Tom Paine · Oct 20, 2011 at 6:00am
Best in Show

I'm burnt out on politics for the moment.  So let's go with something a little frothy.

I watch a lot of movies, but I rarely watch comedies, especially recent ones, which seem to rely solely upon sex and multiple iterations of obscenities.

But I do have a few all-time favorite comedies:

#3 The Station Agent, a bittersweet film about a misanthropic dwarf and his two dysfunctional friends.

#2 Dr. Strangelove, Stanley Kubrick's dark cold-war farce, featuring Peter Seller's epic performance in multiple roles.

#1 Best in Show, featuring a brilliant ensemble cast, obviously ad-libbing their way through a story about a dog show. 

These are films I've watched again and again, guffawing heartily, as though each viewing was my first time. 

What are your favorite comedies?

  • Comment Filters
Contributor Comments
Member Comments
Comment Popularity

Comments :

Jimmy Carter
Joined
Jul '10

Re: Comedy

Jimmy Carter

Caddyshack

Doug Kimball
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

Douglas Kimball

 #3.  National Lampoon's Xmas Vacation - an annual event on the holidays at my house

#2  Office Space - not one second is without humor.  Not one.

#1  Big Trouble - Dave Barry's creation, lost in the 9-11 shuffle (scheduled to come out on 9/15 but moved because of issues with bombs, airport security, etc.)

Also, honorable mention includes Groundhog Day with Bill Murray, The End with Burt Reynolds, Idiocracy with Luke Wilson, and the Graduate with Dustin Hoffman.

Edited on Oct 19, 2011 at 4:15pm
thelonious
Joined
May '11

Re: Comedy

thelonious

 Spinal Tap is my all time favorite.  I think I can quote every line from that movie.  If you have ever played in a band or love or even remember heavy metal it's a must watch.   Made by the same people who made Best In Show also a classic. 

The King Prawn
Joined
Dec '10

Re: Comedy

The King Prawn

This may detract from my conservative credentials, but Army of Darkness, Hudson Hawk, and Happy Gilmore.


Joined
Nov '10

Re: Comedy

HalifaxCB

The Horse's Mouth (somewhat different from the book, but just as good), and What About Bob.

thelonious
Joined
May '11

Re: Comedy

thelonious
The King Prawn: This may detract from my conservative credentials, but Army of Darkness, Hudson Hawk, and Happy Gilmore. · Oct 19 at 4:28pm

Army of Darkness is hilarious but was it intended to be a comedy?  Evil Dead is also awesome.   Bruce Campbell forever!!

The King Prawn
Joined
Dec '10

Re: Comedy

The King Prawn

thelonious

The King Prawn: This may detract from my conservative credentials, but Army of Darkness, Hudson Hawk, and Happy Gilmore. · Oct 19 at 4:28pm

Army of Darkness is hilarious but was it intended to be a comedy?  Evil Dead is also awesome.   Bruce Campbell forever!! · Oct 19 at 4:49pm

My understanding is that the original Evil Dead was supposed to be horror but failed tragically at that goal. The second was intentionally funny, and Army of Darkness continued the trend. It may have even spawned a new genre. And, yes, we need an Ash Williams with a boom stick right about now.

Charles Rapp
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

Charles Rapp

A Hard Day's Night: The Beatles showing that they don't take themselves so seriously - at least at first.

The Three Musketeers: The Richard Lester version (who also directed "A Hard Day's Night"). I saw this movie before I read the book. When I did read the book, I discovered it was just as funny as the movie. Richard Lester captured the book beautifully!

Edited on Oct 19, 2011 at 5:50pm
DrewInWisconsin
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

DrewInWisconsin

This will probably destroy both my conservative cred and my man-cred. One of my favorite movies is Peter Bogdonavich's 1972 homage to screwball comedies (specifically Bringing Up Baby), What's Up Doc?

It's hilarious, has a lot of "Hey, it's that guy!" moments (Look! It's Boss Hogg!) and worth watching just for the incredibly witty dialogue. I have seen it enough times that I could probably recite the whole movie. They just don't make 'em like this anymore. 

Yes, yes, it's got Barbra Streisand in a lead role.

