Bill McGurn · Jul 5, 2011 at 7:06am

Speaking of statues of famous Americans, seems there is a dispute over a new statue of the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. The statue is to be dedicated next month in Washington, but there is grumbling that the sculptor is ... Chinese.

Does seem ironic that folks who want to honor a man dedicated to equal rights for all would complain that someone from another minority group would get such a task. For what it's worth, some like it:

King's namesake son, Martin Luther King III, told USA TODAY that Lei has done well.

"I've seen probably 50 sculptures of my dad, and I would say 47 of them are not good reflections — that's not to disparage an artist," King said in an interview last week. "This particular artist — he's done a good job."

For what it's worth, I like it.

MLK

Photo credit: Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial Foundation via epa

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

StickerShock
Joined
Jun '10
StickerShock

 Bill, I disagree.  The sculptor is not an American of Chinese ancestry.  He's Chinese.

While his work is beautiful, I can understand why the selection is controversial.  I can see that many would like an American icon to be memorialized by an American sculptor.   According to the article, an American sculptor worked up several preliminary versions under the agreement that the Chinese sculptor would be only asssisting him.  Sounds like he was dumped from the project unfairly.

jhimmi
Joined
Oct '10
jhimmi

As long as the Chinese sculptor is not personally guilty of some heinous crime (e.g., I don't think Charles Manson's sculpting skills could overcome his past misdeeds), I don't see why the King family's opinion should be overridden.

No affirmative action for American sculptors.

Antiphon
Joined
Feb '11
Antiphon

 Really, the Chinese sculptor was only assisting him? That piece looks awfully...Soviet. http://www.flickr.com/photos/stodmyk/4012556699/


Joined
Dec '10
Steve in Texas (on the border)

Beautiful statue.   Many of these kinds of works of art are paid for by the taxpayer.

In the case of the many truly awful works of art that we taxpayers have paid for:

There must be a market, somewhere in the burgeoning conservative book market, for a coffee table book that shows the offending artwork and gives the cost as well as a bit of a history of who was involved in proposing, commissioning and seeing the project through to it's disastrous completion.    No doubt many of the responsible parties would have a letter D after their name.

My vote is for Mark Steyn to write this coffetable book, he could make it uproariously funny, it could be a series: statues, architecture, or perhaps by city.

James Poulos

It's a great likeness and a fitting pose. But I can't be the only one who thinks those streak lines on the monument's smooth side make MLKJr look a little bit like he's hurtling forward into interstellar space.

Mark Wilson
Joined
May '10
Mark Wilson
James Poulos: It's a great likeness and a fitting pose. But I can't be the only one who thinks those streak lines on the monument's smooth side make MLKJr look a little bit like he's hurtling forward into interstellar space. · Jul 5 at 8:58am

I think MLK is the keynote speaker at this year's Lantern meeting.


Joined
Jan '11
BThompson

I think he looks very pharoahnic, somewhat ironic given his dream of leading his people out of bondage into the promised land.

Not JMR
Joined
Nov '10
Jan-Michael Rives

I think it's perfectly appropriate, considering the subject was an avowed Marxist.

thelonious
Joined
May '11
thelonious

 Is the rock behind MLK symbolic of anything or is just there for aesthetic reasons?


Joined
Nov '10
Elizabeth Dunn

Frankly, who cares? Anyone who has read extensively on the Civil Rights Movement knows that the young college students from SNCC and SCLC were the true facilitators.

John Lewis, Diane Nash, Jim Bevel, operated as quarterbacks and offensive linemen.

Edited on Jul 5, 2011 at 6:05pm

Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In