Do Not Seek The Treasure

 

shutterstock_156669578Today, in the midst of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, more Obama fecklessness and dithering on the continued threat of ISIS, and the usual late-summer distractions, there is rising chatter (inspired by the White House and its allies) that we’re rushing headlong into another Shutdown Spasm.

I’ve warned you about this before; just don’t do it. I don’t care what the pretense is; don’t do it.

This time, they’re hoping to lure us into a trap just weeks before the 2014 elections. The only people who will benefit from letting the White House, Reid, and Pelosi get away with this shutdown silliness are… the White House, Reid, and Pelosi. The various email hucksters on both sides will fill their coffers with lavish promises of either doom or destiny, but if Republicans believe a shutdown will yield a scintilla of political benefit, they’re drinking too early in the day.

As usual, it’s not because I’m afraid we will lose the legislative fight. That’s inevitable. No matter how much chest-beating you do, Harry Reid has a gun to our heads in the Senate and he’ll whip his people with the ferocity he usually reserves for his other victims. It’s because it’s going to give the Democrats a massive political advantage in the elections.

If I put on my “Imagine I’m A Democratic Strategist Hat” for a moment, here’s a half-dozen things I’d do the minute Republicans walk into the trap. Remember, it doesn’t matter if the things they say are true. It matters that they’ll say them:

  • Every endangered Red State Democrat goes on air with an ad saying, “Although [Republican opponent X] now wants to shut down the government in order to cancel your Social Security, Medicare and veterans’ benefits, I’ll fight to make Washington take care of people first. I don’t always agree with Barack Obama, but I’ll never put your benefits at risk.”
  • I’d turn Washington into a circus, demanding the Senate return in order to eat up the time, attention, and bandwidth of Republican Senators running for re-election, and give Democratic senators an excuse to change the dialogue by saying, “I know you hate me for Obamacare, immigration, and every other way I suck up to this President, but I’m here to save Social Security from the Evil Republican Cabal.”
  • Direct mail will fill the mailboxes of seniors (who still read it) from the Democrats with big, scary, official-looking envelopes saying things like “SOCIAL SECURITY CANCELLATION NOTICE” and “MEDICARE BENEFITS FREEZE.” Behold, the Gray Wave screaming bloody murder into every Congressional district office.
  • The day we shut down the government, the Democrats will be able to effectively nationalize the campaign, running not so much against their Republican opponents (where they might lose) but against the Republican strawmen in D.C (where they’ll likely win).
  • The President, Reid, and other Democrats will push nothing but the shutdown story. Every cable network, including Fox, will get caught up in the silly-season machinations of the shutdown, and we’ll be stuck talking Washington process stories for weeks on end. If you know nothing else about media, it’s that Washington process stories are box-office poison for voters. We won’t be landing oppo hits on the Democrats. Rather, we’ll be in the trenches again, explaining in the interview than we don’t want to cancel Social Security or Medicare and we don’t want to default on the national debt and we don’t want to plunge the economy into a tailspin.

Remember, don’t even bother to rebut the absurdity of the assertions. The Democrats don’t care. They are not bound by truth, and they’ll use this opportunity to demagogue like champions. Don’t play into Barack Obama’s hands, friends. When the trap is this obvious, and the consequences are this serious, don’t walk into its jaws.

Image Credit: Shutterstock user JPL Designs.

There are 5 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. user_86050 Inactive
    user_86050
    @KCMulville

    In previous “shutdown games,” there was at least a legitimate conflict on policy. This one, however, is openly and obviously about baiting Republicans. There is no principle at stake. 

    No way they should shut it down this time.

    May I say that the only … repeat, the only … reason this kind of Democrat strategy could even have been conceived is that Democrats are absolutely certain that the media will not penalize them for it. And, of course, the Democrats are counting on the media to carry the water for them. The fact that they even considered this strategy is testimony to the complete corruption of the media.

    • #1
  2. Western Chauvinist Member
    Western Chauvinist
    @WesternChauvinist

    While I agree that Republicans would be smart to avoid this trap, I’m more concerned about the gullibility of the electorate. Or, is it convinced of it?

    Just this morning, I overheard an oppo ad against Cory Gardner (R – Colorado) while my daughter was watching cartoons before going to school. A woman’s voice floated across the room claiming Gardner would ban abortions, “even in cases of rape.”

    Now, on the issue of abortion, I’m as SoCon as they come. I think the circumstances of a child’s conception have no bearing on the child’s human rights. But, what, in heaven’s name, does that have to do with Colorado’s selection of its senator?

    I don’t even know Gardner’s position on the life issue. Changes in the nation’s abortion laws are (although desirable, imo) so far removed from the issues of the day, and even more removed from Gardner’s ability to do anything about them, it’s absurd to bring them up in this context.

    And yet, if it didn’t work with gullible voters, the Democrats wouldn’t bother.

    War on Women!! Expect this meme to overtake all else.

    • #2
  3. Dave Carter Podcaster
    Dave Carter
    @DaveCarter

    Rick, I find myself in agreement with you this time, though not quite for the reasons which you articulate.  The fact that the Republicans have folded every single time before, even announcing in advance what they would and would not do (essentially following the Barack Obama model of foreign policy wherein you broadcast everything including the timeline of your eventual capitulation) means that the President can and will call their bluff again.   With respect, even your acceptance of the premise the Republicans were the ones who shut down the government last time, though they funded every facet of it save Obamacare, shows that we have no business setting ourselves up for our own failure yet again.

    • #3
  4. user_1938 Member
    user_1938
    @AaronMiller

    The stupid party, forever in waiting. 

    Fine, don’t shut it down. Wait for total control before daring to do anything at all. 

    But perhaps Republicans could start preparing for future Democrat ploys by regularly reminding people of all the worthless expenses that can be eliminated without cutting funding for police departments, firefighters, Social Security, and Medicare. Voters have heard reports of government waste every week of their lives, and yet it’s apparently impossible to consider even trimming the fat.

    If Republicans were truly stupid, they wouldn’t be this consistently inept.

    • #4
  5. user_1050 Member
    user_1050
    @MattBartle

    Kudos for the “O Brother Where Art Thou” reference!

    • #5

Comments are closed because this post is more than six months old. Please write a new post if you would like to continue this conversation.