Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Best Star Spangled Banner Performance: Diana Ross
Diana Ross was the first pop star to perform the national anthem at a Super Bowl, and her 1982 performance set a standard not yet surpassed at any professional sports venue. From high school to professional sports events, Americans have long started these secular public rites with our national anthem. The NFL had long leaned on college marching bands and choruses, but broke from tradition with a pop star actually past the peak of her genre. Diana Ross, Motown royalty, rose to the occasion in Detroit’s Silverdome Stadium, setting the standard for future performers.
There are three basic rules for a good national anthem vocal performance:
- Get the lyrics right
- Stay on tune
- It ain’t about you; points off for stylizing in most forums
Diana Ross knocked all of these out of the stadium, and she did it without a net. She sang unaccompanied and without auto-tune correcting her pitch. She knew the words by heart, to the level of not stumbling in front of a large live and nationally televised audience.
Listen to the beginning. She gives a brief introduction, inviting the live audience and players to sing with her.
Can we sing, our national anthem, with authority?
Sing with me.
Diana Ross then makes a short gesture with her microphone that cues a pianist, off-screen, to give her the first note. Just the first note, mind you. Then she launches into a completely straightforward rendition, without any of her craft’s signature vocal ornamentation. The audience responds by listening in silence and then singing along with Miss Diana Ross. You see some of the very rough-looking football players of the era joining in towards the end.
There have been any good and bad, great and occasionally ghastly performances.* Yes, Whitney Houston gave an amazing dramatic performance at Super Bowl XXV, but I stand by my claim that Motown star Diana Ross set the gold standard for all professional sports venue performances of the Star-Spangled Banner back at Super Bowl XVI, in the Motor City.
What say you?
This post is part of our September group writing theme: “Best and Worst.” We have many open days left this month. From songs to tennis matches, it is easy to fit an idea or a pet peeve into this month’s theme. Do Ricochet a favor and sign up today. Pitch your own post as part of our September group writing theme: “Best and Worst.”
Interested in Group Writing topics that came before? See the handy compendium of monthly themes. Check out links in the Group Writing Group. You can also join the group to get a notification when a new monthly theme is posted.
* Honorable Mention to Demi Lovato for getting the lyrics right, singing on tune (with autotune assumed), and not significantly stylizing after her platinum album achievement.
Published in Group Writing
A thousand times, no! She’s one of the very best ever. You don’t have to like her singing, but from a technical perspective she was simply amazing.
And her vocal coach said she had trouble with her mid-range. Trouble is relative.
One of the critical things – necessary but not sufficient – for a great singer is range. Houston had that big-time, another favorite of mine although she didn’t display it in quite the same way, is Heather Nova (nee Heather Frith) who also writes her own songs, and plays many instruments too.
Mid intensity maybe. All she has is one constant INTENSITY.
Not really.
Sorry, I’m not falling for it. There is no way I’m going to get an ear worm listening to Intensity Houston.
Something else that’s never happened to me: getting an “ear worm” of any song or singer that I actually don’t like.
Your argument is best made with a live performance. Like this, perhaps:
Well, those are both intense songs. What’s your point?
Did you hear her sing the Star Spangled Banner? She had full volume control, and used it.
I played this on the sax, exactly the way she sings it with grace notes, and it’s really got great diversity in volume, timber and “intensity”. She does this very, very well. Very, very, very well. And perfect pitch throughout.
It sure is. A million singers would give their eye-teeth for trouble like that.