Ricochet is the best place on the internet to discuss the issues of the day, either through commenting on posts or writing your own for our active and dynamic community in a fully moderated environment. In addition, the Ricochet Audio Network offers over 50 original podcasts with new episodes released every day.
Student Prevented From Handing Out Constitutions on Constitution Day Sues His College
A couple of weeks back, I wrote about Robert Van Tuinen, a student in California whose college banned him from distributing copies of the Constitution in public areas of campus on September 17—Constitution Day. The story was national news and rightfully outraged many supporters of free expression (not to mention common sense) nationwide.
Unfortunately, despite the widespread criticism of Modesto Junior College’s actions, college president Jill Stearns has since only agreed to “evaluate” the school’s policies that resulted in the censorship of Van Tuinen. Today, the school still requires that students register their expression five days in advance and limit it to a tiny, cement “free speech area.” It should therefore come as no surprise that Van Tuinen is suing the Yosemite Community College District and Modesto Junior College administrators for violating his free speech rights both under the California Constitution and the First Amendment.
FIRE Senior VP Robert Shibley put it well in today’s press release:
“Constitutional law can get pretty complicated at times. This is not one of those times … As FIRE has said from the beginning, every person at Modesto Junior College responsible for enforcing this policy should have known better. The fact that Modesto’s policy was not immediately abandoned when its shameful results were exposed on video is more evidence that too many college administrators fear freedom of speech—and demonstrates how out of touch they are with an American public that respects the First Amendment.”
I’ll continue to update Ricochet members on the case as it plays out. In the meantime, you can relive Van Tuinen’s surreal ordeal in this video:
Published in General
I apologize for not already knowing the answer to this, but may I assume that these schools are state institutions?
Thanks Ryan. Yes, MJC is public and there is plenty of case law going back decades about free speech on public campuses and to what extent they serve as public forums. It would take me a lot more than this space to explain it but I can offer my book, Unlearning Liberty, the FIRE Guide to Free Speech on Campus, and, several recent cases, including this one about U Cincy. This should not be a tough call for the CA courts, legally speaking. As for whether or nor not colleges is or should be closed to the general public is not an issue here as the plaintiff is a student at the college.
Good for him!
Yeah – the entire concept of the constitution is completely lost on the University administration staff…
I can just imagine the alumni from the 60s in today’s college campuses. Oh what fun it would be to watch. I recently re-watched Dead Poets Society; it is as though all Universities today are the Welton Academy….
Oh, I’m familiar with the law (in general, anyway) – having worked (as an intern) with Institute for Justice (and, for what it’s worth, I think I sent an inquiry to FIRE at one point) – I was just curious whether the particular school is public and whether it has been deemed a public forum by case-law.
I’ll read the case; that sounds very interesting.
Good to hear. Thanks, Gregg. Will continue to follow with interest.
I’m a lawyer. Who is FIRE and where do I go to volunteer? This is the absurdist bloody thing I’ve ever heard.
The most powerful and disturbing parts of that video were the map which showed the tiny little “free speech area” and the woman checking the schedule to find the last two days in the month when the student could exercise his free speech. On a university campus — supposedly a forum for the free expression of ideas — ones liberty to share the truth and express ideas is only available by appointment and ghettoized to a tiny area of a large campus. Shameful.
Agreed! And FSZs are scarily common at universities as well. If you have a minute, check out this video about the previously mentioned FIRE case at U Cincy.
There is no free speech on college campuses. My own wife, going back to school after 20-odd years away, is worried about expressing her own opinions in class for fear of getting a lower grade. She said “I’m just going to get through this class and get my grade and move on.” If she were to go to the administration, I am sure they’d pay her lip service and do nothing about it. However, if the political ideologies were different, you can bet heads would roll.
Van Tuinen, FIRE, and supporters might also want to talk to Liberty Institute. These guys handle mostly Establishment and Free Exercise questions, but they might have some ideas/help here, too.
Eric Hines
Greg — Thanks for the video link. I had no idea these “free speech zones” were so common. One would hope that the court finding in the Cincinnati case would have have resulted in other campuses eliminating the FSZs as well. Perhaps it needs a SCOTUS ruling. We should all make a donation to FIRE in the meantime.
Thank you, Karen.
The only reason why we likely will not get a SCOTUS decision is because the law is already quite clear these shenanigans are against the Constitution. Campuses like this are scofflaws and it may take the constant threat of a lawsuit to get them to act better. Cynical and sad, but true.
Time once again to refer to Indoctrinate U, with an appearance by Dr. Lukianoff!
Yes, we do have a Legal Network and we’d love to have you and any other Ricochet lawyers join. You can sign up here: http://thefire.org/takeaction/lawyers/
And, yes, I have been doing this now for 12 years and the stuff campus admins try to pull STILL surprises me on a regular basis.