empire Strikes Back with my wife last night (she has seen it before, but maybe just once or twice). It’d been years since I’d last seen it. What a phenomenal movie- so many spine-tingling moments and beautiful visuals.
I actually went and saw Serenity in the theater (based on Orson Scott Card’s recommendation) before I ever watched any of the show. And even having seen none of the TV episodes beforehand (which I know is the wrong way to do it) I really loved Serenity.
In the original Collider Save or Kill list it is Star Wars/Star Trek. But I was curious to throw Firefly into the mix as it is such a pro-libertarian show and I know it has quite a few fans here on Ricochet.
An excellent observation.
https://youtu.be/uRdbEY_YfV4?t=18s
Because he laughs like a dolphin rolling on molly.
Sowell – owing to his works being more relevant to today’s reality, Free to Choose notwithstanding.
John Wayne – ’nuff said
LOTR or Narnia…I pick keeping Narnia, because I read it when I was a child, never have gotten past Fellowship, and the movies of both are forgettable to my taste.
Star Spangled Banner – I like that our Anthem is difficult to sing, besides, lots of countries are beautiful.
Hitchcock, just like that genre.
Bacon-but that one hurts more than killing off Mr. Friedman, and Clint combined!
Zeppelin – they had a better drummer! (oh no he didn’t!)
No opinion on Star Wars v. Firefly – haven’t watched the latter.
Definitely keep Goldberg alive, he has more relevant (to me) pop culture references.
Baseball, although ten years ago I may have said football, but that game is getting to be a joke.
Fun exercise…can I kill off both Messrs Goldberg and Steyn, have bacon only on thursdays, and resurrect Mr. Friedman?
Our different experiences and expectations may have made for our different takes. I discovered Firefly about a year before Serenity and became a rabid fan, was hugely excited by Serenity… and then massively disappointed.
I bought the DVDs (with commentaries) for Firefly first and was very disappointed at its short lifespan. I think of Serenity as the summarized Firefly seasons 2 & 3.
re: Star Wars. The first movie was awesome for its time. When I took my oldest son to see it (he was 3 or 4), it impressed us both. When the midi-chlorians were added, all I could think was “triumph of Scientology.” Pretty much ruined that universe for me.
Wo, the Thnicka Man! Can I have some?
Hey, shut up kids!
Interesting. I didn’t think any band could be more over-rated than Rush. :)
I should have known I had that coming. I have repeatedly tried with Zeppelin because they get so much radio play. Honestly, I prefer Fairport Convention when Sandy Denny was with them. Aside from Led Zeppelin IV (Denny’s guest appearance on Battle of Evermore is lovely )and a few songs here and there, I find them hard to listen to. I just I am looking for something a little more upbeat.
Friedman
“Friedmanite” is a thing. “Sowell Man” is not.
Clint Eastwood
I would not want to do without the movies Clint has directed.
Lord of the Rings
This is like choosing between Buddy Holly and Christian Rock. As Dr. Johnson said, it isn’t that it walks well, it’s that it walks at all.
America the Beautiful
If I never hear someone butchering the high notes again …
Alfred Hitchcock
Just because he was such a weirdo
Bacon
I hate you. But I can enjoy Bacon without Hamburgers on it.
Limbaugh?
Firefly
This is sooooo easy. Just ask yourself after the most recent episode: Do I want to see another one of these? Bonus exercise: Picture Jar-Jar Binks and Young Anikin as you ask this question about Star Wars.
Jonah
I adore Steyn, but he really, really depresses me, because I know he’s right and I can’t rouse myself to move to New Zealand. The worst things about Jonah are his talking couch and the stories about his dog.
Can’t they both lose?