Claire Berlinski, Ed. · Jan 26, 2011 at 12:26am

Stop me if you've heard this one before. Oh, yeah, you can't. 

Okan sent this to me yesterday, and I'm still not sure whether I'm dismayed that I got it right immediately or kind of proud because I love doing well on tests, even when the test measures total derangement. (I was once looking up the signs of clinical depression on the Internet to see if I was depressed and in need of treatment, rather than just blue. I cheered up so much when I got a perfect score on the Hamilton Depression Index that no further intervention was necessary.)  

I maintain that calling it "the psychopath test" is such a huge giveaway that the question couldn't possibly have any diagnostic value. But because there's that little niggling concern in my mind, I figured I'd run it up the Ricochet flagpole and see who else shoots it dead without so much as a measurable change in his galvanic skin response and then goes out for a box of donuts and never thinks about it again.

So, the e-mail goes like this:

Read this question, then come up with an answer. This is not a trick question. It is as it reads. No one I know has gotten it right. Few people do.

A woman, while at the funeral of her own mother, met a man she did not know. 

She thought the man was amazing.  She believed him to be the man of her dreams--so much that she fell in love with him right there, but she never asked for his number and afterwards couldn't find him.   

A few days later she killed her sister.

Question: What was her motive for killing her sister?

Suggest your answers; I'll tell you the right answer at the end of the day. Apparently, if you come up with that answer, it's a bad, bad sign.

The e-mail says it was a test used by an American psychologist to determine whether the subject had a killer's mind. (This could of course be nonsense, and I'd guess probably is.) But the legend says that many arrested serial killers answered the question correctly. And so did I--without having to think about it much, frankly. I mean, it's obvious, isn't it?

Isn't it? 

UPDATE: The Psychopath Answer

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

dittoheadadt
Joined
Oct '10
dittoheadadt

So she could meet the man again, presumably at her sister's funeral.  (Since he went to the mother's funeral, he'd be likely to attend the sister's.) 

Dietlbomb
Joined
May '10
Dietlbomb

For the inheritance.

Fredösphere
Joined
May '10
Fredösphere

The correct answer works on the level of a joke, but puuuuuleeeez: she's so unresourceful she can't find out the name of someone so close to her family that he attended her mom's funeral and might attend her sister's, but she's resourceful enough to murder with the hope of getting away with it? Nonsense. This is not a test of a psychopath, it's a test of an idiot.

I did laugh when I read the answer, though.

Kervinlee
Joined
May '10
Kervinlee

I could tell you the answer, but then I'l have to kill you. (I'm just kidding!)

I'm too paranoid to answer questions like that.


Joined
Jan '11
Chris Corrigan

 Every woman I have asked (3) has gotten the right answer almost immediately.  None of the men (3), me included got it right.  I'm not sure what that means...

Tripedis Canis
Joined
Jul '10
Tripedis Canis

Having been inspired by Ken Owsley:

  • It's not her sister. It's a hallucination she's had for years in which she has a sister, who is responsible for all the bad things that she does, and she must be destroyed so that she can be good, and so that Hunky will come back, and so that the other voices will just shut UP! (h/t Hollywood)
  • Her sister's not really dead. They just conspired together to make it look like she was dead, so that they could haunt the family home and keep people away until they located the money that Mom had embezzled from the bank years before. (h/t Scooby Doo and the Gang)
  • She didn't kill her sister, her sister killed her! (h/t M. Night Shyamalan)
  • In a flashback, we see that she and her sister were actually CIA operatives working with Interpol to try to capture Hunky, who was a vaguely european terrorist type, and that he killed the sister and framed the other, who, flash forward, changed her name, posed as her own mother, and is gathering enough evidence to clear herself/overthrow the government/both. (h/t Lost, etc)
Bill Walsh

Because he'd come to her funeral, and then they could be happy forever!!! ZOMG!!! That's beautiful!!!


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In