I'm sorry.

:: downcast ::

Edited on Oct 19, 2011 at 5:18pm
Charles Rapp
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

Charles Rapp

Best In Show, Caddyshack, National Lampoon's Xmas Vacation, Groundhog Day, Spinal Tap, and What About Bob.

Hmm. Am I sensing a pattern here? Sort of a Second City/SNL pattern?

DrewInWisconsin
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

DrewInWisconsin

Also, I recently discovered Peter Sellers' The Party, and really enjoyed it, although it was a little too strange and/or dated for the lovely Mrs. Drew, and she didn't finish it with me.

katievs
Joined
May '10

Re: Comedy

katievs
DrewInWisconsin: This will probably destroy both my conservative cred and my man-cred. One of my favorite movies is Peter Bogdonavich's 1972 homage to screwball comedies (specifically Bringing Up Baby), What's Up Doc?

I absolutely love What's Up Doc.

Also Tootsie and What About Bob.

I find the first two Lethal Weapons pretty great for both humor and adventure/suspense, though a bit heavy on the R-rated material.

Another one for the whole family: Three Fugitives.

Jimmy Carter
Joined
Jul '10

Re: Comedy

Jimmy Carter

Airplane!

EJHill, back Me up on this one.

Charles Rapp
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

Charles Rapp
Edited on Oct 19, 2011 at 5:50pm
Fredösphere
Joined
May '10

Re: Comedy

Fredösphere

Anybody who ever watched the Westminster dog show, especially in the years of Joe Garagiola's disastrous tenure as color commentator, has to rank Best In Show as one of the great comedies of all time. Fred Willard's spoof of Garagiola is awe-inspiring.

Tom Paine
Joined
Aug '11

Re: Comedy

Tom Paine
Fredösphere: Anybody who ever watched the Westminster dog show, especially in the years of Joe Garagiola's disastrous tenure as color commentator, has to rank Best In Show as one of the great comedies of all time. Fred Willard's spoof of Garagiola is awe-inspiring. · Oct 19 at 6:08pm

Fred Willard is a comedy genius.  And the Brit actor who acted as his foil in Best in Show was superb.

Drew Hankins
Joined
Oct '11

Re: Comedy

Drew Hankins

Trading Places, The Blues Brothers and The Producers...the real one with Zero Mostel.

katievs
Joined
May '10

Re: Comedy

katievs

Getting ready for our daughter's wedding last June, my husband and I got some welcome comic relief watching Father of the Bride--both the Spencer Tracy and Steve Martin versions.  They're both funny and sweet.

Speaking of Spencer Tracy reminds me of Katherine Hepburn, which reminds me of African Queen.

jetstream
Joined
Dec '10

Re: Comedy

jetstream

katievs

DrewInWisconsin: This will probably destroy both my conservative cred and my man-cred. One of my favorite movies is Peter Bogdonavich's 1972 homage to screwball comedies (specifically Bringing Up Baby), What's Up Doc?

I absolutely love What's Up Doc.

Also Tootsie and What About Bob.

I find the first two Lethal Weapons pretty great for both humor and adventure/suspense, though a bit heavy on the R-rated material.

Another one for the whole family: Three Fugitives. · Oct 19 at 5:30pm

What About Bob was a total hoot.  Most of us have known a Bob or two.

Fredösphere
Joined
May '10

Re: Comedy

Fredösphere

Tom Paine

Fredösphere: Anybody who ever watched the Westminster dog show, especially in the years of Joe Garagiola's disastrous tenure as color commentator, has to rank Best In Show as one of the great comedies of all time. Fred Willard's spoof of Garagiola is awe-inspiring. · Oct 19 at 6:08pm

Fred Willard is a comedy genius.  And the Brit actor who acted as his foil in Best in Show was superb. · Oct 19 at 6:16pm

He's the one actor I've actually come close to permanently injuring myself while watching.


Would you like to comment on this Conversation?

Become a Member for $3.67 a month.

Join the Conversation
Already a member? Sign In
Loading
Welcome Visitor

Already a Member?
Please Sign In

Become a Member to enjoy the full benefits of Ricochet:

Join Ricochet today!

Already a Member? Sign In