EJHill · Aug 24, 2011 at 11:51am
Color

A note from my second grader's packet on Meet the Teacher Night, offered without comment:

Dear Families,

With some recent changes in the race/ethnicity definitions outlined by the Federal Government, it has been requested that school districts give families an opportunity to update their race/ethnic categories.

Please note that if no selection is made, school personnel are asked to use their best judgement in determining the race/ethnicity of students.

Fill out one form for each student. Check the boxes below as appropriate and return to your student's school office.

Thank you for your help in this area as we strive to better serve the needs of our students

Part A. Is this student (or are YOU) Hispanic/Latino?

□ The above question is about ethnicity, not race.

Part B. What is the student's (or YOUR) race? Choose one or more...

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

Jimmy Carter
Joined
Jul '10
Jimmy Carter

"Dear Teachers,

If Y'all truly 'strive to better serve the needs of our students' You'd consider all Yer students Americans.

May God Bless America,

Joe Six-Pack."

EJHill
Joined
May '10
EJHill

I was intrigued by the invitation to "update" my son's race - maybe last year he went as a Latino and this year he could be a Native American. Then by third grade he could be white for a couple of years. I never knew you could change it.

Jimmy Carter
Joined
Jul '10
Jimmy Carter

I was too ticked. I missed that.

Excellent point.

DrewInWisconsin
Joined
Aug '11
DrewInWisconsin

Regarding the "updates" -- Perhaps new categories were added in order to better employ identity politics? For example, maybe last year there were three, and this year 13?

Edited on Aug 23, 2011 at 5:45pm
EJHill
Joined
May '10
EJHill
DrewInWisconsin: Perhaps new categories were added in order to better employ identity politics?

I have three in High School. This is the first year they've asked. And only about the elementary school.

katievs
Joined
May '10
katievs

I note the ominous shift away from the parents get to check a box if they want to, to "either you do it or we'll do it for you."

Opting out is not allowed.

katievs
Joined
May '10
katievs

This reminds me of the time we briefly had our oldest daughter in public pre-school in Ohio.  We were given a form to fill out that included a question about our annual household income.  I left it blank, considering it none of the school's business. 

The principal called and said he needed the information, because we might be eligible for federal milk subsidies.  I declined to give it to him and assured him that we would not qualify, and that even if we did qualify, we would prefer to supply our own milk.

He kept pressing.  He was clearly frustrated with my unwillingness to cooperate.

I was so appalled I pulled her out.

Now, nearly 20 years later, we're giving public school another shot with our 3rd grader.  I'm a little scared.


Joined
Jun '11
michael kelley

Jimmy Carter: "Dear Teachers,

If Y'all truly 'strive to better serve the needs of our students' You'd consider all Yer students Americans.

May God Bless America,

Joe Six-Pack." · Aug 23 at 5:37pm

Is there a box where I can check off "Insane, Workaholic, Deluded Irish Catholic?"

If so, we're good.

If not, I think another Civil Rights Bill is in order.

Jimmy Carter
Joined
Jul '10
Jimmy Carter

michael kelley

 

Is there a box where I can check off "Insane, Workaholic, Deluded Irish Catholic?"

If so, we're good.

If not, I think another Civil Rights Bill is in order. · Aug 23 at 6:18pm

Look for:

"Insane-Workaholic-Deluded-Irish-Catholic-American"

Edited on Aug 23, 2011 at 6:26pm
Cas Balicki
Joined
Jun '10
Cas Balicki

The way things are going next year the note will read:

Dear Families,

With some recent changes in the sex/gender definitions outlined by the Federal Government, it has been requested that school districts give families an opportunity to update their sex/gender categories.

Please note that if no selection is made, school personnel are asked to use their best judgement in determining the sex/gender of students.

They could use the TSA to do the research.

Western Chauvinist
Joined
Dec '10
Western Chauvinist

Egads!  Between this and King Prawn's turlit story, I'm guessing we're within a year or two of the end of western civilization.  It was nice while it lasted.

Edited on Aug 23, 2011 at 6:49pm
The King Prawn
Joined
Dec '10
The King Prawn

 It's a simple thing. The schools with higher minority populations get more federal money. It is very important to your local school to count every minority at least once.

On a semi-related note, I'm curious to see what the census statistics for "American" are this go round. I know there was a push to list that as one's race/ethnicity on the census forms. I complied.

katievs
Joined
May '10
katievs

I did too, KP.  "American."

Mark Wilson
Joined
May '10
Mark Wilson
katievs: I did too, KP.  "American." · Aug 23 at 9:51pm

I think up north, "Canadian" is the most popular ethnicity.  Sometimes those Canucks come up with an idea worth emulating.

Mollie Hemingway, Ed.
EJHill: I was intrigued by the invitation to "update" my son's race - maybe last year he went as a Latino and this year he could be a Native American. Then by third grade he could be white for a couple of years. I never knew you could change it. · Aug 23 at 5:40pm

My husband -- as a reporter for his college paper -- changed his race at the University of Oregon. All he had to do was go into the registrar and self-identify as Native American. They did ask him "what tribe?" and he gave a response of whatever came to mind. I forget what the point of the exercise was but at U of O I think there were courses restricted to minorities. Or something like that.

So yes, you most definitely can change your race! At the University of Oregon, at least.

Rob Long

Jimmy Carter: I was too ticked. I missed that.

Excellent point. · Aug 23 at 5:41pm

Me too.

But EJ, you should "update" it to something interesting and rare.  My son is a "Romanov" or "Aztec."

John Walker
Joined
Oct '10
John Walker

Note the delicious doublethink of which the acephalic collectivist mind is capable.  On the one hand, “Race doesn't exist—it is purely a social construct”.  On the other hand, “You will sort yourselves into racial categories or we'll do it for you”.  On the gripping hand….

~Paules
Joined
Jun '10
~Paules

 As long as "race" is just a social construct I'm okay with changing your race from time to time.  Did I just hit on the antidote for this nonsense?

Stuart Creque
Joined
Dec '10
Stuart Creque

 "Please note that if no selection is made, school personnel are asked to use their best judgement in determining the race/ethnicity of students."

Dear Race-Obsessed Bureaucrats:

If I tell you that my student's race/ethnicity is "none of your business," your best judgment had better be to determine that her race/ethnicity is "declines to state."

Very truly yours,

Stuart Creque

Matthew Gilley
Joined
May '10
Matthew Gilley

Is Esperanto a race or just a language?  How about Klingon?


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In