Troy Senik · Dec 30, 2011 at 1:18pm

One of the things that has rankled me throughout this campaign has been the widespread talking point that the more familiar someone is with Newt Gingrich, the less they like him. Having written for Newt, that wasn't my experience at all. Whether you love him or hate him, watch this video from a forum in Iowa earlier today and recognize that there is a beating heart to the man that rivals his brain and his lungs:

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

Ben Domenech

I'll have more to say on this after Iowa, but I actually think the problem with the past month has been Newt trying too hard to be likeable, when it was the angry Newt Republicans loved all along.

Trink
Joined
Apr '11
Trink

OK.  He's real.  So are these tears.

flownover
Joined
Aug '10
flownover

Iowa .....eh ( don't let it bother you Newt ) It's Des Moines Jake. 

What's the big deal. Anyplace there's even a chance of people actually giving a majority to Ron Paul shouldn't be considered as telling of anything other than what's been going on within it's borders. And that is 4-5 years grassroots Paulian work. 

Thomas Sowell, Art Laffer will tell you that this is the smartest,most experienced guy in the room. The MSM will do their best to make him a porcupine, and the GOP hierarchy may, may have some feelings about it, but so what ? The voters need to send someone in who can rectify things. If he can cry good. He can't cry like a Bush. That's a good thing because they were soft in the end, especially when Paulson and his gang rolled over the admin.

Edited on Dec 30, 2011 at 2:00pm
Russ Hayes
University of Michigan
Russ Hayes

Certainly more convincing than Hillary's tearing up 4 years ago in New Hampshire, anyway.  

flownover
Joined
Aug '10
flownover
Russ Hayes: Certainly more convincing than Hillary's tearing up 4 years ago in New Hampshire, anyway.   · Dec 30 at 1:49pm

Or how about Bill Clinton's crying act at Ron Brown's funeral ?

Scott Reusser
Joined
May '10
Scott Reusser

Who couldn't love Newt after that? But loving Newt and being comfortable with him as president are two entirely different things.

This clip confirms still more what those of us who deeply admire Newt, yet also have deep misgivings about Newt as president, suspect: that he's a wonderful man and an intensely emotional and brilliant man, but one who has a manic nature (for which his mother's bipolar disorder provides further evidence) that , while an amazing asset when channeled, comes with profound risks.

Newt-as-president is a gamble of the first order, akin to putting an Eisenhower-free Patton in charge of Allied Forces. A potential stroke of genius, yes, but just as likely a disaster -- and hence a profoundly unconservative thing to do.

   


Joined
Jan '11
Anon

Complex human beings, particularly those capable of broad spectrum thinking, are big targets.

Pseudodionysius
Joined
Sep '10
Pseudodionysius

This clip confirms still more what those of us who deeply admire Newt, yet also have deep misgivings about Newt as president, suspect: that he's a wonderful man and an intensely emotional and brilliant man, but one who has a manic nature (for which his mother's bipolar disorder provides further evidence) that , while an amazing asset when channeled, comes with profound risks.

Very well put Scott. That does, indeed, explain a lot.

David Williamson
Joined
Mar '11
David Williamson
Pseudodionysius: This clip confirms still more what those of us who deeply admire Newt, yet also have deep misgivings about Newt as president, suspect: that he's a wonderful man and an intensely emotional and brilliant man, but one who has a manic nature (for which his mother's bipolar disorder provides further evidence) that , while an amazing asset when channeled, comes with profound risks.

Not to worry - we have as President a man with total control of his emotions (and his pants are sharply creased).

Fake John Galt
Joined
Jul '11
Fake John Galt

Maybe I am just being old school here, but I don't want a crying President at least not in public and on the air unless it is at a funeral. I think this touchy feely stuff gets us in trouble on the world stage as others perceive it as weakness.

Scott Reusser
Joined
May '10
Scott Reusser

David Williamson

Pseudodionysius: This clip confirms still more what those of us who deeply admire Newt, yet also have deep misgivings about Newt as president, suspect: that he's a wonderful man and an intensely emotional and brilliant man, but one who has a manic nature (for which his mother's bipolar disorder provides further evidence) that , while an amazing asset when channeled, comes with profound risks.

Not to worry - we have as President a man with total control of his emotions (and his pants are sharply creased). · Dec 30 at 4:52pm

Cute, I guess, if I'd made the case that self control is sufficient for an effective presidency -- but of course I didn't.

Joseph Eagar
Joined
Oct '10
Joseph Eagar

Troy, how many others like you are there?  There's just so many anecdotal reports of former and current Congressmen and their staffers hating the guy.

Western Chauvinist
Joined
Dec '10
Western Chauvinist

Um, Newt's adopted isn't he? That pretty much rules out a genetic link with his mother's bipolar disorder. I'd attribute this particular episode to exhaustion, and, well, having a heart.

Scott Reusser
Joined
May '10
Scott Reusser
Joseph Eagar: Troy, how many others like you are there?  There's just so many anecdotal reports of former and current Congressmen and their staffers hating the guy. · Dec 31 at 12:12am

"Hating" might not be the right word, Joseph. Most, best I can tell, just think he's ill-suited to the presidency.

Western Chauvinist: Um, Newt's adopted isn't he? That pretty much rules out a genetic link with his mother's bipolar disorder. I'd attribute this particular episode to exhaustion, and, well, having a heart. · Dec 31 at 8:07am

Good catch, WC (although ADHD, bipolar, etc are also statistically higher in adopted kids, too, but I won't go there).

But the point of my comment was not that "crying = instability". Not at all. It's that this clip reveals his deep and obvious goodness, a quality that many of us have known to be there, even while considering him an unwise choice for pres. 

Bob Schwalbaum
Joined
Jun '11
Bob Schwalbaum

 Turned me off completely.. much like my reaction to John Boehner's bawling at the drop of.. you-name-it.

Western Chauvinist
Joined
Dec '10
Western Chauvinist

Great. So Newt's too erratic to be president and Mitt's too milquetoast to beat Obama. Someone remind me how we got here?

Joseph Eagar
Joined
Oct '10
Joseph Eagar
Western Chauvinist: Great. So Newt's too erratic to be president and Mitt's too milquetoast to beat Obama. Someone remind me how we got here? · Dec 31 at 12:44pm

Mitch Daniels declined to run.  So did Paul Ryan, Chris Christie, and Haley Barbour.  Claire put it best when she commented on the historic abnormality of a group of talented leaders "dangerously disinclined to seek power."


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In