Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
A Train Wreck Waiting to Happen?
The first two years of the Biden administration have been a train wreck. Now that Republicans have a majority in the House, there is a chance to, at the very least, slow down the Woke Express in the next two years of a Biden administration.
The infighting between Republicans over the Speaker of the House reminds me of a parliamentary government. More time is spent on coalition building and then coalition failures that lead to a parade of Prime Ministers. I would hope that Republican representatives come to their senses and realize that they have a chance to influence Senate legislation. They also have the ability to control Biden’s spending over the next two years.
The egos, and the intellect of those who are elected to the House are interesting and amusing. You get two years of short-term employment to try and stop the train, but as it speeds down the track you spend that time tossing each other off the train.
GK Chesterton:
Published in PoliticsThe whole modern world has divided itself into Conservatives and Progressives. The business of Progressives is to go on making mistakes. The business of Conservatives is to prevent mistakes from being corrected. Even when the revolutionist might himself repent of his revolution, the traditionalist is already defending it as part of his tradition. Thus we have two great types — the advanced person who rushes us into ruin, and the retrospective person who admires the ruins. He admires them especially by moonlight, not to say moonshine. Each new blunder of the progressive or prig becomes instantly a legend of immemorial antiquity for the snob. This is called the balance, or mutual check, in our Constitution. (Illustrated London News, 1924)
Conservatives are calling for change, and it’s making Republicans very uncomfortable.
Like the majority of them really care.
Substitute “thoughtless” for “advanced” and the quote pretty much has it.
A GOP Speaker can do very little in 2023. There will be an opportunity at the debt ceiling and whatever they expose though investigations. If the Speaker is a typical GOPe, they will choose to surrender on the debt ceiling and protect the Dems and Deep State in any investigation and thus waste 2 years of majority. There are a few Freedom Caucus fighters that think America needs more, much more–real investigations and hard-line negotiations on the debt ceiling to undo the Leftist agenda. I agree with them. We can’t win, if we don’t fight and fighting is uncomfortable. Sorry.
What? Actually do what they were sent to Washington to do?
You ask too much!
In a normal year, we’d probably have at least three main-feed posts on today’s House Speaker election, at least one by an editor of the site.
I suppose it’s because everyone’s exhausted by years of ginned-up drama by the ruling class and an exhausting mid-term election year, but . . . it seems like everyone understands how little it matters.
Even this post has only gotten five comments today. (Six if you count this one.)
I can’t decide if that apathy is good or bad.
I’m thinking . . . good?
Apathy is good, if results in Jim Jordan being Speaker. That guy is literally and figuratively willing to fight anyone at any time.
Republicans are playing a dangerous game. In the third round of voting:
Hakim Jeffries (D) was short 6 votes of becoming House Speaker.
When I was on the streets, I never called a subject an idiot. I said sir, or ma’am I’m not calling you an idiot, but you’re acting like one. Whether it’s one Republican, or 20 Republicans I’m not going to call them idiots, but they’re acting like idiots.
Why isn’t anyone considering that Kevin McCarthy is publicly trying to ram his speakership through the congress. If you are such a leader, then lead your own conference. But he’s not. Perhaps he will now that the House has adjourned sede vacante. Lots of people think the freedom caucus votes were making fools of themselves. Lots of other people think Kevin McCarthy made a fool of himself.
What is the danger? Do you think 20 Republicans are going to choose to not vote? Or that 10 will vote for Jeffries?
Seriously, what is the risk?
The risks are a miscalculation on the actual voting. Jim Jordan does not seem to be interested in the Speaker’s job. He would be a great Party Whip. Want to remove Swalwell, and Schiff from any committee then have Jordan convince McCarthy to get rid of them. Want to revisit funding for 87,000 IRS agents then quit screwing around and begin that process on January 4.
The GOP couldn’t even defund the baby-parts traffickers at Planned Parenthood when they held the White House and both houses of Congress.
Defunding 87,000 IRS agents? Not a chance that’ll ever happen.
Right now, the risk is that Jim Jordan takes enough votes away from, let’s say 30 or 40 from the current 20 votes. The Dems are voting a straight Jeffries vote. 218 votes are all Jeffries (D) needs to become Speaker.
That would require six Republicans to join the Democrats. Can you imagine! Talk about ending your career in a blaze of glory!
Republicans are nailing down the Stupid Party trophy. The idiocy on display in the House will serve only to persuade Americans that the GOP is not only not ready for primetime, they’re not ready for morning or drive time, either. Maybe wee hour, paid programming time, but even that might be a stretch.
I think we might end of with Don Bacon, Republican of Nebraska, as Speaker of the House.
Don Bacon has already said that if the 19-20 Republicans refusing to support Kevin McCarthy keep it up, he and a group of Republicans will form a coalition with the Democrats and have a bi-partisan Speaker.
https://dailycaller.com/2023/01/02/opinion-if-mccarthys-speaker-bid-fails-democrats-might-have-to-be-part-of-the-process-rep-don-bacon/
You better hope that every Republican can attend the voting for Speaker. Six votes are a slim majority.
Also, the House can vote to allow a Speaker to be chosen by a plurality, rather than a majority, of the House vote. They can also vote to choose a Speaker through ranked choice voting.
But we already knew that.
That would require changing the rules. They can’t even agree on the rules.
Why doesn’t McCarthy put forward an acceptable alternative himself?
I’ll answer my own question: It’s so very hard to give up power, isn’t it?
Do we maybe have an answer to Joshua’s question (“Choose ye this day whom ye will serve..”)
There is no acceptable alternative.
The 19-20 Republicans want either Jim Jordan or someone like him.
There are about 20 Republicans from New York, New Jersey and California who don’t want Jim Jordan or someone like him.
So, it’s a deadlock. No Republican can get 218 votes.
Right now McCarthy has the support of 90 percent of Republicans. But that’s not enough.
Acceptable to whom?
Marjorie Taylor Green of GA is by no means a GOPe member. The GOPe in GA is not happy with her most of the time. She voted for McCarthy.
I want the GOP to change. Giving control to the Democrats is not the way to win. This is not a “vote harder” situation, it is going with what we got.
These 19 people are grandstanding. I don’t believe for a moment, they are doing any of this on principle. It is about their personal power, not what is best for the GOP and not what is best for America.
They are there to do a job, and they are looking for perks.
I’d been following the drama on this leadership vote but mainly through online/print. That was the first, extended coverage I’d seen of Matt Gaetz’ objections and they are pretty cogent and worthy of debate & coverage. Too much of this vote has been about “shut up and go along/we look like we can’t govern (as if what’s been going on there could be defined as governing)”. It may be messy but these kinds of fights against the staus quo are long overdue. The Continuing Resolution mode of budgeting is an embarrasment and McCarthy & McConnell have been in on this farce for decades now.
With all the loose “lobbying” cash floating around, and all the egos involved in this mess, I won’t be surprised if we end up having a Democrat Speaker.
Yes. I thought so, too.
The Status Quo is not acceptable. And it does my heart good to see members of Congress using what little power they have against it. They may end up defeated in the end. But not for lack of trying.