George Savage · Jan 12, 2011 at 6:20pm

I'd like to extend my personal thanks to the President for his thoughtful and moving speech in Tucson honoring last Saturday's shooting victims.  Aunt Phyllis would have approved.  And been delighted by Mr. Obama's send-off.

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

Emily Esfahani Smith, Ed.

"A few minutes after we left her room...Gabby opened her eyes from the first time." --Obama during the speech. 

Emily Esfahani Smith, Ed.

A moving speech indeed. 

Sisyphus
Joined
Jul '10
Sisyphus

I am pleased that his words met with your approval, George.  My best to you and your family.

Steven Potter
Joined
Aug '10
Steven Potter
Sisyphus: I am pleased that his words met with your approval, George.  My best to you and your family. · Jan 12 at 6:29pm

Same here.

Ken Owsley
Joined
Nov '10
Ken Owsley

And here's me doing my check book when I should have been watching Barry O.

Kenneth
Joined
Jul '10
Kenneth

How many times did he say, "I"?

Tommy De Seno

 I thought of you during, George.

He may have moved the country forward by distancing himself from what we've been hearing the past few days.

Doing it with Job was wonderful. 

+ 1 Mr. President.

Too much cheering though at times. Felt more like a State of the Union show than a memorial service at time, but that may be reflective of the college aged crowd at the University.

Edited on Jan 12, 2011 at 6:44pm
Mike LaRoche
Joined
Oct '10
Mike LaRoche
Kenneth: How many times did he say, "I"? · Jan 12 at 6:41pm

More times than Ricky Ricardo.

Kenneth
Joined
Jul '10
Kenneth

Mike LaRoche

Kenneth: How many times did he say, "I"? · Jan 12 at 6:41pm

More times than Ricky Ricardo. · Jan 12 at 6:45pm

Lol.  That's "Aye!", Gringo.

Mike LaRoche
Joined
Oct '10
Mike LaRoche

Kenneth

Mike LaRoche

Kenneth: How many times did he say, "I"? · Jan 12 at 6:41pm

More times than Ricky Ricardo. · Jan 12 at 6:45pm

Lol.  That's "Aye!", Gringo. · Jan 12 at 6:48pm

Lo siento. ;)

Erik Larsen
Joined
Jan '11
Erik Larsen

Mike LaRoche, warn me next time! Funny

Brian Watt
Joined
Jun '10
Brian Watt

No doubt Obama's best speech. Very moving. The exuberance of some in the auditorium was a bit unsettling at times. I thought that some of the hoots, hollers and shout outs were a bit strange. 

That said, I don't know how anyone, even here on Ricochet, can argue with the substance of the President's speech. And I am one of his harshest critics but I'll take the night off. The memory of what happened and of the wonderful lives lost are more important to reflect upon.

All the best, George.

Kenneth
Joined
Jul '10
Kenneth

I just read the transcript.  It's well-written, conciliatory.  Should be instrumental in putting all this ugly noise behind us. 

Midget Faded Rattlesnake
Joined
Aug '10
Midget Faded Rattlesnake

Where is the transcript?

I am especially curious as to what he said about Job (having recently put some of my own thoughts about Job regarding the matter here.)

EDIT: Oh, never mind. I've found the transcript on my own and read it already. Moving speech.

Edited on Jan 12, 2011 at 8:11pm
Ottoman Umpire
Joined
May '10
Ottoman Umpire

Here's a link: http://www.omaha.com/article/20110112/AP/701139850


Joined
May '10
David Jones

The audience was atrocious, but the President was at his best--it was a very moving speech and it was a wonderful tribute to the fallen.

I am happy to hear that your Aunt would have approved.

Emily Esfahani Smith, Ed.

Tommy De Seno:  Too much cheering though at times. Felt more like a State of the Union show than a memorial service at time, but that may be reflective of the college aged crowd at the University. · Jan 12 at 6:43pm

Edited on Jan 12 at 06:44 pm

I agree. With all the cheering from the audience, it felt like Obama was on the campaign trail--maybe he was. 

TucsonSean
Joined
Jun '10
TucsonSean

Good.  Now why don't you all run right out and get your Obama stickers.  Have you forgotten what members of his own party have been saying about us?  Did he make any statement condemning them for taking political advantage to benefit themselves and him?  No.  That would have been the one productive thing he could have done, but he did not, because he agrees with taking advantage of this situation.  Just like Clinton, his next speeches will take direct political advantage.

Emily Esfahani Smith, Ed.
TucsonSean: Good.  Now why don't you all run right out and get your Obama stickers.  Have you forgotten what members of his own party have been saying about us?  Did he make any statement condemning them for taking political advantage to benefit themselves and him?· Jan 13 at 5:40am

Give Obama some credit. He did say:

If this tragedy prompts reflection and debate - as it should - let's make sure it's worthy of those we have lost...Let's make sure it's not on the usual plane of politics and point-scoring and pettiness that drifts away in the next news cycle.

Ursula Hennessey

I'm glad it worked for you, George. It was meant to try and soothe wounds, not create them for victims' families. How did your family members feel about the "vibe" of the night?

For me, the start of the memorial, with the cheering and the unprofessionalism (right word?) of the opening speakers, was shockingly inappropriate. It had the feel of a rally, as many have said here, which was deeply troubling for me. Having attended the funeral of my father and mother-in-law several months ago, I actually found it physically painful to watch. My husband watched it in disbelief.

However, I did tune in to Obama. I listened with nervous dread, waiting for him to stick a zinger in there, but he didn't. Thank God. I thought he made it as clear as he could -- without outright embarrassing that police chief guy in the 2nd row -- that pointing fingers and assigning blame was disrespectful to the deceased.

Obama took a big step up in my eyes last night. I will, however, be listening closely to see if he keeps up this approach in coming speeches.


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In