Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Everyone Worships Something: 7 Steps Down the Aisle of Toleration’s Church
“Tolerance” is a doctrine. In theology or education or everyday life, “doctrine” is ever present. Everyone has doctrine since everyone has beliefs. We subscribe to a teaching, dogma, or creed to explain what we believe. Our commitment to that set of teachings limits our acceptance of contrary or adversarial claims. It does not matter if you are a feminist, committed to LGBTQ+, a Baptist preacher, or a conservative talk show host; you have doctrine. Everyone everywhere has doctrine. But in our current cultural moment, identity, ethnic, sexual, and gender politics demand our belief in the doctrine of tolerance.
I will use the metaphors of religious ideas and icons to communicate the cultural doctrine of “tolerance.” First, toleration demands “understanding,” then “acceptance,” then “allegiance,” then “obeisance,” then “conformity,” and ultimately “evangelism.” The ordered steps down the cathedral aisle do not matter as much as the baptismal outcome. Hollywood’s hymnal sings both obvious and subtle references to accepted and rejected points of view. Celebrities must bow before the altar of imposed speech codes. News outlets preach from their pulpits against the latest outrage. The plight of those suffering worldwide is reported only if their deaths reinforce the common book of party prayer. Catechismal teaching reinforces the moment-by-moment commitment to membership in the church of toleration. Excommunication is swift for any who would sin against accepted authority. Reputational ruin comes to anyone daring to cross the received cultural commandments. Toleration’s heaven accepts the culturally righteous who are the tolerant saints wearing white robes of social purity. Toleration’s hell awaits anyone who has rejected salvation offered by the cultural gods of the day.
Let me be perfectly clear. I am tolerant, kind, generous, respectful, and gracious to people, no matter who they are or what they believe. But I will always speak out against ideas — the doctrine of tolerance included — that stand against the doctrines of God’s word.
Published in General
This new church of evil also is impossible to stay in if the mob turns on you. Being OK today does not mean you will be OK with them tomorrow.
Exactly. Forgiveness is impossible in “the church” because there is no sacrifice that can eradicate sin. Something I produced in video this past summer: https://youtu.be/S_GbJeFZQr0
It is all about will to power.
Even Luciferians?
Sure. Even them. 2 Timothy 2:24-26
I think you might be able to add one more step as those who preach tolerance usually end up embodying intolerance.
And then you become David French.
Yep. They are tolerant as long as you believe in the same thing they are promulgating.
There is a difference between tolerance and acceptance. Excommunication is not just a punishment, it is also carried out to give the sinner a chance to save their soul, tough love in other words. A road back is being offered to an individual.
There is a danger to those that believe a sinner is beyond redemption. Believing a sinner is beyond redemption implies that there are some sins that are greater than the Holy Spirit, which is really a form of blasphemy.
The best quote on tolerance that I have ever heard comes from Archbishop Charles Chaput:
Maybe the key question is this: Can we tolerate the intolerant?
I don’t think so. I think that it is a big mistake to head down this path. This turns out to be a mechanism for suppression of those who disagree with you, by the simple expedient of classifying them as “intolerant.”
This was Herbert Marcuse’s argument in Repressive Tolerance, an important — I would say infamous — essay from 1965. For those unfamiliar with him, Marcuse was a neo-Marxist and probably the most influential member of the Frankfurt School.
James Lindsay has a fine series of four videos discussing and criticizing Repressive Tolerance. The first is here, if anyone is interested.