Quote of the Day: Dr. Larry Arnn, President of Hillsdale College, on Beauty

 

We periodically receive in our email a little newsletter from Dr. Arnn titled “The Life of Hillsdale College.” They are always stimulating and reassuring that real education, not indoctrination, is taking place at Hillsdale. This one was received on March 1, 2022. Having spent a fair amount of time with Dr. Arnn, I can hear his voice speaking the words.

On Saturday, our chamber ensembles performed in our Christ Chapel. A week earlier the Chapel chorus performed Evensong. These events and many like them resounded in that magnificent structure, a blessing to us all designed by the splendid architect Duncan Stroik. They are the product of skill and work cultivated for years and decades. In that work, the students and teachers continue a line as long as civilization.

Christ Chapel and most of the music played in it are “beautiful.” Beauty is one of the “three transcendentals.” A noble tradition says they are the highest objects of study and apprehension. The word beauty is cognate with “beatitude,” meaning supreme happiness, or in the Christian faith, meaning the experience of seeing God, the perfect Being.

Is beauty in the eye of the beholder? Many have always thought so. Today probably most do—except, that is, when they see it. Then it captivates the eye and, in the same instant, the soul.

Everyone has the experience of beauty. He sees something so fine that it calls a halt to other sensing and thinking. Did you ever walk into Yosemite Valley? If not, go do it. If your eyes are not clouded by some intrusive dogma, you will see that this is no ordinary scene. Have you listened to the “Sanctus” movement in Faure’s Requiem, in which the voices swell up to heaven to sing the call of praise, “Hosanna in the highest?” The hearer who attends must think this an evidence of the divine in us.

Do not miss the evidence of beauty that can break out in popular music, except when it is corrupted by the ugliness of the age. In graduate school, I learned with a lasting friend to admire the country singer George Jones. Listen to “Still Doin’ Time” or “He Stopped Loving Her Today”—in them is heartbreak defined.

There is beauty in human acting and speaking. I have always loved the Peoria speech by Lincoln. It is not a poetic masterpiece like the Gettysburg Address or the Second Inaugural. Instead, it is a masterful exposition of the fact that we have always known the evil of slavery, except he says that a new and evil ideology has made some forget it. The speech is a narrative of events, but along the way, Lincoln stops to give one of his axiomatic proofs, as close to Euclid anyone has ever come in rhetoric. If the right to property, he argues, belongs to any man, that by itself proves that no man may rightly own another. It is curious, but reading that speech once made me burst into tears. Lincoln was arguing for the beauty of our country, and through that argument he would save it.

It is not given to mortal man to say definitely what is the most beautiful scene or music or structure or book or speech, but the real contenders are as different from the ordinary as a mountain from a molehill. My son-in-law, a Plato scholar, thinks Bernini the superior of Michelangelo. Surely not, but it is a respectable opinion for a young man. If he had said Mapplethorpe I would have ejected him. But he would not.

Today, in our zeal to conquer everything including nature and God, we lose our powers of observation. We see a child grow and learn, and we think we are making it grow and learn. We paint a picture and think we are providing the beauty to the scene. We compose music that rants and threatens and think it graceful because we—or rather I—did it. This is a failure of education that also destroys the chance of it.

Beautiful things happen here at Hillsdale College frequently. It is the reason we are here. We wish to learn to see with perceptive eyes, to hear with acute ears, to think and talk with comprehending minds—and then we can behold the beautiful. That is the experience nearest heaven on earth.  Come and join us. It is the best and highest fun.

Published in Group Writing
This post was promoted to the Main Feed by a Ricochet Editor at the recommendation of Ricochet members. Like this post? Want to comment? Join Ricochet’s community of conservatives and be part of the conversation. Join Ricochet for Free.

There are 5 comments.

Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.
  1. Susan Quinn Contributor
    Susan Quinn
    @SusanQuinn

    Dr. Arnn is so eloquent. And he’s also gifted with insight and a wry sense of humor. Thanks, RB.

    • #1
  2. Rodin Member
    Rodin
    @Rodin

    Interesting argument that we “find” beauty but do not “create” it. We learn what constitutes the transcendent and may assemble (reproduce) it from created parts, but cannot originate it. Beauty helps us understand our subordinate role to G-d.

    • #2
  3. Unsk Member
    Unsk
    @Unsk

    There was a day , not too long ago,  when  most artists pursued “Truth and Beauty”in their art.

    But that pursuit did not serve the Marxist aim to destroy enough of society to create a chaos where the ruling order could be overturned.  So now if you pursue ‘truth and beauty” in your art you are likely to be cancelled quite severely, for failing  the ruling Marxist creed.

    • #3
  4. Jim George Member
    Jim George
    @JimGeorge

    RushBabe49: We periodically receive in our email a little newsletter from Dr. Arnn titled “The Life of Hillsdale College.” They are always stimulating and reassuring that real education, not indoctrination, is taking place at Hillsdale. This one was received on March 1, 2022. Having spent a fair amount of time with Dr. Arnn, I can hear his voice speaking the words.

    We had the inestimable honor of meeting Dr. Arnn and having an opportunity to have a nice conversation with him at the Hillsdale Leadership Conference in Naples, Florida back in February. To be with him is an experience difficult  to describe in mere words and to hear him speak can be downright magical at times as he is one of the true intellectuals we have ever had the privilege to hear and to be with. As you know, he sprinkles his talks with liberal (not the best use of words for Dr. Arnn, but is meant in the classical sense, not the current corrupted sense) references not only to Aristotle’s works, but to Book numbered citations. I so appreciated your sending this discourse on beauty as it encapsulates so much beauty in such a small amount of words. I plan to share it with my friends on my blog (and again thank you for being in that number!). 

    Rushbabe, I should also mention that one of the most touching discussions of beauty we have seen was in a television special put on, I believe, by the BBC, and featured one of my, and so many others’, I am sure, favorite conservative intellectuals of all time, Sir Roger Scruton (RIP). While I am sure you have seen it, if you have not, I would urge you to watch it as it is a masterful presentation in the way only Sir Roger could have handled it. 

    As we have gotten more involved with Hillsdale in the recent past we hope to make a visit to the campus soon, perhaps for the seminar on Russia in early October. 

    Thanks again for this wonderful post. Jim

    • #4
  5. Lilly B Coolidge
    Lilly B
    @LillyB

    RushBabe49:

    It is not given to mortal man to say definitely what is the most beautiful scene or music or structure or book or speech, but the real contenders are as different from the ordinary as a mountain from a molehill. 

    Arnn’s essay is a wonderful invitation to really observe and acknowledge beauty, “…If your eyes are not clouded by some intrusive dogma…” 

    ******

    This post of part of the Quote of the Day (QOTD) group writing project. If you would like to share a quote with or without your own commentary, please pick an unclaimed date on the August QOTD Signup Sheet. The links to the previous month of QOTD posts can be accessed here.

    • #5
Become a member to join the conversation. Or sign in if you're already a member.