Sean Penn has accused Britain of "colonialism" in the Falklands.

"I know I came in a very sensitive moment in terms of diplomacy between Argentina and the UK over the Malvinas islands. ... "

Exactly what the world needs at a very sensitive moment in terms of diplomacy! Sean Penn! Welcome, embajador! I can only thank with brief thanksgiving whatever Gods may be that he's too busy there to show up here.  

Anyway, I'm comforted to know that at least British military planners do seem to remember something about history. Thatcher was (properly) excoriated for weak signaling prior to the last Falklands crisis. Obviously no one's making that mistake now:

"[Timerman] went on to show a series of photographs of what he claimed were state-of-the-art war ships, planes and a nuclear submarine he said was Vanguard, flagship of the Vanguard fleet which carries Britain's Trident nuclear deterrent.

He also produced aerial shots of military bases and two runways in the Falkland Islands. The foreign minister also claimed that the British defence budget had been cut in every area except the South Atlantic."

Yes, well, right decision. 

Comments:


Douglas
Joined
Mar '11
Douglas

I wish the Cameron government would release an official statement on this: "Sean Penn can go pound sand".

Edited on February 14, 2012 at 6:09pm
Misthiocracy
Joined
Aug '10
Misthiocracy

Maybe he's a little "frustrated" since being dumped by Scarlett Johansson.

James Of England
Joined
Apr '11
James Of England
Gaby Charing: I sat up into the small hours to listen to the House of Commons debate. My recollection is that there was virtual unanimity among MPs in supporting military action. That included the vast majority of Labour MPs. Claire will put me right if I'm mistaken.

Labor party leader Michael Foot supported the launch of the task force, but then objected to its engagement when it got there, condemned and called for an investigation into the sinking of the Belgrano (despite, as a subsequent mild scandal showed, privately believing that it was necessary), fought for greater resort to the UN and international diplomacy rather than the unilateral and direct assertion of sovereignty that Thatcher decided upon, and generally caused trouble, consistently from a pacifist, internationalist, perspective.

Part of this is because Labour was quite heavily focused on purging the communists (Militant Tendency) who were trying to take over the party. Support for fighting fascists was a pretty good shibboleth for that.  Militant itself was split between those who supported the fascists as an enemy of the British bourgeois and those who opposed both sides. Officially, Militant came down in favor of a socialist  federation of Argentina and Britain.

Gaby Charing
Joined
Sep '11
Gaby Charing

James Of England

Gaby Charing: I sat up into the small hours to listen to the House of Commons debate. My recollection is that there was virtual unanimity among MPs in supporting military action. That included the vast majority o

Part of this is because Labour was quite heavily focused on purging the communists (Militant Tendency) who were trying to take over the party. Support for fighting fascists was a pretty good shibboleth for that.  Militant itself was split between those who supported the fascists as an enemy of the British bourgeois and those who opposed both sides. Officially, Militant came down in favor of a socialist  federation of Argentina and Britain. · 30 minutes ago

Thanks, James. Militant were Trotskyists. Michael Foot was a learned fool.

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

Charles Starnes: Berlinski: "Exactly what the world needs at a very sensitive moment in terms of diplomacy! Sean Penn! Welcome,embajador!"

Okay, I've had my coffee, but now I've got the smile on my face that I can move on with the day.  Thank you, Claire!

Honestly, I darn near spit out my coffee. · 6 hours ago

Aw, thanks. I have to confess I just re-read my own words and cracked up laughing, too. It's the total surreal absurdity of these words coming out of someone's mouth, in earnest. 

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

Charles Starnes

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

Glenn the Iconoclast: I'm sure Claire knows more about this than I do, but inMilitary Intelligence Blunders it is the Foreign Office that is identified as being unclear in their signals to the Argentinians rather than Mrs. Thatcher.

[...] Needless to say, if you want to learn more, there's a book  I can recommend .· 6 minutes ago

For goodness sakes!  Someone has to take up the torch!  It's http://www.amazon.com/There-No-Alternative-Margaret-Thatcher/dp/0465002315.  

I recommend it highly: It's a wonderful read.  I'm currently four chapters in and I'm learning a great deal about someone - and a time - I thought I was already very familiar with.  The interviews are fabulous.

Claire, I want to say directly - I love your writing style.  It's authoritative and crisp in just the right way and just so pleasant to read.  I'm enjoying it so much I've now added two of your fiction works to the queue: Lion Eyes and Loose Lips.  Very much looking forward to them. · 5 hours ago

Edited 5 hours ago

Why, I love you, too! Happy Valentine's Day!

Claire Berlinski, Ed.
Gaby Charing: I'm not sure the US was as supportive as it should have been. (Again, Claire will correct me if necessary).

She had to hang up on Reagan when he asked her to accept a settlement. James Rentschler's Falklands Diary is wonderful on this from the American side, by the way. 


Joined
Apr '11
Charles Starnes

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

Charles Starnes

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

Glenn the Iconoclast: I'm sure Claire knows more about this than I do, but inMilitary Intelligence Blunders it is the Foreign Office that is identified as being unclear in their signals to the Argentinians rather than Mrs. Thatcher.

[...] Needless to say, if you want to learn more, there's a book  I can recommend .· 6 minutes ago

For goodness sakes!  Someone has to take up the torch!  It's http://www.amazon.com/There-No-Alternative-Margaret-Thatcher/dp/0465002315. 

Edited 5 hours ago

Why, I love you, too! Happy Valentine's Day! · 15 hours ago

Ha!  I'll take it - better than a signed book!  Happy post Valentine's Day in Turkey.


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading

Start your shopping here!

Help support Ricochet by making your purchases through our Amazon links.

Welcome Visitor!
Join  or  Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Ricochet: The Right People, The Right Tone, The Right Place.  Join today!

Already a Member? Sign In