Liberal Outrage Over Tyrants


Recep_Tayyip_ErdoganAll things are not necessarily equal when it comes to tyrants and liberals. Turkey has just elected a new president, or more accurately, they had their first popular election for that office, and moved their prime minister into that position. Recep Tayyip Erdogan has been acting a little power hungry lately, and decided that he wanted to be president, and expand the powers of that office to meet his desires. For better or worse, the people of Turkey have obliged him. Because he’s backed by mostly conservative Sunni Muslims, it won’t be surprising if in the coming months we’ll see liberal foreign policy wonks talking about how bad this is. They’ll be right, but probably for the wrong reasons.

Cenk Sidar offered a very interesting pre-election analysis of the situation in Turkey at, particularly through a thumbnail sketch of the Erdogan administration. The first statement of interest had to do with Erdogan’s attitude about the system of checks and balances in the Turkish government.

Lately, Erdogan has shown little interest in preserving a system based on checks and balances and the separation of powers. The prime minister’s harsh crackdown on his political opponents and his combative rhetoric strongly suggest that he would like to see Turkey become a decidedly illiberal democracy, one in which he and his party can use the mandate of the ballot box to rule as they please, with little or no consideration of dissenting views.

If one removes the references to Turkey in the previous, and inserts the U.S., it remains accurate. We can expect to see multiple detractors of Erdogan around the world over these actions, but many of them would not bring Obama to task for the same issues. But, the similarities do not end there.

Last year, leaked tapes showed Erdogan making direct calls to media group owners to give instructions and complain about negative publicity. After a major corruption scandal involving senior government officials surfaced last December, government officials failed to address the allegations and even covered up the ongoing parliamentary investigation of the three ministers who resigned after revelations about their alleged malfeasance. All of this has eroded Turkish citizens’ trust in their institutions, including the court system and the news media, which are increasingly viewed as subject to the prime minister’s whims.

Laws recently passed by parliament, which is dominated by the AKP, are part of the same trend. The laws, which tighten government control over the judiciary and the Internet while expanding the remit of the intelligence agencies, are all clearly designed to strengthen the AKP’s grip on various aspects of daily life. In addition to these bureaucratic measures, however, Erdogan has also inflicted serious damage to Turkish democracy with his use of discriminatory rhetoric. In order to consolidate his voter base, he willingly inflames religious, sectarian, and ethnic divides.

Again, the Erdogan and Obama administrations are eerily similar. However, the fact remains that while the Turkish leader can easily be referred to as a tyrant without fear of reprisal, even a whisper of the same about Obama will earn one relegation to the “tin-foil hat” crowd. We’ve known this for a long time, but Erdogan may actually become useful to conservatives that want to point out the real problems the Obama administration has been creating.

It is a little more difficult for liberals to maintain their argument that nothing is wrong when they are simultaneously calling another world leader that is doing the same things a tyrant. Hypocrisy is nothing new to them, but this comparison may help to illustrate the message that the U.S. government has been twisted into as Sidar put it, an “illiberal democracy.”  It would also dispel at least one liberal myth about conservatives — uneducated people could not easily bring this argument to the table. They wouldn’t know enough to look for it in the first place.

There are 7 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. user_124695 Inactive

    It’s almost like Mr Erdogan is a closet Islamist, or something.

    He is famous for “Democracy is like a streetcar. You ride it until you arrive at your destination and then you step off.”

    Just as well that can’t possibly happen in America.

    • #1
  2. user_645 Editor

    May I suggest, as someone who lived in Turkey for the better part of the past decade, that this post reflects a certain failure of imagination about the meaning of the phrase–or perhaps the details involved–when we describe Turkey as an “illiberal democracy?”

    • #2
  3. Liz Harrison Contributor
    Liz Harrison

    Claire Berlinski:

    May I suggest, as someone who lived in Turkey for the better part of the past decade, that this post reflects a certain failure of imagination about the meaning of the phrase–or perhaps the details involved–when we describe Turkey as an “illiberal democracy?”

     I didn’t intend to gloss over anything here. What I wanted to point out here was that there was a succinct statement about Turkey out there that just happened to be so similar to what has been happening here in the U.S., that it was remarkable. The item was agenda driven, in context with what is actually happening in Turkey (since the author barely scratched the surface of what is actually going on there), just like most of the mainstream media items here are when it comes to (lack of) coverage of the Obama administration. That said, I think readers here might be interested in seeing something about how kind that article is, when it comes to describing Turkey. You’re arguably in a much better position than I am to do that, since I would have to rely on statements from people like you.

    • #3
  4. user_645 Editor

    This was the last piece I wrote before I left. I left with a broken heart, for many reasons.

    • #4
  5. user_645 Editor

    I’m watching the reports from Ferguson and thinking that perhaps I spoke too soon.

    • #5
  6. Julia PA Member
    Julia PA

    Claire Berlinski:

    This was the last piece I wrote before I left. I left with a broken heart, for many reasons.

     Claire, that was a stunning article. I couldn’t read it, without being heartbroken, yet you lived it.
    Would you compare that violence in Turkey as being similar to what has been going on in Ukraine, even if the power-brokers are different?  

    • #6
  7. user_645 Editor

    In many ways, yes–but the basic political process is more like Russia under Putin than anything else.

    • #7

Comments are closed because this post is more than six months old. Please write a new post if you would like to continue this conversation.