50493_172553629422449_4445903_n

It is impossible for anyone who is closely watching what's going on in Egypt right now to conclude that there are no significant forces for tolerance and civilization at work in the contemporary Muslim world. The only way you could come to this conclusion is by steadfastly ignoring the news:

“Although 2011 started tragically, I feel it will be a year of eagerly anticipated change, where Egyptians will stand against sectarianism and unite as one,” Father Rafaeil Sarwat of the Mar-Mina church told Ahram Online. The Coptic priest was commenting on the now widespread call by Muslim intellectuals and activists upon Egyptian Muslims at large to flock to Coptic churches across the country to attend Coptic Christmas Eve mass, to show solidarity with the nation's Coptic minority, but also to serve as "human shields" against possible attacks by Islamist militants.

Mohamed Abdel Moniem El-Sawy, founder of El-Sawy Culture Wheel was among the promiment Muslim cultural figures who first floated the bold initiative. ...

While the reasons they cite for doing so may vary, many Egyptian Muslims are rallying around the idea of acting to protect their fellow citizens.

“I know it might not be safe, yet it’s either we live together, or we die together, we are all Egyptians,” Cherine Mohamed, a 50 year old house wife said.

For Youssef, Egyptians should attend regardless of their faith as “we all have Christians as part of our family. I am a Muslim but I’m sure my great grandfather was a Christian.”

Think this is just state propaganda? Look on Facebook for the symbol above. It's everywhere.

Comments:


Stuart Creque
Joined
Dec '10
Stuart Creque
Ross Conatser: You do not often hear about nationalism as a positive force any more, but this seems to be an example where an appeal to nationalism or dare I say patriotism is all for the good. · Jan 6 at 7:09am

Indeed -- that's a reason that the Muslim Brotherhood represents a powerful potential threat.  If ever pan-Islamism truly replaces national, ethnic and tribal identity as the animating force throughout the Islamic world, it will be a very formidable foe.  But so long as Arabs hate Persians and Egyptians think themselves more worthy Arab than Syrians -- never mind the religious dispute between Sunni and Shi'ite and the other Muslim offshoots -- the Muslim world will remain fractured and weak.

Kervinlee
Joined
May '10
Kervinlee

Amid all of the legitimate doubts this is very good news indeed. Pray it starts a trend.

This is more than an act mere "tolerance" (what a silly word that has become) on the part of the Egyptian Muslims. This is courageous defiance against violence. God bless them.

Umbra Fractus
Joined
Nov '10
Charles Lavergne
Douglas Pologe: 1) It will be interesting to see how many people actually follow through and do this.

If they don't I don't think anyone would blame them; following through would, after all, mean literally risking life and limb. That people are willing to even say such a thing in that part of the world is still a huge step in the right direction.

Umbra Fractus
Joined
Nov '10
Charles Lavergne
Stuart Creque For one thing, Egypt has a strong affinity to its pre-Islamic history.  

Interestingly, the Copts actually are a link to pre-Islamic Egypt. While most of the Copts speak Arabic in daily life just like everybody else, the Coptic language used in church services (sort of like Latin used to be in Catholic services) is a surviving relic of language of the Pharaohs. It resembles said language about as closely as French resembles Latin, mind you, but the link remains.

Stuart Creque
Joined
Dec '10
Stuart Creque

Charles Lavergne

Stuart Creque For one thing, Egypt has a strong affinity to its pre-Islamic history.  

Interestingly, the Copts actually are a link to pre-Islamic Egypt. While most of the Copts speak Arabic in daily life just like everybody else, the Coptic language used in church services (sort of like Latin used to be in Catholic services) is a surviving relic of language of the Pharaohs. It resembles said language about as closely as French resembles Latin, mind you, but the link remains. · Jan 6 at 3:36pm

I certainly hope that the Islamic fundamentalists never make good on their threat to destroy the pre-Islamic monuments and temples.  The example of the Bamiyan Buddhas in Afghanistan shows that it's not an empty threat.

Charlie Dameron
Joined
Jul '10
Charlie Dameron

Stuart Creque

Trace Urdan: This is an inspiring story Claire, but I wonder if you read the post by Stuart Creque in the Member Feed which paints a different picture of secular tolerance for Christians. Is this simply the difference between Egypt and Pakistan? · Jan 5 at 10:35pm

Egypt isn't Pakistan.  For one thing, Egypt has a strong affinity to its pre-Islamic history.  For another, Egypt has a tourist industry that gives it an economic incentive to practice tolerance of non-Muslim Western ways.  For a third, Egypt is an Arab country that still has the idea that it should be the leader of the Arab world.

On the other hand, Pakistan has nuclear weapons and missiles with which to deliver them, so there's that. · Jan 5 at 11:05pm

For what it's worth, the NYT has a fantastic piece and video about rising violence against Sufi Muslims in Pakistan. Since Pakistan has a rather small non-Muslim population, moderate Muslims are inevitably the target of extremist violence there.


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading

Start your shopping here!

Help support Ricochet by making your purchases through our Amazon links.

Welcome Visitor!
Join  or  Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Ricochet: The Right People, The Right Tone, The Right Place.  Join today!

Already a Member? Sign In