Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Reflections of a Weak Society?
Monday night, with a little over five minutes remaining in the 1st Quarter of the Bills-Bengals game, Buffalo safety Damar Hamlin suffered cardiac arrest. He was attended by both teams’ trainers and EMTs and was transported to the University of Cincinnati Medical Center where he remains in critical condition.
The overwhelming opinion of the media and everyone connected with the game is that it could not continue and the the NFL suspended play.
Is it a sign of respect or sign of weakness?
On March 22, 1989, Steve Tuttle of the St. Louis Blues and Uwe Krupp of the Buffalo Sabres crashed into the nets and, in a freak accident, one of Tuttle’s skates cut open the neck of Sabres’ goal tender Clint Malarchuk, severing his carotid artery and partially cutting his jugular vein. Malarchuck lost a liter and half of blood. The Blues resurfaced the ice and the game was finished.
In 1940, Cincinnati Reds backup catcher Willard Herschberger committed suicide in the team’s hotel in Boston. (I wrote about his story here.) After a team meeting the Reds played the next day and completed the road trip to Brooklyn to take on the Dodgers.
The only player to die on the field during a National Football League game was Chuck Hughes of the Detroit Lions. With 1:02 left in an October 1971 game at Tiger Stadium vs the Chicago Bears, the 28-year-old wide receiver collapsed on his way back to the huddle. He was pronounced dead at Henry Ford Hospital.
Were we tougher back then or were we just terrible people?
Published in General
And that’s why Catholics have Confession.
Ah.
Should the NFL have played the weekend of JFK’s assassination?
Should they have played the Sunday after 9/11?
It depends. And probably yes.
Depends on what?
Seriously, I have two concrete examples. You know all the facts in both cases. Should they have played?
And freely speak their opinions.
Also several people on my other social media stated that it took a full hour for the NFL people to decide to cancel the game. But that the players and coaches of both teams had requested that the game be done another time.
Wasn’t baseball cancelled? Until finally baseball mgrs got together and said “This sport of ours keeps us all united and provides an outlet for something other than fear and grief.”
Of course, maybe that is not exactly how it was. But I do think baseball games were cancelled.
Begorrah.
And didn’t W throw the ceremonial first pitch?
I do *not* know all the facts about the teams playing. Was there great hue and cry about them playing? Were any of the players friends with Kennedy, or Connally? Children of those killed in the 9/11 attacks? Were those players told to play ball or hit the bricks? And so forth. I don’t suppose so, but I do not *know* of course.
I support it if it was a post-calamity stiff-upper lip sort of thing. To the extent that I give a damn.
These examples of yours are a different animal, though. Those were world/national events. This current one is an NFL event that happened to go out on broadcast. Different thing.
I don’t much care, and I’m certainly done debating it. I do not care enough to have a crisp opinion, so yes, you’ll find me squishy on it. I don’t care.
For 9/11, baseball resumed on 9/17. However, I agree that it’s a different animal. I seem to recall some general public anguish about any large public gathering. I also recall being in favor of continuing on. Should games have continued on 9/11 itself? No, because of the very real threat of additional attacks.
Several months ago I posted regarding the Ukraine commemorative stamps. I was shocked that there were hours long lines in order to get the gag stamp. Not to enlist, but to acquire an anti Russia stamp. Anyway, I was further shocked by the consensus meh reaction of the Ricochete. After all, life goes on even during war time, people still go bowling and to the movies and restaurants. Even with actual invaders ~250 miles away. Anyway.
For the JFK assassination on 11/22/1963, it appears that there was a full football schedule just two days later on 11/24/1963. If the assassination had happened on a Sunday, I would have favored the games going on.
I know it doesn’t seem like much, but these kinds of conversations are my favorite around here. It can be surface or we can go deeper, we can stay on direct topic or go off in interesting yet related directions. Of course, when I find myself on the outside of the consensus, yet everyone seems to think their position is obvious and obviously correct, I really can’t resist digging in to the issues.
In addition to the incidents I mentioned in the original post, NASCAR returned the week after Dale Earnhardt Sr. died at Daytona.
There has been a many in-season deaths of MLB players: Darryl Kyle… Thurman Munson… Tyler Skaggs… Nick Adenhart… no one thought to not play as a league.
I’d leave it alone @ejhill. Some People have opined – some people disagree. Some agree. That’s okay. It’s a big world and there’s room for all of us.
Edited to add: (after a few beers) I am not the same person that I was on 9/10/2001. For that matter, I am not the same person that I was in summer 2022. Or summer 2021. Or summer 2020. Or summer 2019. And guess what? None of these young men are the same young men as they should have been in 2020, 2021, 2022, had those years not been so ridiculous. And know what? That’s on us. Boomers. We own this. We forced the young to pay a price to supposedly keep safe the old. That’s you and me.
Bringing up instances in the past and trying to compare them to January 2023 does not work; it’s literally not relevant. Is that a good thing? A bad thing? I have no idea. But I do know it doesn’t work.