Claire Berlinski, Ed. · Dec 18, 2010 at 4:27am

We need tie-breaking votes. The five copies of Andy McCarthy's broadside go to the authors of the best five comments on this thread. Right now we have more winners than broadsides.

We also need a deadline for voting, so I'm issuing one. The winners will be announced at midnight tonight. Ah, but which time zone? Midnight, central and mountain. Who says we never acknowledge the flyover states? 

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

Pilgrim
Joined
Jun '10
Pilgrim

Sorry to raise picayune details in an election, but, hey, I'm from Florida -- its not how you vote, its how you count the votes. 

Are a commenter's votes cumulative, rewarding the commenter who may have contributed the best line of argument to the thread, or does the scintillating zinger prevail? (Totally disinterested here, I bought (and read) the broadside)

BTW: A member is not able to "Like" his/her own comment, the button is blocked. 

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

Pilgrim: Sorry to raise picayune details in an election, but, hey, I'm from Florida -- its not how you vote, its how you count the votes. 

Are a commenter's votes cumulative, rewarding the commenter who may have contributed the best line of argument to the thread, or does the scintillating zinger prevail? (Totally disinterested here, I bought (and read) the broadside)

BTW: A member is not able to "Like" his/her own comment, the button is blocked.  · Dec 18 at 4:50am

Oh, wow, I did not know that about the inbuilt anti-cheating mechanism. I guess that tells you I've never tried to show my approval of my own comments. 

I think it's really up to the voter to decide the criteria. I trust the wisdom of Ricochet. 

Cas Balicki
Joined
Jun '10
Cas Balicki

Take heart, Claire, we in the back row like your comments. The only exception being when you're screening off the piano legs in the name of Victorian faux-modesty. Sigh! too bad Albert died so young, imagine what history would have been like if Vicky were, er, how shall I put this, somewhat less frustrated. 

Duane Oyen
Joined
May '10
Duane Oyen

Claire, you must be a liberal.  You issued two deadlines.  It is presently, as I type this with my two fingers, 2:53 Central, 1:53 Mountain.  Look it up.

Pilgrim
Joined
Jun '10
Pilgrim
Duane Oyen: Claire, you must be a liberal.  You issued two deadlines.  It is presently, as I type this with my two fingers, 2:53 Central, 1:53 Mountain.  Look it up. · Dec 18 at 12:53pm

The count will be announced CDT, the recount MDT

Claire Berlinski, Ed.

What's more, I miscalculated the time difference and went backwards, not forwards. 

Stay tuned. I shall announce the winners presently. Sorry about that. 


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In