Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 40 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Quote of the Day: Accountability
It’s hard to imagine a more stupid or more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong. – Thomas Sowell
One of the great failings of today’s federal government is the lack of accountability of those who run it. Through at least the 1960s, and somewhat into the 1970s, if a government official screwed up big time, he (or she, but mainly he back then) resigned. If they did not, they were fired.
During World War II the US Army and Navy went through flag officers like tissue paper. When the US entered the war, Marshall replaced most of the Army’s pre-war generals with younger men, typically colonels and lt. colonels. If the replacements did well, they were promoted. If they screwed up, they were replaced. Admiral King did the same in the US Navy. Competence counted. We won that war.
The Civil Service was much the same during the ’40s and ’50s. The incompetents were handed walking papers. Those of ability rose. Not always, but more often than not and frequently enough.
In the 1960s that began to change. Failures were not relieved. They were kicked upstairs. Promoted. It had also spread to industry and business. The Peter Principle emerged by the late 1960s.
In the private sector this led to spectacular crashes in the 1970s, most notably in the auto industry. Things corrected somewhat. Competition and creative destruction have a way of doing that in the private sector. Not so in government. The CYA trend and protect-your-buddy trend continued there because there was no real corrective mechanism. Government, especially its civilian sector, got worse and worse.
(The military was somewhat protected from this trend because through the victory in the Gulf War it was unpopular. Since it was not a prize, it was allowed to correct itself. Men like Creighton Abrams were allowed to fix it. After we won the Gulf War the bureaucrats realized there was gold in those hills, and the politically correct began burrowing in.)
I first really noticed it after the Challenger Disaster in 1986. Everyone culpable was promoted. The old saw of “search for the guilty, punish the innocent, and rewards for the uninvolved” kicked in. Since then, especially in government, things have gotten worse and worse. Destroy cities through absurd policy decisions. Get promoted. Poison a river in Colorado? Punish those in the private sector who could not override bad government decisions and reward those in government whose mistakes led to folly. And so on.
Incompetents rose to the top like cream, because incompetents only feel secure hiring those more incompetent than themselves. We get progressions like Obama to Biden to Harris to Walz. Over the last 20 years no one in government has been held accountable for anything.
That era appears to be over. People in the federal government are being fired for their failures. They are beginning to be held to account. I say beginning because the process started only one month ago. That is time enough for firings — and only a few firings — but not time enough for well-merited indictments, especially if those indictments are to be based on law, not vengeance. The process has been so long delayed that some good people will go out as well. For that I refer them to Aesop’s fable of “The Farmer and the Stork.”
Sowell is right. Power without accountability is madness. In a real sense, it is not power that corrupts. It is power without accountability that is truly corrupting.
(David Deeble referenced Thomas Sowell today, so I thought I might provide an offering of Sowell food for thought today. Sowell is who I want to be when I grow up.)
Published in Group Writing
If you haven’t grown up by now, I have bad news for you.
It may be an old saw but it’s new to me. However, I’ve seen plenty of it.
Hmmm. See, Saw, Have seen… They’re all the same word, aren’t they?
Tell me about it. I know.
Actually, under the Democrat administrative state we saw plenty of rewards and promotions for the guilty.
Hmm, in one area did the process start from the top and work down, or did it start at the bottom and work up? Were judges stupid and corrupt first, then prosecutors, and then cops? Or were the cops stupid and corrupt and dangerous first? You’d think bad cops wouldn’t exist without first having bad prosecutors and judges to allow it. But maybe the prosecutors and judges had some other reason to allow bad cops, such as Affirmative Action or what-not, and then that worked upwards.
The DOJ has a Civil Rights division, I hope they put a lot of work into dealing with bad cops, prosecutors, and judges. One of the main reasons the federal civil rights laws came about to start with, was because of bad cops, prosecutors, and judges in the South. Seems like they’re already starting to work on bad mayors and governors etc, for violating federal immigration laws and such. So I have some encouragement.
Janet Reno “took full responsibility” for the disaster at Waco in 1993, and then proceeded to remain in the Clinton administration until it ended in 2001.
20 years after the 197os and after Challenger. The trend was in place. We were in the “take full responsibility and do nothing” phase. By the time the EPA poisoned the Animus River, in 2015, no one was even taking full responsibility. It was “Oops. Those things happen.”
What did you have in mind about the 70s? I first started to take notice of how “full responsibility” meant “no responsibility, no consequences” in 1983, after Ronald Reagan took all the responsibility on himself for the bombing of the U.S. military barracks in Lebanon.
My point was (and is) that governmental accountability began to die in the 1970s. Which you yourself noted.
And was widely praised as if this were the epitome of accountability.